3 ms·
"That's kind of already happened. Stroustrup has done a whole ton of work in that area with Concepts." Wasn't aware of that. It was an interesting read. Thanks
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
"That's kind of already happened. Stroustrup has done a whole ton of work in that area with Concepts."
Wasn't aware of that. It was an interesting read. Thanks for mentioning it.
"It turns out that provable correctness invariably involves a fair bit of complexity"
I wasn't even talking about that. I just looked for static analysis tools that could reliably find common implementation flaws or interface issues with little to no false positives. These already exist for C, Java, Ada, C#, and academic languages. Similarly, some verification or foundation of standard library like Modula-3's or the one for C. I found little to nothing of any of this for C++. So, the C++ verifications would all be visual and manual unless you pay big $$$ for one of few commercial tools.
Unacceptable. Formal methods would make C++ unacceptable for even more reasons.
"This stuff goes back a way, but stemmed from Modern C++ Design."
Same book pjmp recommended. Guess the study should start with it.
"You can override operator-> to make it behave more like a proper pointer. CRTP gives you some pretty powerful ways of getting the job done too."
Interesting example. I think one test of C++'s safety would be whether such methods can provide same protections that Ada provides where applicable to both languages:
http://www.adacore.com/knowledge/technical-papers/safe-secure/ http://www.adacore.com/knowledge/technical-papers/safe-secur...
It would need to catch the problems, do it during compile phase, and do it fast enough to be productive. I heard bad things about C++ compile phase in the past, esp for template heavy code. Plus, needs design-by-contract as Eiffel and SPARK have shown. I've seen it done with asserts and object constructors/destructors so that's probably not a problem. The other stuff, esp static analysis for memory & concurrency safety, is where C++ will be judged most.