4 ms·
> Why would people want to work longer? As much as I enjoy technology, working is the least pleasant part of my life. I think modern industrial civilization en
by munificent 11y ago
> Why would people want to work longer? As much as I enjoy technology, working is the least pleasant part of my life.
I think modern industrial civilization encourages a sort of compartmentalization of roles and terms that isn't actually real. Certainly, for many people, their job is not a pleasant part of their life. From that angle, sure, no one wants to keep doing that until the day they die.
But that doesn't mean the alternative—pure idle leisure—is that great either. Doing nothing sounds awesome when you're burnt out, but after a week or two of it, most people will start chewing on the wallpaper.
This dichotomy that "everything that you do for money is unpleasant and unsatisfying" and "everything that is recreational is easy and unchallenging" is false. There is a whole spectrum of difficulty, reward, and monetary compensation and jobs, hobbies, recreations and pastimes occupy all sorts of points on it.
For most people, they want to spend a good portion of their time doing things that are rewarding, and not necessarily easy. Being retired just means you can optimize for personal satisfaction without having to also optimize for monetary gain.
If I could retire today, sure, I'd get a bit more sleep. But I'd also hack more open source code, write more books, and volunteer. Those are difficult things (especially that middle one). Does that make them "work"? In the sense of "working on the book", "my life's work", etc. yes. But is it "work" in the sense of "thing I'd only do for money"? Certainly not.
- lfowles 11y ago> But that doesn't mean the alternative—pure idle leisure—is that great either. Doing nothing sounds awesome when you're burnt out, but after a week or two of it, most people will start chewing on the wallpaper. Did you take a lesson from dogs there? They'll literally start chewing the wallpaper unless you give them "work". We're not all that much different.
- iamsohungry 11y agoBob Black's essay, The Abolition of Work gives an alternative dichotomy to the "work versus idleness" dichotomy: work versus play. You can be paid for playing if your play produces value (and many forms of play do produce value).
- coldtea 11y agoPursue a career you like and feels like play (DJing, skating, liberal arts, photography, music) and you wont have to work a day in your life (because nobody's hiring).
- iamsohungry 11y agoI realize you're joking, but in the context of this discussion, this shouldn't be mistaken for a valid point. We're talking about how to structure a society, and I think it makes sense to structure society in a way that allows people to play, maybe not all the time, but more and more as technology reduces the need to work. Continuing to push the idea that work is a value in itself as work provides less and less value is going to be a bigger and bigger problem as the need for work decreases.
- coldtea 11y ago>But that doesn't mean the alternative—pure idle leisure—is that great either. Doing nothing sounds awesome when you're burnt out, but after a week or two of it, most people will start chewing on the wallpaper. That's because people have been conditioned to not do anything significant out of their jobs -- except maybe from some tame passtimes that get boring soon. But there's a universe of things to do, and stuff to do with job-level concentration+personal freedom to do them as you like, if you don't have to work on some 9-5 job.