6 ms·
Voice Quality on Smart Phones Still Sucks (2014)
- oomkiller 11y agoVoLTE is becoming fairly prevalent now. With the new wideband codecs, quality can be quite good.
- sbierwagen 11y ago(VoLTE is branded as HD Voice for many phones.)
- feld 11y agoThe problem is that there is no cross-carrier HD voice or VoLTE. If you call someone on another carrier your call quality will be flushed down the toilet. These idiots refuse to inter-operate. This is why data calling (Facetime audio, Google Hangouts(?), Skype, Whatsapp, etc) is going to crush the cellular industry. It's going to be fragmented and ugly, but at least the call quality won't suck.
- smackfu 11y agoIt seems like if you are calling another network, your network should be able to terminate your HD voice call at the edge, and you would still get at least wired telephone quality.
- feld 11y agoThat's what you get, and it's bad. It's so bad these days I can't stand talking on the phone to anyone who isn't using data (facetime, etc) or HD Voice. I literally cannot understand what people are saying half the time. And company support phone numbers? The worst. Their callcenters are using terrible voip with overloaded trunks. It feels like we've spent the last 10 years trying to kill the phone call.
- Aloha 11y agoI don't think the carriers would want to, a traditional voice call is 'less expensive' than a HD Voice call.
- swiley 11y agoCellular carriers at this point are really just low traffic ISPs anyway.
- guelo 11y agoNone of those IP voice services interoperate either, it's the same issue just at another layer with a different set of greedy corporations.
- hueving 11y agoTrue, but it's easy to switch between these upper-level services. It's a pain to change cell providers (in the US).
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> It's a pain to change cell providers (in the US). What!? You can port your number from one carrier to another with ease, for several years now.
- droopybuns 11y ago>>These idiots refuse to inter-operate. Not true. There is tremendous effort in place trying to get IMS roaming/interop working. http://www.gsma.com/newsroom/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/IR.65-v12.0.pdf http://www.gsma.com/newsroom/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/IR.6... The problem isn't idiots refusing to interoperate, it's that the standards are implemented in subtly different ways between operators. So if you're on an AT&T or VZW network making calls to a Sprint person, you have 5 dependencies in play: 1) IMS compatible home network w/ HD voice codec support 2) HD Voice compatible home device 3) IMS compatible destination network w/ HD voice codec support 4) Interop agreement between carriers. 5) HD Voice compatible destination device. Device churn is just as big a hurdle as the non-trivial network compatibility problem.
- zw123456 11y agoExactly. The only realistic way to do it in the short term I think is to have everything fall back to G.711 but they you still end up with multiple codecs which is not idea.
- LogicX 11y agoAlso you can configure your verizon phone to use voLTE and then google voice supports it, so you can get some voLTE benefits (like using data while on the phone) and voLTE to carriers verizon doesn't yet partner with for voLTE
- jfountain2015 11y agoCell quality of GSM/CDMA or others isn't good but the article ignores all the Wi-fi calling, FaceTime Audio and VOIP type calls you can make on a smart phone now. I've found that those are substantially better quality than any landline or cell.
- kalleboo 11y agoAlso since the article has written, VoLTE has launched on many networks which is a huge improvement
- jobu 11y agoYeah, consumer reports is blaming the cell phones for poor voice quality, but it really seems to be the phone companies. In a previous job most of my team worked out of Bulgaria, and I could hear them better over Skype on my iPhone than I could hear my wife on a regular phone call. Headphones helped the sound quality even more, but it really wasn't necessary.
- eco 11y agoMy brother accidentally called me with Hangouts the other day and the quality was just shockingly better. I've started using it instead of a regular call where it makes sense (i.e. the other person is on hangouts+wifi too, essentially. I don't want to use up their data plan for it).
- pak 11y agoIf you want to know the real reason for this, it's because normal cell calls still have to go over POTS (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plain_old_telephone_service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plain_old_telephone_service) on the backend, which typically uses 8-bit mu-law companding of audio at 8kHz. This compresses the typical frequency range for phone calls to 300-3000Hz, which is a lot smaller than the real range of human hearing, although it covers the range used by human speech so it was considered totally acceptable before unreliable wireless packeting became the typical last leg. VoIP, FaceTime, Skype and other IP-only technologies can use much better audio codecs, going all the way up to CD quality audio (44kHz, 16bit). This makes a huge difference when there is background noise and clipping and less than optimal transmission conditions. (Source: I used to work for an IVR company.)
- ChuckMcM 11y agoSo this was from last year it seems. These days there is "HD Voice" on voice calls on t-mobile. Sounds quite good to my, nominal, ears.
- snuxoll 11y agoCall quality on any device I've owned with T-Mobile for the past two years since I switched from AT&T has been great, more carriers need to get off their butts and upgrade to HD Voice.
- smackfu 11y agoWe have AT&T HD Voice here, it's very impressive if you manage to have two people on new iPhones (6 or better).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- s_q_b 11y agoThe app that I want for my phone is phone.
- droopybuns 11y agoI've been starting to get HD voice calls when I get a hold of someone with a compatible device. The clarity is so improved that we don't end up talking about anything but how good the call sounds.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe wideband "hd audio" codec was developed by telecom people in the 70s. The problem with mobile is that the vocoder is trying to cope with a channel having 99% packet loss and latency variance 10x over the mean. The width of the passband is the least of voice's problems. The solution to mobile voice's problem is for the carriers to invest in a network that isn't ludicrously oversold.
- cptskippy 11y agoI started playing around with a Lumia 530 on T-Mobile which has HD Voice and the call quality is night and day compared to my Nexus 4. Everyone I've talked to says the calls sound dramatically better and I'm not aware of anyone who has HD Voice capable phones. The noise cancelling seems to be a big thing as most people tell me that they can't tell I'm driving when I have them on speaker phone. I didn't realize it had HD Voice and chalked it up to Nokia just knowing how to make a decent handset.
- tschuy 11y agoThe Nexus 4 also has HD voice, at least on T-Mobile.
- cptskippy 11y agoI seriously question your claim and would require some citation. The Nexus 4 call quality is abysmal and the dual microphones to cancel out background noise seem to only amplify it. It's not just my phone because I've had 2 now, I love the phone but it's call quality sucks.
- explorigin 11y agoThis! HD Voice is amazing and honestly I wish I could have a dumb phone that could do Skype calls and HD Voice. Honestly the only reason I like having a smartphone is the better call quality for (some) voice comms.
- dswiese 11y agobut does the average customer care? similar to how Pono may have better audio quality, most people are just fine with a compressed mp3. Its what works and its just good enough.
- smileysteve 11y ago> but does the average customer care? They do, but they don't understand why it's bad. This is 'can you hear me now' and 'what'd you say' happen most of the time
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoCell phones actually inject "comfort noise" on the receiving end so that you can't detect when the stream is cut off during pauses in the conversation. I would venture that they just keep it on all the time, set above the actual noise in the voice data stream so that you don't hear two different noise levels.
- jhallenworld 11y agoMy pet peeve is that speaker phone quality was better on cheap flip-phone vs. what you get a smart phones. This caused me to start using a headset. For home meetings, my cordless phone's speaker phone is better than any cell phone, even though it's using "MagicJack".