5 ms·
I work professionally with audio to some extent, and I can hear the difference between 320 and wav in some cases (on my own home setup, of course) — but if a la
by golergka 11y ago
I work professionally with audio to some extent, and I can hear the difference between 320 and wav in some cases (on my own home setup, of course) — but if a layperson asks, I'd advice them to buy Beats instead of professional monitor headphones which have better sound quality for less money. It's simple: if you can't tell the difference between 192 and 256, and are going to listen to Spotify stream anyway, it makes more sense to invest more into the appearance than in sound.
- Oletros 11y ago> It's simple: if you can't tell the difference between 192 and 256, and are going to listen to Spotify stream anyway, it makes more sense to invest more into the appearance than in sound. I'm unable to understand this kind of logic
- coldtea 11y agoIt's simple: a) Good headphones only bring marginally better sound over mediocre ones for most of the source material and format people hear (not to mention if you listen to pop hits, they're often mastered to sound good to mediocre headphones in the first place). b) Appearance matters. Being trendy and following fashion is good for your social life (yeah, other people are often that shallow: don't fight it, hack it to your benefit). c) For most people their social life is way more important than something like better frequency response. So optimize what's actually important to you, not what should be important in theory. Heck, I'm a heavy DAW user and I have AKG and AT monitor-grade headphones, but I'm still tempted to get a pair of Beats, a) to hear mixes through a headphone "in vogue" producers of pop/hip-hop/r&b optimize for, b) for the fashion part. (And no, "everybody has one" doesn't diminish the fashion factor, except to fashion snubs people who you'd want to avoid anyway. Fashion works better when you conform -- to put it another away, nobody was seen in a bad light wearing Nike because "tons of other people have Nikes").
- widdershins 11y agoIn my opinion bad headphones will have a bigger impact on the sound than the difference between a 192 and 320 mp3. Sure, on a 192 a practiced listener might be able to discern compression in things like cymbal washes, but bad headphones can wreck the whole balance of a track by boosting bass to ridiculous levels etc.
- falcolas 11y ago> Good headphones only bring marginally better sound over mediocre ones for most of the source material and format people hear I have to disagree here. Perhaps it's just me, but when I listen to my music downloaded from iTunes over crappy headphones, then over my good headphones, there is a tremendous difference. I can hear synth beats, quiet drum hits, vocal inflections, and guitar riffs on the good headphones which are lost to the muddled and over-driven bass in bad headphones. And this is with recent music by Taylor Swift, Adelle, and Avicci. > Appearance matters. Thankfully, companies like Sennheiser have started to make tremendous leaps in these qualities. Of course, they're starting to drive up their prices as well, so that's a bit of a backslide... > So optimize what's actually important to you Agreed. Though it wouldn't hurt to expose folks to more good sounding headphones, so they can make a decision on actual data. If I didn't have headroom in my home town, I wouldn't know what truly good headphones would sound like; my experience would have been limited to Boise and Beats.
- Oletros 11y agoSo, it is better to recommend buying overpriced shit over cheaper good quality because you think they will serve better. I wouldn't call friend someone that recommends me something like that
- golergka 11y agoHow do you define "quality"? Why do you automatically assume that the most important thing about headphones is sound quality for everyone?
- Oletros 11y agoI repeat, you're the one assuming that for other people is more important look than price or quality. Why do you automatically assume that the most important thing about headphones is "look" for everyone?
- golergka 11y agoI don't assume — may be I didn't state this in the most correct way. I ask the person about his listening habits and fashion sense when giving advice, of course. Often, brands like SkullCandy or UrbanEars are aesthetically closer to a person's style; Beats is just a good illustration of a principle.
- detaro 11y agoThe difference between different headphones is often easier to tell than the difference between different file formats/encodings. Also, if you care about the social signals, don't buy Beats if you don't want to look like someone with more money than sense ;) (Mileage obviously may vary between environments, but it seems like the one things most people know about headphones is "Beats aren't good for the price", even if they never really looked at the topic in detail)
- irremediable 11y agoHow do Beats compare to e.g. the cheapest Sennheiser cans? My go-to headphones are the HD201, which you can get for about $30. They're the best headphones/earphones I've ever used, but I'm no audiophile, as you can tell from that fact.
- noir_lord 11y agoLove the 201, so much in fact I bought 202's and 205's for different places and actually liked the 201's better, all sounded the same to me and the 201's are so comfy particularly compared to the 203's.
- golergka 11y agoHow do you compare? Beats look a lot better, for once.
