2 ms·
Ricardo's Difficult Idea (1998)
- zkfyy7en1o 11y agoSpecialization is centralizing. Centralized systems are arguably more fragile (a negative, when reliability is a goal) and easier to actively leverage for something I might not like (absolute power corrupts...). There is also a patronizing aspect to 'free trade' that implies monopolies are the just outcomes of meritocracies, which I consider patently false. Quite the opposite: we constantly have to fight centralization of power, and 'free trade' (a misnomer, IHMO), is a dangerous centralizing force at a global level, which we have basically never had to reign in. I find it amusing how often people who consider themselves libertarian, etc, argue for some of the most fascist regimes imaginable.
- aidenn0 11y agoI think that part of the disconnect is that economists look on a much longer term policy wise than non economists. There will be an affect on jobs, trade deficits, &ct. of any free-trade act for at least a decade, and it's not unreasonable to look at history and argue a time frame of ~50 years for markets to approach an equilibrium. If you reframe it the discussion as "lots of you will lose your jobs over the next 50 years, but your grandchildren will have about the same employment rate as you, and higher quality of living" then you can start to have a more meaningful argument about how to manage the short-term side effects and the long term benefits. Similarly there's debate as to the long-term viability of monopolies, as well as government regulation. If in the long term monopolies fall apart on their own and government regulation turns to regulatory capture, then you can see the economist's opposition to trust-busting.
- 9mit3t2m9h9a 11y agoThere is such thing as current relative advantage; and to change what your relative advantage is, it may be useful to restrict some of the trade. Also, having ten inefficient suppliers is often better than having one very efficient monopoly — because it is usually also efficient at overcharging. If the incentives are perfectly aligned and there is a medium term success or failure to consider, relative advantage works as advertised; but this will be closer to three equal startup co-founders dividing the work in the early stages than to international trade.