5 ms·
> + perhaps most importantly, were out of their depth when it came to assessing a political risk, namely the extent to which a surprise attack would bring down
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
> + perhaps most importantly, were out of their depth when it came to assessing a political risk, namely the extent to which a surprise attack would bring down on them the implacable fury of an enraged and industrially-powerful United States.
By "out of their depth" do we mean "dumber than six pounds of gravel"? I admit that the fantasy that slapping someone in the face will instantly cow them, instead of provoking angry retaliation, is a common one in history, but I don't think that makes it any less stupid given the historical evidence.
(See also Every Terrorist Ever, with the exception of the ones who want to provoke angry retaliation.)
- dctoedt 11y ago> By "out of their depth" do we mean "dumber than six pounds of gravel"? There's no excuse for the Japanese militarists' infliction of millions of deaths and untold suffering, but please keep in mind that they were doing the best they knew how at the time with the hand they were dealt (genetics, education, training, experience, social pressures, etc.), in a situation with enormous risks for their nation, which they believed to be on their shoulders. I'm curious what if anything you know of such pressures.
- stickfigure 11y agoThere's no excuse for Adolf Hitler's infliction of millions of deaths and untold suffering, but please keep in mind that he was doing the best he knew how at the time with the hand he was dealt (genetics, education, training, experience, social pressures, etc.), in a situation with enormous risks for his nation, which he believed to be on his shoulders. I'm curious what if anything you know of such pressures. Seems like you can plug just about any name you want into this paragraph. What are you trying to say?
- newjersey 11y agoOr in case of Germany, zero risk because hyperinflation after the treaty meant Germany didn't have much to lose and a lot to gain. Blame Hitler all you want but England and France are ultimately responsible for WWII.
- dctoedt 11y agoI'm saying: 1. it's better to understand who and what you're dealing with, especially when it's a mortal adversary whom you might have to fight to the death; 2. the older I get, the less judgmental I get about other people personally, because I really do believe everybody does the best they know how --- and that's true even though very often I don't accept (and might be more than willing to fight against) what they regard as "the best"; and 3. I'm mindful of the words of a very wise, first-century Middle Eastern sage [1] who urged us to love our enemies [2]. [1] http://www.questioningchristian.com/2004/11/benjamin_frankl.html http://www.questioningchristian.com/2004/11/benjamin_frankl.... (self-cite). [2] https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew%205:43-48 https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew%205:43-...
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoCertainly the situation as a whole was quite complex, but when you get down to the details, dctoedt specifically asserts that there were people who thought the US would roll over and cower if attacked once, and if that is true, then those people were bloody great idiots. If it's not literally true, then perhaps they were something else.
- dctoedt 11y ago> dctoedt specifically asserts that there were people who thought the US would roll over and cower if attacked once For the record, that overstates what I said, which I hope was a bit more nuanced than that. Certainly the Japanese militarists, as a whole, decided to roll the dice that the outcome would not be "An enraged U.S. will counterattack us until our way of life is destroyed." It doesn't necessarily follow that there were those among them who thought, "The US will roll over and cower if we can just take out their battleships at Pearl Harbor." (Of course, some Japanese militarists had an overly-exalted regard for Japanese military virtue and prowess. So it does seem likely that there were indeed some militarists, especially junior officers, who held the latter view, and yes, that view proved fatally naïve.)
- lsc 11y ago>(See also Every Terrorist Ever, with the exception of the ones who want to provoke angry retaliation.) I don't pretend to know what a terrorist's goals are, but my observation, as a US civilian is that our responses to terror have harmed us a whole lot more than the terror attacks themselves, so assuming that a terrorist's goal is to maximize damage to my country, it would be rational for them to focus not on how many people they kill, but on how big and self-destructive of a response they can provoke. (the counter-argument, of course, is that I don't know how many terror attacks would have happened without our massive reaction.)
- mirimir 11y agoAs I understand it, the goals are to provoke overreaction and sharpen the conflict. And so to radicalize supporters, and build support among potential allies. Except for the violence aspect, the strategy is not all that different from nonviolent resistance.
- lsc 11y agoI think that nonviolent resistance is different because the nonviolent resistor is saying, essentially "give me what I want or I will put myself in a position where you have to hurt me." - which only works if the authority in question has some problem with hurting the nonviolent resistor. Terror, on the other hand, seems to be saying something more like "no matter how powerful you are, you can't prevent us from coming in and inflicting shocking, unexpected violence on you." Do you see the difference? one relies on fear, while the other relies on... well, I had it called guilt, but a better person than I am would call it 'empathy' or something like that.
- mirimir 11y agoI agree that the initial primary goal of terrorism is fear. There's also anger, because fear and anger are connected. But I'm not so sure that nonviolent resistance is all about fostering guilt/shame/empathy. I think that guilt etc and anger are also connected. And so both can lead to overreaction. And once you've goaded an opponent into overreacting, they will be hurting innocents. And that will foster sympathy, and build general support for your cause.