4 ms·
The title seems rather meaningless. Saying 71% of 'top colleges' where 'top colleges' has a rather fluid definition doesn't say very much. <anal_retentive> Yo
by pyre 17y ago
The title seems rather meaningless. Saying 71% of 'top colleges' where 'top colleges' has a rather fluid definition doesn't say very much.
<anal_retentive>
You should probably refer to them as 'universities' since from my experience people outside the US (specifically Canada, but I understand Australians and Europeans are the same) understand 'college' to refer to what Americans view as the 'community college.' When you say college they wouldn't understand you to be including MIT, CalTech, UCLA, etc under that term.
</anal_retentive>
- hga 17y agoYou have a point, but I suspect the tier of colleges below "the top" are just as bad if not worse. So the statement is probably fundamentally true.
- JacobAldridge 17y agoIt's a fair point (too late for me to change it) although as an Aussie I did understand what it meant. I felt the original title ("PC Never Died") was either vague or misleading, so went with a paraphrased quote from within the article ("71 percent of the 375 top colleges still have policies that severely restrict speech") that I thought summed up the content and relevance to HN.
- pyre 17y agoNo worries. The entire comment is a little anal (the last part being even moreso).
- ramchip 17y agoI think any Canadian with sufficient exposure to the Internet will get it, but here in Quebec we don't really use the words 'college' or 'community college'. I remember being a bit confused about its meaning at first.
- pyre 17y agoI've come across people that were mildly confused. Even with non-trivial amounts of exposure to American language-isms/culture it's still possible to over-look the nuances. There are probably a lot of instances where the context doesn't allow the listener to make the distinction between whether the 'Canadian definition' or 'American definition' of the term is being used (unless you're really paying attention for that sort of thing; like if someone told you to pay attention to it).
- manbearpig 17y agoYeah but this is an article about American colleges, and Americans don't read 'college' as 'community college'. College = undergrad. If people from outside the US don't understand this, then here is a chance to learn the vernacular.
- netcan 17y agoActually, in Australia, "College" is used in a few different ways, I think varying by state. Where I went to Uni, college was where you lived. This has been now changed to "residential hall" though it is still referred to colloquially as college. In some states, College means the final two years of school (16-18 yr olds). Since I graduated (3 years ago), my old university has substituted "college" for what used to be called "Faculty." I think previously they still used it as an alternative organizational structure (Faculty of Arts vs College of Fine Arts). Today it seems that The University is now divided into colleges divided into colleges, divided into faculties & schools divided into departments, more or less. Basically, the term is a moving target down here. Anyway, we know what americans mean because all of that wonderful TV that seems to be the number one Yankie export. What I don't understand is the term "community college," other then the fact that is not as good. I'm not sure we have an equivalent. We have crap Universities, obviously, but it's a scale rather then a different creature altogether. Apart from Universities there are TAFEs. These are pretty much "everything else" from 1 week OHS courses to multi-year diplomas similar to University courses, training for 15 year old apprentices and professional training for every class of profession. They are not bound to any particular format.