2 ms·
Any time the subject of democracy or voting comes up, I like to post this old link that I found in someone else's HN comment long ago: http://zesty.ca/voting/si
by nitrogen 11y ago
Any time the subject of democracy or voting comes up, I like to post this old link that I found in someone else's HN comment long ago: http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/
It shows how different voting systems behave in different multi-candidate scenarios where candidates differ on more than one axis (as they always do, a fact which is not represented by our linear left/right political narrative). A better voting system would do more for democracy than better districting.
- eru 11y agoGreat page! Alas, it doesn't seem to be taking strategic voting into account. (Strategic voting destroys Borda Count somewhat, but if anything improves Approval voting from where it stands in the simulation.)
- smoyer 11y agoUnfortunately, there's often no one I'm interested in voting for on the ballot. How do I vote then? Should I vote at all? I don't think I'm an outlier as more and more people aligned with both parties feel disenfranchised, but you don't stand a chance at having a reasonable candidate for most races with the amount of money required to mount a campaign. If you can't get media attention, you're out!
- nitrogen 11y agoApproval voting would make it safer and easier to run more candidates, as you wouldn't have the vote splitting problem. It does have the problem that running 10 similar candidates makes their viewpoint more likely to win, if I recall correctly, so a party-based system might still be useful in that case.