4 ms·
What I wonder about for LIDAR is how it will work when you have 20+ Cars using these devices simultaneously, say when driving on a busy road. Do they suffer fro
by Someone 11y ago
What I wonder about for LIDAR is how it will work when you have 20+ Cars using these devices simultaneously, say when driving on a busy road. Do they suffer from not being able to discriminate their own signals from those of the other cars, or is that (statistically) not a concern?
- jjoonathan 11y agoI suspect that a little bit of modulation cleverness goes a long way towards eliminating crosstalk.
- dogma1138 11y agoNot sure if you look at military applications then when a group of aircraft will fly in formation only 1 of them would have the radar on in active scan mode and the data is usually going to be shared over the data link. With phase shift due to movement and the uncertainty of how many cars are there around you modulation might not be enough to prevent cross talk.
- jjoonathan 11y agoYes, overload is real, you can never eliminate crosstalk only suppress it, and degenerate cases will probably pop up as the tehcnology scales. But coming to a compromise that allows every car to generate a map of the road should easily be possible. Well, "easily" in the technological sense, perhaps not the political sense. For military applications it's more useful to have one radar at high range/power than to have n radars at low range/power, while it's just the opposite for civilian lidar applications. So I don't see military radar SOP as evidence that this is inherently difficult.
- Symmetry 11y agoDo they still do that? If so it's because they don't want to have frequency agility turned on all the time so potential adversaries get less opportunity to figure out the relevant algorithms. The degree by which radars adjust their pulse frequencies is way larger than the doppler shift of anything you're likely to run into traveling in the atmosphere. You will occasionally have a conflict by chance but radars by their very nature have to deal with a certain amount of noise. With lidars you won't be able to adjust frequency because that's not how lasers work. Well, you can with free electron lasers but nobody is going to be putting those in lidars. But a laser is directional in a way that a laser isn't. You will occasionally get some false returns but real objects persist from scan to scan in a way that noise doesn't. I've worked with a small fleet of lidar equipped robots and lidar cross talk never caused us any problems. Sunlight on the other hand could be a big problem but automotive lidars are all rated for the outdoors.
- Schwolop 11y agoAh yes - the ol' "facing west near sunset" bug... I lost a few nights sleep to that one. :-)
- rasz_pl 11y agoThis is why I believe LIDAR is a blind alley. We will need to use stereo camera setups and clever bit of firmware (maybe even neural nets) to extract 3d directly from the picture in real time, just like the rest of us monkeys.
- Animats 11y agoWith a flash LIDAR, it's not a big problem. If you're taking 100 images a second at 200 meters, you're only receiving for 1.2us every 10ms, for a duty cycle of about 1/10000. Conflicts are possible but unlikely. If you vary the flash timing randomly, the odds of N successive collisions are (1/10000)^N. A frame with a conflict is going to look totally different than the previous and following frames, so it will be obvious when you've been jammed.
- therein 11y agoWhat would be stopping people from driving around with jammers, or how about enthusiasts who would mod the LIDARs on their vehicles to achieve a higher frame rate? Will police have detectors on their cars, patrolling for these vehicles that are not following the spec?
- grkvlt 11y agoThe same thing that stops people driving around with GPS and cell-phone jammers. That is, nothing, apart from the threat of prosecution if caught. This seems to be a common complaint about new technologies; people claim that somehow anti-social, violent or abnormal behaviour will be a problem merely because it is _possible_.
- Animats 11y agoYou can blind one of the things with a laser pointer at the right IR frequency. But the device can easily detect this, locate it, and use a camera to take a picture of the jammer. For directional devices, jammers are targets; you get direction, but not range.