7 ms·
Codes of Misconduct
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 4ad 11y agoWell, this article is interesting because it's not the typical mindless Yes We Can article written by someone who heard that now wanting "Social Justice" (whatever that is) is the trend of the day, without understanding the dynamics of social interaction in the slightest. It's also not an article written to sound like someone in the above category wrote, but in fact is being written by someone who understand the social dynamics, and just has an agenda. In fact the article is sincere, and correctly identifies the "problem". There are many things I find abhorrent about the proposed world described in the article, but I will refer to only one of them. Btw, even if I find abhorrent this "new" world order, it's much better than the world order imposed by the Yes We Can people. > Additionally, they shall have one or more "hosts" who do not drink alcohol, and who are trained to observe and catch violations should they occur. Yeah, this casual suggestion that some sort of "police" should exist to monitor people's behavior and catch policy violations quickly is the worst thing that is currently happening to humanity in my opinion, and ultimately results in a world I don't want to be part of. The police part is bad in itself, but much worse is how casual this "final solution" is proposed, and how little people complain about it. People were bred into obedience and submission. We already lost. There's very little for me to do about this. All I can do is vote with my money, e.g. I don't go to conferences where people are not adults enough that they don't know how to live, yes, live life, without CoCs and police, even though I am one of the nice people at those conferences, not one of the "bad actors" the author mentions. Of course this doesn't affect the world in the slightest.
- PieterH 11y agoI've a large building and we've hosted many parties here. Almost always, people are great, even when drunk. Alcohol does not make good people turn bad, in my experience. Every now and then an event deteriorates. I learned that someone has to stay sober and play host. It's not about policing. It's about being available, and separating parties when there's an incident. That's all. I'll modify the text to make this clear, as the notion of policing is exactly what I'm trying to make distance from. One example: we had a party downstairs with several hundred guests. It was a Congolese wedding, so people were drinking a lot. I go to sleep, and around 2am get woken by extremely loud noises. I put on some clothes and go down, and find a battle raging in the entrance to my building. Seems two young guys (North African) had come in and were caught stealing from peoples' jackets. The crowd had caught them. One had escaped, one was still prisoner. The one that fled had come back with reinforcements, so I found about eight young men hammering on the doors of my building with a steel bed frame (don't ask me where this came from). Inside, a group held the other young man down, while he was shrieking for help, afraid they would murder him. It took only a few seconds to get this whole story from various people. I picked up the young man by his arm and dragged him out, and threw him at his friends. "You will leave now, or the police will be here," I told them. They put the bed down and left. I told the party goers, "are you utterly insane? What did you think was going to happen?" and ushered them back into the party room. It all took maybe 5 minutes. If I'd had even a small amount to drink, no way I could have done this. Now, such incidents are extreme. Yet when you have guests in your home or event, and you offer them alcohol, you have (in my mind) to look after them. No ifs or buts. Bad stuff can happen. I also learned after this night to have professional security, which is another thing that can help. Hope this helps. The host absolutely does not monitor peoples' behavior. He/she intervenes quickly when there is an issue, before it gets out of hand. Thanks for your feedback, it was helpful.
- afarrell 11y agoWow. I admire your ability to take command of a situation.
- aaronem 11y ago> this casual suggestion that some sort of "police" should exist to monitor people's behavior and catch policy violations quickly is the worst thing that is currently happening to humanity What alternative do you suggest? Putting the entire weight of dealing with predators on the people they seek to victimize? I mean, you seem to be invoking Godwin's law over an example of the responsibility borne by a host to a guest -- "final solution"? Really? -- so I'm not expecting a reasonable discussion with you on this subject, but I figure I ought to ask just in case.
- whatyoucantsay 11y agoIn theory, part of being an adult is being able to take care of yourself. This includes being aware of your personal safety, leaving when a situation becomes dangerous and calling for help in the case of an emergency. Sometimes police have to be involved, but in the vast majority of situations people can handle issues as they arise when they are at a supermarket, a public park, a bus stop, a bar or even a tech conference. Involvement of authority figures and police monitoring at every single public gathering might slightly reduce certain problems, but the price is too high.
- aaronem 11y agoThe only ones here talking about "authority figures" and "police monitoring" are you and the commenter to whom I originally replied. The article under discussion suggests nothing more than that a convention's hosting organization take a slightly more active role, in discharging its responsibility to its guests, than is embodied in the standard code-of-conduct model requiring a victim of sexual misconduct to complain to the organizers in order for anything to be done. If I invite two guests to my home, and while they're there I see that one of them is refusing to be politely dissuaded from making sexual suggestions that the other finds uncomfortable, then it's part of my responsibility as a host to intervene. (This isn't a hypothetical situation for me; it's actually happened.) If my organization invites N people to my convention, our responsibility is just the same: they're here because we asked them to be, so while they're my guests, we are bound to look after them. Of course, like any adults, they'll still look out for themselves to the extent they're able; it would be foolish to imagine otherwise. That's where the "polite dissuasion" part comes in. The host's responsibility begins where harassment escalates beyond that point, and all the article under discussion suggests is that hosting organizations ensure there's someone at hand, in a situation like a con hotel bar where such escalation is historically speaking most likely to occur, in order to intervene in the improbable event that it actually does. As for the nature of that intervention, the article goes into a lot of "good actor/bad actor" business which, while not without interest, IMO just clouds the basic issue. Speaking, again, as someone who's actually done it, this kind of intervention doesn't start with the police, and it would be stupid to imagine otherwise. You start with a firm, quiet word in the ear of the miscreant, on the subject of the standards you expect your guests to uphold, and with a note that those who fail to do so cease to be welcome. If that doesn't do the job, you tell your former guest he's no longer welcome and escort him out, or in the convention case have your security staff do so. If he refuses to leave, then at that point he's made himself a de jure trespasser, and if that's not enough to get the point across, then and only then is it appropriate to involve the police. Such a response is measured at every stage, and titrated from zero up to the minimum necessary to fulfill the responsibilities of a host. Those merely too dense to take a repeated hint will get the idea at step one, and curtail their misbehavior. Those who fail to do so will be removed from the situation so that they may no longer maltreat your guests. If merely escorting them off the premises will suffice, then that's all that is done; only someone thick enough not to get the idea at that point risks incurring force majeure. And nothing in the article implies otherwise. But, hey, if you want to imagine the author's talking about stationing uniformed police in every con hotel bar, to descend with flashing nightsticks upon he who makes a pass at a colleague and finds himself turned down, then go for it, I guess.
- peteretep 11y ago> The mainstream theory of harassment (let's call it > "Model A") has these assumptions: > - Anyone can be the harasser. > - Harassment is a motiveless act. > - Outlawing harassment will stop it. I don't think that's right. I think people who want a Code of Conduct generally see the primary reason for a Code of Conduct as a signal from organizers that they will take actions listed seriously as harrassment if they happen. It's like a sign at a small rural hotel that says "Same-sex couples welcome". They don't mean that other couples are unwelcome, they don't mean they're catering exclusively for same-sex couples, they don't think you should change religion: they're just sending out a signal that if a guy and his husband stay there, they're not going to run in to official hostility. A CoC sends the signals that: the organizers know harrassment takes place, they care, and they're willing to publically agree to address it and take it seriously when it occurs.
- PieterH 11y agoI think we agree that is the intention. However it's more like putting up a sign on a hotel saying "Murder and mayhem will not be tolerated." If there is a real risk of murder and mayhem, the sign needs to read, "If someone tries to murder you, please call 911!" Harassment does not simple "take place" and that's the point. Participants enter zones of vulnerability caused by distance from home, separation from friends, alcohol, the need to socialize, etc. This draws in predators. The organizers need to understand that, and guard against it. The term "code of conduct" is itself a problem as it strongly suggests "behave or else!" while talking to the entire audience. Do you have a better explanation for the antagonism many feel (and I personally used to feel) towards codes of conduct?
- DasIch 11y agoCoC do explain who to contact for help, the equivalent to 911, if you will.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- unimpressive 11y agoMy biggest problem with this essay is the idea that in all instances of egregious social misconduct it's the result of psychopathy. I think the psychopath factor should be given a much higher prior, but not an absolute one. Sometimes people didn't get the socialization that they should have gotten in childhood or adolescence, within this industry in particular it seems odd to ignore the possibility of social impairment through autism. Sometimes people really do make mistakes, and sometimes those mistakes make you go "Wow how did somebody not know this wasn't okay?"[0], and sometimes they know better and had a lapse in judgment or read the wrong signals. Predators exist, psychopaths exist, most harassment is probably repeat victimization by the same bad actors, but mistakes still exist. [0]: I know I've asked this question about my own behavior before, I somehow suspect most of us have at one point or another.
- aaronem 11y agoNo one's suggesting that mistakes should be dealt with in the same way as predatory behavior. The article makes this explicit in its specimen code: > [I]f the organizers feel a particular individual is the cause of more than one complaint, and does not self-correct, they may exclude that person from the event. There's room here to deal with someone who's merely boorish or ignorant without throwing them out of the con; with such a person, a word on the subject of minimal standards of behavior will generally suffice. In cases where that doesn't suffice, and the harassment continues, I am much of the opinion that the host's responsibility to his blameless guest outweighs that to the misbehaving one; sure, it's a shame if someone gets booted out of a con because he genuinely isn't equipped to behave in a minimally decent fashion, but it's much more of a shame if people feel like they can't safely go to a convention at all because there's a significant chance they'll be harassed by fellow guests.
- PieterH 11y agoWe all make mistakes. Yet if we're talking about safety, then we're talking about danger, and that means something specific. Social impairment makes people awkward, it does not make them dangerous. Taking offense at such awkwardness is itself a problem IMO. This is why you cannot take a complaint at face value without corroboration and allowing people to self-correct. We have all found ourselves on the wrong side of social mores and codes. The thing is, some of us move rapidly back, and others sit there happily, and on purpose.
- fche 11y ago"So the solution is to remove the incentives and opportunities for misbehavior, and raise the risks of exposure. Then, bad actors will adapt and self-select. Either they will behave, or they will go elsewhere." That sounds good, but nothing in the rest of the write-up actually "removes incentives and opportunities" etc. It's the usual sort of "don't harass, don't touch, don't X Y Z ..." litany, without any procedural prescriptions as to what to do in case someone does X.
- PieterH 11y agoThe protocol I describe is almost entirely about procedure. Was that not clear, or not detailed enough? Removing incentive and opportunity means recognizing what creates risk for participants, and reducing that. Which I also did try to cover.
- fche 11y agoOK, there were three bullets in the middle of the "protocol" that dealt with procedure. ("The organizers shall provide as secure ..." through "... privacy of all parties"). But it belabours trivia ("collect time, place, name ...") and skips over substantial questions like burdens of proof, appeals, range of penalties, false complaints, violations of procedure. That's the meat & potatoes of law, amateur or professional.
- PieterH 11y agoYou're right, this part is thin. In terms of penalties, there is only exclusion, or law enforcement. We can expand on the procedural part later.
- rl3 11y ago>The organizers shall be aware of the risk of "date rape" drugs. I'd love to see sensor hardware combined with computer vision techniques employed to combat this problem. Smart glassware already exists, but a major caveat is that it doesn't catch the perpetrator.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> The term "bad actors" is a convenient euphemism for sub-clinical psychopaths. Nice example of dehumanizing the enemy. We now have our very own untermenschen. > It will speak to bad actors and say, clearly: you are welcome as long as you act decent. Otherwise, we are watching, and we will catch you. Is this why we, a bunch of adults, congregate in technical conferences? So we can hunt down the "baddies", play the policing game, recycle some old presentations so we can feel good about our technological choices and at the same time pat ourselves on the back for finally being able to bully someone as a group?
