4 ms·
A Biofuel Dream Gone Bad
- ArkyBeagle 11y ago"The result was a relative preponderance of lab researchers with Ph.D.s and a dearth of people with technical, operational experience running energy facilities. " Yep. But the plummet in energy prices alone would have doomed it.
- intopieces 11y agoSo the failure was due to circumstances Kior could not have controlled, yet: '"In the suit, Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood described KiOR as “one of the largest frauds ever perpetrated on the State of Mississippi."' Something doesn't add up here. The loan was only for $75m, and by this account the founder put in much more than that in his own money. It sounds like MS took a gamble they weren't prepared for and are now trying to get what they can out of it. Fraud doesn't seem to enter into it, but maybe that's just the bias of the article I'm picking up one.
- mikeyouse 11y agoYou've got it.. The state help (we looked at it as well) involves making tech predictions about where your yields will be and your cost structure will be in 3-5 years... It's nearly impossible to get these projections right, and the companies are obviously optimistic so when the numbers come up short, it looks like they were lying. I highly doubt there was any actual fraud. It won't matter anyway, the whole point of running a business is to shield the investors from liability, none of our (smaller) incentives ever involved guarantees from investors.
- graycat 11y agoA Ph.D. can't do operational things? Uh, the Manhattan Project, WMAP, the US Navy's version of GPS, GPS itself?
- ArkyBeagle 11y ago"Technical, operational experience". It's really a thing. As specializations have become more narrow, it's more of a thing. We're all on intellectual ice floes, drifting apart.
- graycat 11y agoYup. But in the Manhattan Project, the Ph.D.'s seemed to get that experience quickly enough. Besides, where to find people with experience turning chemical goo into blocks of explosive and machining them to fit precisely in a 3D puzzle so that when the 40 or so detonators fired all at once, the explosive would make a nearly perfect spherical wave shrinking down to compress the nuclear fuel? The guy who did that first in the Manhattan Project did it the first in all of history.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoGuys, plural. So I cheated and looked it up - Kistiakowsky had a background in ordnance :) von Neuman's model was critical though , and may well have been nearly pure invention. A lot of things like this in the present day are boring, path-dependent stuff. Takes a while to get up to speed.
- Animats 11y agoFuel from cellulose has been around from a long time, back to WWII. It works, but it's always been a marginal technology economically. Around 2012, lots of companies seemed to be building plants, and some of them even started up.[1] But few seem to break even. It's frustrating that this doesn't work well, since most plants are powered by agricultural waste (stalks, cobs, etc.) that is already being produced and just has to be collected. However, it's good to know this can be done, since someday, oil will run out. [1] http://www.renewableenergymagazine.com/article/abengoa-celebrates-first-commercialscale-next-generation-biofuel-20141020 http://www.renewableenergymagazine.com/article/abengoa-celeb...
- graycat 11y agoI see a pattern in the article. The pattern seems to apply to the writers of the article and also Khosla and his firm. The pattern: Hover about 100,000 feet above reality where really can't tell the difference between a horse, cow, or bison. Can't tell the difference between a Model T and a current Chevy SUV. Instead, just look at really simple, crude, external things and ignore the complicated, internal, crucial, core things. Like trying to learn how to build a rocket to go to Mars by watching all the episodes of Star Trek or all movies of Star Wars. Like trying to learn auto engineering by watching NASCAR races on TV. Silicon Valley has managed to get by with this view from 100,000 feet because of some special considerations, but in general for engineering, applied research, and advanced technology that 100,000 foot view doesn't work. Instead, details matter, right down to the last nut, bolt, washer, wire, switch, light, clamp, tube, weld, etc. Silicon Valley? Okay: A startup is based on software. The hardware and systems software are rock solid and standard. Clearly there is traction, significantly high and growing rapidly. The product/service is clearly for a large market. The technology is clearly highly scalable by routine means. All the technical parts are just routine software that can be done by a major fraction of the software developers in Silicon Valley. Nothing else looks bad. There are several founders, each male, each with a pregnant wife. The founders are desperate for some cash and are eager to sign a term sheet with some really onerous terms, things like claw backs, cram downs, liquidity preferences, pro rata rights, with four year vesting of the stock by the founders, and where the BoD is dominated by the venture investors and can fire anyone in the company for any reason or no reason before their stock is vested. So, presto, bingo, invest. Biofuels are very different. Sorry Vinod.
- mikeyouse 11y agoI worked for a competing biofuel company and our story reads very similarly to Kior's. Aside from the internal problems that everyone has, the price of a barrel of oil moving from $100 when we were founded to $180 while we were fundraising to $60 while we were trying to commercialize just wrecked our story and business model. Nice article though. I'm nostalgic and tempted to try again focused purely on speciality chemicals.
- keithpeter 11y agoDo you think there is a case for developing 'proof of concept' pilot plants with subsidy even if the price of oil is so low that there would be no commercial business that could be carried on? Just so that if/when things change in the future the technology is well known? (I'm in UK, politics around subsidies a bit different)
- mikeyouse 11y agoHonestly, that's just about what's happened.. All of the companies in the biofuel world (KiOR, Solazyme, Amyris, Aurora, Algenol, Joule, Sapphire) spent a ton of money -- I think everyone on that list blew through >$100M -- to develop the technology and get to the pilot level. They all failed trying to commercialize. The technology still exists in the form of IP held by the investors, so if the economics ever make sense again, it would be a much shorter route to commercialization than the first time around. We absolutely have the ability to make large amounts of energy from algae, cyanobacteria, cellulose, etc. Given a few hundred million in CapEx to get a plant off the ground and a few tens of million in working capital, most of those companies break even with usable fuel at ~$150/bbl. If you relocated the facilities to a low-cost-of-living area and started with, say $1B, you could likely produce for ~$100/bbl. Unfortunately, the return will be very low and unstable based on global energy prices. The pitfalls of producing a volatile commodity. Another random thought is that we were seeing immense progress in the quality of work out of Asia for engineering and construction for the facilities. It's expensive to put steel and concrete in the ground, shockingly so for many SV investors, but the quality was quickly improving out of China / Thailand for custom-engineered oil/gas processing equipment. Assuming this continues to improve, the future costs will be much lower.