3 ms·
"Naturally, some members of the enterprise are better at leadership and strategic thinking than others. It is natural for these members of the enterprise to sp
by jodrellblank 17y ago
"Naturally, some members of the enterprise are better at leadership and strategic thinking than others. It is natural for these members of the enterprise to spend their time thinking more strategically. Others will be executing more tactically. Some will be involved both strategically and tactically."
And some will be working. </cheap jab>
He does claim that some employees are 10x more productive, but later on says there is anecdotal evidence that some are 10x more productive. Maybe the reason firms aren't paying 10x more is not because they're unable to measure the difference, or because they're mean, but what if the 10x productivity is only possible in certain sets of circumstances which don't manifest in typical large business work?
e.g. when the employee has some kind of cross-department authority to make decisions and affect large chunks of a product which they would have in a startup but which would be proxied via some other people in a larger business?
- eru 17y ago> e.g. when the employee has some kind of cross-department authority to make decisions and affect large chunks of a product which they would have in a startup but which would be proxied via some other people in a larger business? Upper management has these authority in larger businesses. They also get paid magnitudes more.
- jodrellblank 17y agoIndeed; the person who sprang to mind was Jonathan Ive - known as a good designer, wikipedia puts a million pound salary on him, he is an Apple higher up. Is he paid that because he's a Senior VP, or because he's worth that? If he is worth that, how much is he worth it full stop, and how much is he worth it but only when he can amplify his efforts, direct chunks of the company, refuse compromise, etc. using the power and respect of the SVP position? How far can the two be separated?
- pchristensen 17y agoYou could compare his salary to other SVPs in Apple or other companies. The difference is how much his abilities are valued at. Sort of like the average NBA shooting guard makes a few million a year, but Michael Jordan was making $30 million a year at the end.
- kurtosis 17y agoI've heard the story where there was a 10x difference in the time it took CS students to complete a series of system programming assignments, but are there other anecdotes out there? I'm very suspicious of this story, and think that a lot of this fabled 10x multiple can be explained by extrinsic circumstances or luck. At least that's what I've observed in science where easy experiments in a field that is new and fashionable can yield lots of interesting papers, where taking on more difficult projects in established fields can require much more work to achieve incremental results.
- earl 17y agoThere is some empirical evidence in a book called Peopleware. http://www.amazon.com/Peopleware-Productive-Projects-Teams-Second/dp/0932633439 http://www.amazon.com/Peopleware-Productive-Projects-Teams-S... I would paste some quotes but I lost my copy.
- fhars 17y agoThat page gives an overview over the (dead tree) literature on the topic: http://forums.construx.com/blogs/stevemcc/archive/2008/03/27/productivity-variations-among-software-developers-and-teams-the-origin-of-quot-10x-quot.aspx http://forums.construx.com/blogs/stevemcc/archive/2008/03/27... An interesting data point he cites is the comparision between Lotus 123 version 3 and Excel 3.0: "Excel took 50 staff years to produce 649,000 lines of code. Lotus 123 took 260 staff years to produce 400,000 lines of code. [...] The difference in productivity between the two teams was more than a factor of 8." But then it will probably not be too difficult to find people who will tell you that 123 was still the better product. [Edit: Another important point is that the these factors are between the best and the worst. The difference between the best and the median can be considerably smaller, so it is not that surprising not to see any programmers paid ten times the average.]
- ytinas 17y agoThe Lotus vs. Excel thing is more likely showing the fact that smaller teams can outproduce larger teams, since with smaller teams there is less coordination needed.
- argv_empty 17y agoI don't think I've ever heard of top employees being 10x as productive as the average employee. I usually hear 10x quoted as the difference between top and bottom. I think the part you're missing here is how low the bottom is, not how high the top is.