3 ms·
> I don't remember being "trained" I see. Do you remember being potty trained? Do you remember being trained on what things and behaviors are masculine and fe
by wpietri 11y ago
> I don't remember being "trained"
I see.
Do you remember being potty trained? Do you remember being trained on what things and behaviors are masculine and feminine? Because you were trained, and if you spend time around toddlers you can see them being trained on both.
You were also trained in the use of tens of thousands of words. Do you remember being trained on each one of them? I sure don't. Do you remember being trained on how to avoid collision on the sidewalk? On how to use a fork? On how to use your fingers to put things in your mouth?
Your memory of being trained on something isn't a good indicator of whether you were trained on it. A relatively small amount of what society trains people on is explicit, formal, and sufficient to cause episodic memory formation. Most of our learning is implicit.
> And I don't remember my wife being "trained"
Were you married when she was 2? Gender role training starts at least that early.
Regardless, if you look you can read plenty of actual stories from adult women on how they have been trained to deal with it, and how they're still being trained in that by being punished for breaking from it.
Clementine Ford has experienced exactly that kind of training, so if you wanted to learn something, you could start with her articles. Other good sources are Everyday Sexism, Project Unbreakable, or the autobiography of pretty much any pioneering woman. Madeleine Albright talks explicitly about this and how rising through the man's world of diplomacy forced her to cast off her training and adopt loud and space-demanding behaviors just to be heard.
- csorrell 11y agoI find this attitude pretty condescending. A broad gender statement like "boys are trained to be loud and space demanding" isn't honest in representing all boys.
- wpietri 11y agoNo broad statement about X represents all X. That's what a broad statement means. Note that your reply here is basically "not all men!" A response that has been examined and found deeply lacking: https://www.google.com/search?q=not+all+men https://www.google.com/search?q=not+all+men
- x0x0 11y agoNo no -- one counterexample out of the approx 154M men in the United States disproves that point. Logic!
- wpietri 11y ago> I find this attitude pretty condescending. That's fair. When somebody leaps into a discussion without understanding the basics and acting in a way that is basically ignorant denial, I am ok with condescending to them. The discussion of gender bias and gender equity is a rich and complicated subject. Here on HN, people are generally expected to know something before they open their mouths. I think my condescension here is about 1% of what somebody would get if they were ignorant about language design and still offering similarly bold opinions on languages that they've never used.
- zaccus 11y agoYou don't know what you're talking about either though.
- wpietri 11y agoDo tell.
- chippy 11y agoDoes anyone else encounter the situation where, when confronted with a challenge to certain ideas, the response sounds like the following: "look it up in the literature" or "you don't understand the basics and therefore you are ignorant"? I have noticed this in particular to do with this ideology of gender etc. It appears to me that this implies that these ideas are beliefs that rely on faith in the belief and that challenging the belief is considered a sign of ignorance at best and a conscious attack at worst. It seems to me that all a questioner need to do is educate themselves in the correct literature and there would be no need to question anymore. To challenge the belief of faith creates incomprehensibility in the holder of the beliefs as it implies that the belief is not certain and can be open to challenge. Thus the most common reply to a question about the certainty of the beliefs is a urgent request to educate themselves.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago