4 ms·
>>The problem with this is that it creates moral hazard. There are lots of individual acts which are fun that I might engage in (e.g., gluttony, gay sex, inacti
by gambiting 11y ago
>>The problem with this is that it creates moral hazard. There are lots of individual acts which are fun that I might engage in (e.g., gluttony, gay sex, inactivity, smoking, drugs) but which impose potential costs on others. Why is it reasonable for me to enjoy these benefits while others pay the costs?
Does it not work the exact same way with private insurance? If you require treatment, you increase premiums for everyone, not just yourself.
Anyway, I'm personally super happy with national insurance because I simply don't have to think about it. I know that if I need an operation, I will get one. I know that if I have an accident, and they need to send a helicopter to get me, I won't even see the bill for that. If I need to stay in hospital for the next year of my life, I won't see the bill. If I lose my job and become homeless I'm still going to be covered. I don't need to worry which hospital to go to, or which doctor/dentist can see me - they all can, there's no receipt produced, it's simply not a worry I have. Right now I pay about ~$100USD a month for the national health insurance, and it's an amount I am extremely happy to pay. Why would I care that other people are having accidents or smoking?
- maxerickson 11y agoIf you are talking about insurance in the pure actuarial sense, the company can choose to charge higher rates or not carry people that engage in excessive risks. Of course insurance is not purely actuarial anymore, if it ever was.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIf private insurance can account for your risky behavior (as the article is describing, then no. Private insurance doesn't have this problem. And again, high deductibles mitigate it, since your risky behavior can cause you to lose 20% of your income, but still protect you from tail risk. Why would I care that other people are having accidents or smoking? Because you are paying for the consequences of their actions. A quick google search suggests more than 20% of the (far more than $100/month) Americans pay is caused by gluttony alone: http://www.healthycommunitieshealthyfuture.org/learn-the-facts/economic-costs-of-obesity/ http://www.healthycommunitieshealthyfuture.org/learn-the-fac... That's about 1/3 of what we spent on our overpriced military. And that ignores the costs inflicted by overweight but not obese people as well as various other unhealthy behaviors. In a country where medical professionals have no other options and therefore take low salaries, this may be less of an issue. But in the US medicine is very expensive, so it costs us a lot.