3 ms·
I'm a bit perplexed by his issue with the realism of futures in which we wear mini-dresses and three-piece suits, drive gas-burning automobiles (or hovercars: i
by notahacker 11y ago
I'm a bit perplexed by his issue with the realism of
futures in which we wear mini-dresses and three-piece suits, drive gas-burning automobiles (or hovercars: it's just a rabbit/smeerp replacement), carry handguns (or blasters: see rabbit/smeerp), eat the kind of food we eat today, live the kind of way we live today, and most importantly think the way we think today.
Especially after an article attacking space opera tropes.
Frankly, if the sci-fi of half a century ago had assumed that a decade or two into the next millennium we'd live in neat little houses on suburban Earth, don suits to go to work in our (non-flying) car, eat hamburgers and worry more about humans in other countries than alien empires it would have been absolutely right.
- DanBC 11y ago> it would have been absolutely right. Science fiction is not future prediction.
- jhbadger 11y agoWell, 1950s SF did have a bit of trouble imagining the social changes that did actually occur. Even when they tried to be progressive by having a woman scientist or something they always made it seem strange like "I'm looking for Doctor Smith" "I'm Doctor Smith".
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y ago> had assumed that a decade or two into the next millennium we'd live in neat little houses on suburban Earth, don suits to go to work in our (non-flying) car But this is changing, it's not the 1950s any more. By a fifth of the way through the 21st century, it's quite common that 1) The business attire is often jeans and t-shirt 2) Women go to work almost as much as men 3) The couple in the "neat little houses" may not be married. Or may be the same gender and married. Or there may just be 1 person there. 4) Smoking is very uncommon 5) The work is sometimes from home, or your job might be moving to somewhere cheaper like a call-center in India or a factory in China. 7) The local mall is struggling due to online shopping. 8) people don't pre-plan their social engagements like they used to - they're always in contact with their friends so the era of "I'll meet you in the cinema lobby at 8" (or bust) is over. In fact the cinema might be netflix and chill at home. 9) The car might soon be self-driving. These changes add up over time. This movie from 1981, supposedly set on Jupiter's moon Io in the late 21st century, has scenes that look very looks outdated to me, particularly a room full of men smoking: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0082869/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0082869/
- notahacker 11y agoThe point isn't "the world is exactly the same as the 1960s", the point is that the world is much more similar to that of the 1960s than the early 2000s depicted in any scifi from that period, especially the scifi written on the premise that the idea that anyone in half a century's time would still work in an office and drive a gasoline powered car was desperately unimaginative. I'm sure there's a lot of subtle-but-significant ways in which society will have changed by 2065 too (whether influenced by scientific advances or not), but I'm not convinced that they'll find the idea of characters set in their time period eating hamburgers nearly as unlikely or amusing as some of the things we might invent in their place.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoOh sure, people around 1950-70 looked at the pace of change over the last 100 years: from horse and cart and gas lamps to electricity, intercontinental jets and moon landings and projected in on linearly to moon and Mars colonies in the next 50 years. And then ... that progression clearly wasn't linear, it peaked and slowed down after then. But change hasn't stopped though. It could speed up again. Even if it doesn't, those Mars colonies and robot asteroid mines are not ruled out just delayed - they are back on some people's long-term plans now.