5 ms·
I think NASA should capture an asteroid and place it into a stable Lagrange point. The mass of the asteroid could provide resources, radiation shielding, and ad
by stcredzero 11y ago
I think NASA should capture an asteroid and place it into a stable Lagrange point. The mass of the asteroid could provide resources, radiation shielding, and additional gravitational stability for other facilities/assets at the same Lagrange point.
If suitable engineering is done, stations could undock from the radiation shield and updated stations docked in place, so the investment in delta-v and materiel could be preserved.
- orik 11y agowhy not the moon?
- ch4s3 11y agoLEO is an orbit around Earth with an altitude between 160 kilometers (99 mi), and 2,000 kilometers (1,200 mi) The moon is on average 384,400 kilometers (238,900 miles) away. The Moon(ish) is where NASA is headed, LEO is what they're leaving behind.
- stcredzero 11y agowhy not the moon? The L2 Lagrange point is "behind" the moon.
- stephengillie 11y agoWhy not halfway between us and the moon? It could be an easy-to-reach halfway point for the Moon, a refueling station and very-low-g launchpad other points, internet relay base, and also have commercial, industrial, and housing areas. This could be an interesting new step in human modification of the environment - "orbitforming" (like terraforming?) a better solar system. It's like razing a hill to make way for farmland or better city building conditions. An asteroid that's easy for vacationing billionaires, mining companies, and highly-pollutant industry to reach would be a great next step for humankind.
- mcguire 11y agoDon't be silly. Shoving around a mountain is laughably beyond NASA's capabilities. Moving the moon would be ridiculous.
- pmoriarty 11y agoThose with the power to capture and steer asteroids also have the power to direct them at targets on Earth.
- deegles 11y agoThose people would likely also have access to nuclear weapons, what's your point?
- colordrops 11y agoI don't know what the grandparent's point was, but I believe that kinetic weapons are exempt from space weapons treaties, hence the "Rods from God" satellite designs.
- evanriley 11y agoI'm sure if someone wanted to destroy the earth, there are far more manageable ways to do that.
- Estragon 11y agoYeah, you could just pump CO2 into the atmosphere for a couple of centuries until greenhouse effects make it uninhabitable.
- mturmon 11y agoProfessor Moriarty, is it you? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dynamics_of_an_Asteroid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dynamics_of_an_Asteroid)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI know little of space physics, but wouldn't the additional gravity of an asteroid disrupt tidal patterns on earth?
- Pinckney 11y agoNo. Any asteroid we could reasonably capture is much too small to have any significant impact.
- nerfhammer 11y agoWhat if we mess it up and it comes tumbling toward earth?
- personjerry 11y agoThis is the sort of thing we would verify the calculations of, many times, and consider problems ahead of time.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 8note 11y agoit would likely burn up on entry
- InclinedPlane 11y agoWe lack the ability to move a large enough asteroid to do any serious damage.
- Pinckney 11y agoNot yet, but perhaps in the near future. The National Space Society has a proposal up for capturing 99942 Apophis via gravitational slingshot, which would be fairly damaging if we managed to crash it.
- akira2501 11y agoLagrange orbits aren't that great in the long run, and come with their own unique set of challenges (from en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lagrangian_point#Mathematical_details): "Although the L1, L2, and L3 points are nominally unstable, it turns out that it is possible to find (unstable) periodic orbits around these points, at least in the restricted three-body problem. These periodic orbits, referred to as "halo" orbits, do not exist in a full n-body dynamical system such as the Solar System. However, quasi-periodic (i.e. bounded but not precisely repeating) orbits following Lissajous-curve trajectories do exist in the n-body system. These quasi-periodic Lissajous orbits are what most of Lagrangian-point missions to date have used. Although they are not perfectly stable, a relatively modest effort at station keeping can allow a spacecraft to stay in a desired Lissajous orbit for an extended period of time. It also turns out that, at least in the case of Sun–Earth-L1 missions, it is actually preferable to place the spacecraft in a large-amplitude (100,000–200,000 km or 62,000–124,000 mi) Lissajous orbit, instead of having it sit at the Lagrangian point, because this keeps the spacecraft off the direct line between Sun and Earth, thereby reducing the impact of solar interference on Earth–spacecraft communications. Similarly, a large-amplitude Lissajous orbit around L2 can keep a probe out of Earth's shadow and therefore ensures a better illumination of its solar panels."
- adevine 11y agoYour quote, though, is talking about L1, L2 and L3, which are the unstable Lagrangian points. Parent was talking about L4 and L5, the stable points.
- akira2501 11y agoEarth-Moon L4 and L5 is still very unstable due to the Sun (and other planets). Earth-Sun L4 and L5 is more stable, but almost useless as a waypoint; however there are already naturally captured asteroids (and a lot of dust) already there. All orbits require station keeping in a dynamic solar system that is circling around a black hole.
- lxmorj 11y agoIf the asteroid has any water, station keeping won't require external fuel. If it doesn't, mass drivers could be used to toss chunks of the asteroid off and correct for instability (though that might create space debris if the velocity isn't enough).
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoBy shielding, do you mean that astronauts could live inside or behind the asteroid, just using its mass between them and the sun? That would be pretty dark and cold. As far as I know, no asteroids have major magnetic fields. I am totally with you on using the asteroids for materials, but I am not sure that they would provide useful gravity either. Even one of the largest near-earth asteroids, 433 Eros, only has a surface gravity of 0.0059 m/s^2. Is that useful?
- stcredzero 11y agoBy shielding, do you mean that astronauts could live inside or behind the asteroid, just using its mass between them and the sun? I mean that the habitable modules would be located inside silos embedded within the asteroid, so that the living space would be entirely surrounded by radiation shielding mass. That would be pretty dark and cold. The problem in space is generally getting rid of heat. Vacuum is a great insulator, insulation material is effective and relatively cheap, and radiative cooling is fairly slow. The other thermal problem is exposure to direct sunlight. The asteroid as a shell of massive shielding would help in this regard.
- robbiep 11y agoSEVENEVES
- mirimir 11y agoWell, that was a big chunk of ice (comet core) and they stuck a bare fission reactor core in it to make a steam rocket. And they had robot swarms to mine/shape ice. It's a very cool book, though!
- InclinedPlane 11y agoDo you not remember the asteroid that was attached to the station from the beginning of the story onward?
- mirimir 11y agoDoh! But he didn't say how they moved that.
- mcguire 11y agoThe largest thing NASA has moved above low earth orbit since the early '70s is, what, Galileo? How many orders of magnitude are there between G and your asteroid?
- ethbro 11y agoTo paraphrase Shawshank Redemption, "That's all it takes really, pressure, and time." With enough time, and high enough specific impulse/in place fuel extraction, you can move anything.
- celias 11y agoCassini was launched in 1997 and weighed over two and a half times what Galileo did (5712kg vs 2223kg). Still several orders of magnitude less than an asteroid.