4 ms·
Memorable SF Characters of the Essential Authors
- CurtMonash 11y agoI think this is a fair critique, if a bit hyperbolic. One point overlooked is that the predominant form of science fiction was, for some decades, short stories. Salvor Hardin was as richly imagined a character as Bayta Darell, but he only appeared in short stories (or novellas); he was the hero for about half of Foundation. The sequels were novels; the women were accordingly more memorable; and by the way, I found grandaughter more memorable than grandmother anyway. Another point overlooked is the happy introduction of the vivid, lovable rogue. Nicholas van Rijn is an excellent example, even if by profession he is a tycoon. Lazarus Long is another; I found him a lot more vivid than the article's author evidently did. Fafryd and the Grey Mouser are Exhibits 3A and 3B, although that's fantasy, and even Lord of the Rings had vivid characters, so perhaps the criticism never applied to fantasy at all. On the other hand -- as much as I adore Zelazny, his heroes are pretty much all the same. They're jaded and cynical, witty in their cynicism, and usually very altruistic even so. Usually they're quasi-immortal demigods too, with the most important counterexample that part probably being the poet in A Rose For Ecclesiastes. Dune deserves a mention as being fairly early in the genre for having great characterization. Also Ann McCaffrey's Pern books, but those are really fantasies with a thin SF veneer. Getting more modern yet, I agree that characterization is the norm rather than the exception. My favorite is probably Miles Vorkosigan. I have no idea how that series could win so many Hugos and Nebulas and still seem to be relatively unknown.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoI've been reading Asimov's short stories recently, and not only are they brilliantly imaginative, they also have unusually vivid characters. They're not as developed as they would be in a novel, but they're certainly not emotionally flat. In fact they're colourful but economical - just a few choice phrases and snatches of dialogue paint enough of a picture to bring them to life, complete with complex, sometimes hidden or unexpected motivations, and inner conflicts. They may be of their time, but they're certainly not cardboard.
- CurtMonash 11y agoSusan Calvin was certainly an interesting character, now that you mention it. And so were both the partners in the Caves of Steel books. And when I mentioned Salvor Hardin before, I could have mentioned Salvor Hardin as well. I.e., I agree with you, both on the vividness of the characters and the restrictions on characterization imposed by the short story format.
- fsiefken 11y agoAfter all these centuries I still remember R. Daneel Olivaw, I wonder if I ever meet him again.
- empthought 11y agoI know Vonnegut was reluctant to embrace the SF author moniker, but surely the characters in Player Piano and Cat's Cradle merit a mention?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoHaven't been up on SF works outside video games. Personally, I think they did a good job with Shepard and Reaper plot on Mass Effect 1. Kind of integrated a lot of themes into the ultimate villain and ability to artificially mitigate the threat of biological evolution. Maybe it was a knock-off of someone but I thought it was clever. Reapers remain my favorite, SF villains. :) Need to get back into the genre at some point. Anyone got recommendations on especially interesting or innovative works?
- douche 11y agoI don't know if it is especially innovative, but I've gotten a lot of enjoyment out of James A. Corey's Expanse novels lately. Hopefully the SyFy channel doesn't butcher it when they put it on TV.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoThis is an essay by John C. Wright who has written, among other things, regret that he didn't physically assault Terry Pratchett: "I sat and listened to pure evil being uttered in charming accents accentuated by droll witticism, and I did not stand up, and I did not strike the old man who uttered them across the mouth: and when he departed, everyone stood and gave him an ovation, even though he had done nothing in his life aside from entertain their idle afternoons." (http://www.scifiwright.com/2011/10/the-watchtowers-of-atlantis-tremble/ http://www.scifiwright.com/2011/10/the-watchtowers-of-atlant... )
- prewett 11y agoYou miss the context, though. The unnamed writer (presumably Prachett) advocated suicide as something positive and talked an audience member into suicide. All for the sake of feeling better (or, rather, not feeling). For Wright, humans are made in the image of God, and to kill yourself as if you were a horse with a broken leg is a travesty. To advocate doctors killing people, even if they want to be killed, is to treat people in an amoral, atheistic way that destroys civilization. And in the comments, Wright regrets that he did not have the gall to stand up and do something about this evil. It's a bit like, if you knew what would happen when Jar-Jar proposed giving Palpatine dictatorial power, regretting not actually doing something instead sitting while everyone else pulled civilization down around you.