4 ms·
Are we really, really sure that no one is lurking with a patent?
by protomyth 17y ago
Are we really, really sure that no one is lurking with a patent?
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoOh the MPEG-LA have definitely got patents, but it's a bit uncharitable to characterize their first-hit-is-free strategy for web video as lurking.
- evgen 17y agoI think protomyth was referring to the fact that while the Theora folks loudly claim to be unencumbered by patents this is a completely untested assertion and if such a patent were to show up they are without their own suite of patents with which to threaten the other party. MPEG-LA is covered by patents and has a licensing board, but the spec is also pretty-well vetted by various teams of lawyers and if someone tries to submarine a patent in they would find themselves facing a rather large, well-funded, and pissed off group with no qualms about burying the troll in counter-claims and long/expensive discovery, etc.
- protomyth 17y agoYep, you nailed what I meant but didn't spend enough time writing. I just get this feeling that, given the number of companies involved, the patent situation is a known quantity for MPEG-LA, whereas the situation around Theora hasn't been as well researched. Unless someone with a massive amount of lawyers starts the ball rolling, I really don't see hardware people building accelerators into chipsets for Theora like they have done for h.264.
- AndrewDucker 17y agoThat's why you make it possible to plug in any video codec you like, and isolate them from the Mozilla Foundation itself.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoMozilla Foundation isn't trying to protect itself, it's trying to protect the web. You can disagree with that goal and/or with their strategy, but if you think it's just about Mozilla not wanting to pay fees then you're going to be very confused about what they do and why.