- falcolas 11y agoI disagree - I think the Sennheiser HD201 cans look pretty decent. Now granted, they don't have the Beats logo on them, but they do have the Sennheiser logo. Even better, they sound good too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- irremediable 11y agoI guess you give statements like that, but for several aspects, e.g. audio quality, durability, etc?
- dharma1 11y agoI struggle to hear a difference between 320 and wav, doubt I would get it right in a blindfold test. It's more of a psychological thing for me - prefer to listen to FLAC (or vinyl/cd) because I know it's "all there" :) I have a pretty good monitoring environment and headphones. What cues do you listen to to differentiate 320?
- golergka 11y agoSharp 20 kHz LPF that is present in almost all lossy codecs. The 20+ kHz gives you the certain feeling of "air", but doesn't actually affect the music quality in the meaningful way.
- mkj 11y agoAt least if you're sitting at a computer it seems worth getting a better DAC before crazy-pricey headphones. I was quite surprised how much for example http://hifimediy.com/sabre-dac-uae23 http://hifimediy.com/sabre-dac-uae23 improved sound over Intel/Dell motherboard output.
- 4ad 11y agoUnfortunately many PC motherboards ship with really poor DACs. If you use an iPhone, or an iMac, don't bother though. Their DAC are truly excellent. The only reason to upgrade would be if you have high-impedance headphones, or low-sensitivity headphones that require a more drive than these DACs can produce. Note though that the iMac DAC has higher output that most cheap external DACs, so chose accordingly. This is the only reason to get a different DAC. These DACs have lower output impedance than most DACs under $500. Edit: http://www.kenrockwell.com/apple/iphone-5/audio-quality.htm http://www.kenrockwell.com/apple/iphone-5/audio-quality.htm
- mkj 11y agoI tried that one I linked above on my macbook pro retina (2013?) and it seems _slightly_ better. Nowhere near the difference to my work Dell though. Guess laptop parts are more constrained too.
- qb45 11y agoYour link deals only with iPhone. I'm pretty sure that Apple's x86 systems use the same HD Audio codecs everybody else is using. They may or may not have better analog output amps (if they have any, but iirc at least some laptops have such) but as for using better DACs - links or it didn't happen.
- voltagex_ 11y agoI can't justify that kind of outlay. I've managed to strike a decent balance between price and quality - Sennheiser PX 100 [1] for foldable headphones (not suitable for office use as they leak a lot of sound) or Audiotechnica ANC33is [2] for noise-cancelling & office use 1: http://en-au.sennheiser.com/stereo-headphones-travel-lightweigt-px-100-ii http://en-au.sennheiser.com/stereo-headphones-travel-lightwe... 2: http://eu.audio-technica.com/en/products/product.asp?catID=5&subID=36&prodID=4391 http://eu.audio-technica.com/en/products/product.asp?catID=5...
- golergka 11y agoHow do you define "quality"? Do you automatically assume that sound quality is the most important component of headphone quality, for everyone? Why?
- voltagex_ 11y agoThey're well built, reasonably sturdy (although I've crushed the AudioTechnica ones accidentally) relatively affordable and replacement (parts/products) are available easily. And they sound good.
- golergka 11y agoThanks for that information. But it would be nice if you answered my question. How do you define headphone quality? Do you think that this definition is the same for everyone?
- voltagex_ 11y agoOf course not - that's why I listed some criteria that I use to judge the subjective quality of headphones. If fashion is important to you, you might choose differently.
- 4ad 11y agoThis advice makes no sense. Beats headphones are poor headphones at their price range. You can get cheaper headphones which are far better, in fact you can get really, really cheap headphones which are better. So why buy beats? The appearance argument is ridiculous, you can get cheaper, better headphones, that look (and are built) better. Beats don't excel at anything, they just make you look like a fool. I guess that's a feature!
- eertami 11y ago>and are going to listen to Spotify stream anyway But... Spotify streams at 320kbps (Vorbis), which is WAY more than enough until you start spending $500+ on your setup. Why is that even relevant?
- usrusr 11y agoI tend to disagree: the occlusion predictions of the encoder should usually be more accurate when the decided signal it's played through a high quality output chain than when played through a chain that does all kinds of intentional and unintentional signal mangling post-codec. This surely does not rule out the possibility that certain classes of compression artifacts are lost only on low end headphones, but I really would not give compressed sources a free pass on wonky headphones. If you listen to compressed audio, you don't want post-codec inaccuracies.