- PieterH 11y agoYou're projecting and/or reading meaning that isn't there. Most of us congregate to learn and open our minds. A small percentage come to prey on others. This is just how it is, no good or bad. My book The Psychopath Code (http://psychopathcode.com http://psychopathcode.com) makes it quite clear I don't consider psychopaths as enemy or bad guys. It's much more fun than that.
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> Most of us congregate to learn and open our minds. So not to feel safe and protected, like when we were children? > I don't consider psychopaths as enemy or bad guys But you consider them "bad actors". Furthermore, you simplified everything by declaring that every unsavory character suffers from the same pseudo-psychiatric pathology. And you're supposed to be an authority on the matter because you wrote a book?
- PieterH 11y agoFeeling safe and learning aren't exclusive. The term "bad actor" is widely accepted and understood. If you have a better term, I'm all ears. The term is accurate when seen from the perspective of the majority, which is the perspective I'm taking in this article. As for my authority, no, all I can say is I've studied this dynamic in depth for many years and have a lot of good data on it, and tools that work. You're free to use those tools, ignore them, etc. And it's not a pathology. It is something far more profound than that. If you're interested, and perhaps you are, read just the first chapter of that book (the PDF is free to download).
- chippy 11y agoThis is a good approach to severe acts of harassment in real life meetings of people. In particular social events involving beer. But these acts are rare in tech events. The most common acts of behaviour we see that some people call for Codes of Conduct are not this severe. The most common types of things would include: telling lewd jokes, being loud and argumentative, questioning particular religious or political beliefs, or being not politically correct enough. In short behaviours which do not fall into a right and wrong objective morality, but which depend greatly on the thoughts and feelings of those offended. They are subjective. These are the behaviours which I think many proponents of Codes of Conduct in tech events are thinking of.
- PieterH 11y agoThe reason I wrote this article is because I think the mainstream is so wrong it hurts. All the behaviors you listed are a normal and necessary part of socialization. Without some argument there is no learning. There is a real right to freedom of speech. This is why I tried to define "violation" from first principles as an unwanted intrusion into personal time and space. There must be (profoundly) the intention of damage. Offense is not damage.
- chippy 11y agoI see, thank you!
- pornel 11y ago> Harrasement is not a gender issue It's interesting that it can be true, but not change much in practice due to gender imbalance at tech conferences. Let's assume that 1% of attendees (of any gender) are bad actors attacking the other gender. If a conference has e.g. 800 men and 200 women, then there will be 2 female harassers vs 800 men, and 8 male harassers vs 200 women. That's a 16 times difference in likelihood of being harassed ((8/200) / (2/800)), just from attendee imbalance, and no fault of any gender.
- PieterH 11y agoMost harassment at tech conferences is male-on-male, and it is not sexual. It is about power and control, and perhaps amusement. Sex, gender, height, choice of programming language: these are ways to create and exploit vulnerability. Sometimes I don't think psychopaths, sorry, bad actors, care about sex at all, except as a tool for controlling people.
- pvdebbe 11y agoIs making fun (not constantly though) of some bad languages now harassment?
- PieterH 11y agoIf it's used to intimidate and isolate, then yes. Remember school bullies? Same thing yet more subtle and stealthy. Often the model of harassment is indirect. For instance you have a group of people who are happy and working together. A predator arrives and sees opportunity. He sees another guy is protecting and coaching the group. So he slowly undermines and destroys this guy's credibility, provoking him to anger and finally making him leave. Then, the group is exposed and easy to play with. You almost never see it. Even when it happens to you, you can almost not see it. It is so slow, careful, smooth. This is why education of these patterns of stalking, isolation, and attack are so important.
- cbd1984 11y ago> The organizers shall be aware of the risk of "date rape" drugs. They shall be aware that the most important "date rape" drug is alcohol. That's un-PC to say, especially around drinkers, but it's true.
- PieterH 11y agoYes, very much so. This is critical. We often depend on alcohol to relax and socialize, when among strangers. Yet it makes us vulnerable to all kinds of manipulation, and the next day everything is blurred and we forget. When I see a man (or woman) offering shots, time after time, to people who are already drunk and careless, I watch his face and his eyes.