4 ms·
I'm always suspicious of Etruscan finds. Some original 'tombs' were empty when first recorded, then mysteriously full of artifacts decades later. Something fish
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
I'm always suspicious of Etruscan finds. Some original 'tombs' were empty when first recorded, then mysteriously full of artifacts decades later. Something fishy going on.
And the finds are always so 'pat'. The museum I visited had amphorae with amusing graffiti, toys and knickknacks, even a 'pencil cup' with the Etruscan and Greek alphabets written around the top. So convenient! So that everything else could be instantly translated, this 'Rosetta stone' was included no extra charge.
And now a complete tomb found, with just the right sort of cool stuff to get the tourists coming back for another 10 years. Ok.
- euyyn 11y agoSo your theory is there was no such thing as an Etruscan people?
- harlanlewis 11y agoThis is the first I've heard of counterfeit Etruscan sites, but it's not entirely dismissable. Early archaeology was a mix of wholesale grave looting and falsifying finds to generate interest in the site and give glory to the discoverer. Egyptian mummies floating around Europe during "Egyptomania" (after Napolean's visit) were often much, MUCH younger than ancient Egypt. It seems unlikely to me that any modern sites are actually digging up planted relics, but inflating the finds at tourist sites by importing from one site to another, or creating replicas to make up for assumed grave robbery? Almost harder to believe that doesn't happen.
- euyyn 11y agoGoing to the length of making up a language, as that guy suggests?