4 ms·
36-bit processor, 25MHz clock, 128K system memory, 100MB drives, air-conditioned room... Totally killed by a modern $5 Pi Zero. If you took a Pi back in time
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
36-bit processor, 25MHz clock, 128K system memory, 100MB drives, air-conditioned room...
Totally killed by a modern $5 Pi Zero.
If you took a Pi back in time no one would know what to do with it. Linux would be recognisable, Ethernet would be recognised by Xerox Parc and a few experts, and only at 10 MB/s - but USB, HDMI, SC cards, the SoC, and the web would all look like advanced alien technology.
- salgernon 11y agoYou would be surprised. A lot of of those things were invented in those times - and with realistic timeframes for when they'd be available. PARC in particular had a "skate where he puck will be in 10 years" attitude.
- VLM 11y agoA classic display of latency vs bandwidth. The DEC box wins on latency but the pi wins on bandwidth, for large enough tasks, anyway. A 2040 was a PDP-10 with a 30 MHz KL processor running around 30 MIPS and TOPS-20 (the source of the "20" in the name) a quarter century ago. 30e6 * 60 * 24 * 365 * 25 = about 4 e 14 instructions. I can't get a straight answer but hundreds of MIPS sounds reasonable for a pi zero. 4e14 / 500e6 / 60 / 24 / 365 = about a year and a half So sometime in 2017 a pi zero would finally catch up to a DECSystem-2040 which had a quarter century head start. Of course the 2040 has been continuously producing intermediate results for the first 25 years of the "race" while the pi output no results at all having not being invented yet. Also after 27 or so years the pi will somewhat surpass the 2040. Also the IO bandwidth and scalability of old mainframes usually puts newer hardware to shame. "My calculator has more power than a 1960s NASA mainframe that sent men to the moon" "Oh so you're saying you've been to Mars, then?" On one hand, 4e14 instructions executed would have been enough to run entire civilizations, some years ago. On the other hand, its not enough to boot modern Windows, although despite the difficulty is none the less not accomplishing anything in the real world.
- rjsw 11y agoI don't think a PDP-10 does all that well on a bandwidth comparison with a modern system, I would expect something like a Cubietruck with SATA and Gigabit Ethernet to win fairly easily.
- jacobush 11y agoBut ... the parent suggests a Pi wins on bandwidth.
- linker3000 11y agoDid any of the computing magazines of the era feature a free DEC-20 on the cover? Just wondering!
- VLM 11y agoSort of. About 30+ years ago the world was absolutely awash in Compuserve free/demo accounts, included in software boxes and probably magazines. Wish I could find an old 80micro magazine cover on archive.org to document this aspect of the past. People who lived thru it could verify that free compuserve accounts were the AOL floppy/CD of an older era. Compuserve in say 1983 was a DEC service bureau moonlighting at night as a very expensive per hour super BBS system. Like $5/hr at 300 baud. And yes it was a network of PDP-10s as per the linked article (although I seem to remember KI processors not KL's)
- salgernon 11y ago75460,1375 Why did you make me remember that! We used compuserve to support our (retail, boxed Mac) software. Then we had to expand to AOL to cover "the outsiders". And then... Eternal September. (Some day, "like us on Facebook" will be as obsolete as "AOL keyword BLAH", which you can still see at the ending credits of movies from the 90s. I don't recall a similar push for compuserve.)
- hga 11y agoOne other issue, the KL processor had 72 bit wide floating point hardware, it was a fast number cruncher in its day (one reason the follow one Jupiter CPU failed, it only had 36 bit wide FP hardware). The Pi Zero is ARMv6 and therefore has IEEE double precision 64 bit floating point, but move to the Pi 2 ARMv7 and you lose double precision in hardware....
- rasz_pl 11y agonah, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xerox_Star https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xerox_Star looks pretty ok even for today standards, and it was just a streamlined Alto from 73
- agumonkey 11y agoAnd don't mention 1080p screens, for their sanity.
- WalterBright 11y ago> advanced alien technology I wouldn't be so sure. USB, for example, isn't that different from RS-232, it's just faster. There were people in the 70s (I was one of them) looking to build a handheld tablet. We were defeated (obviously) by the needed display and miniaturization technology being a couple orders of magnitude (at least) inadequate. Our ideas were awfully crude by current tablet standards, but we would have recognized a modern tablet, just like I would have recognized my current desktop as not conceptually that different from an LSI-11 box with a terminal.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago"Faster" was not even close to being a solved problem when practical TTL maxed out at around 25MHz and ECL needed its own air conditioning plant. USB 3 runs at low microwave frequencies. There's a lot of engineering between that and RS232 running at a few kbps.