2 ms·
As you've worked in games, perhaps the designers you've worked with are more adept than average at taking up new tools...? At least that is my experience. Game
by pavlov 11y ago
As you've worked in games, perhaps the designers you've worked with are more adept than average at taking up new tools...? At least that is my experience. Game artists often have experience with all sorts of in-house tools with UIs of highly varying logic and consistency, whereas most "traditional" designers have used Adobe tools and nothing else.
It seems to me that the success of Sketch lies in how little it diverges from the Adobe formula. Sketch doesn't really add any new significant mental model: it adopts Illustrator's terminology (such as artboards) and some of Photoshop's bitmap capabilities, and cleans up the three decades of cruft that obstruct the Illustrator and Photoshop interfaces. That has clearly been a good recipe for something that's easy to pick up for designers.
The UI layout tools in Xcode and Android Studio are not like that. The learning curve is very steep. Interface Builder is a tangled mess of quirky NeXT legacy and complex new concepts like auto-layout constraints. Android Studio's UI editor is worse because it's "property editor hell" -- editing layouts by twiddling Android's endless and confusingly named properties will drive designers mad. (I used to think that Microsoft's Visual Basic was the epitome of this type of tool, but Android is much worse.)
I've worked on a tool called Neonto Studio that tries to provide a designer-friendly cross-platform mobile UI solution:
http://neonto.com http://neonto.com
It generates native code for both iOS and Android, there's no framework.
It has been really difficult to figure out a layout model that is both understandable to designers with Adobe/Sketch background _and_ can translate reasonably well to iOS and Android classes! Our current effort is pretty good, but it definitely has room for improvement.
Still, I would suggest that Neonto Studio is a much gentler way to introduce mobile UIs to a traditional designer than throwing them into the deep end of Interface Builder or Android Studio :)