6 ms·
Holometer rules out first theory of space-time correlations
- Kinnard 11y agoThis pairs very well with Stephen Wolfram's recent piece on the true nature of space-time: a network https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10664272 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10664272 Published acoincidentally on the 100th anniversary of Einstein's original General Relativity Paper.
- powertower 11y agoThe results seem to disproves both: 1. A quantum foam space-time. 2. A networked/graphed space-time in which the nodes can have plank-scale (or larger) movements and re-arrangements. But I'm not sure if this experiment disproves a space-time of fixed-position nodes which have additional properties (such as a field of scalars / vectors / spinors / etc). To test the above I think measuring the smallest possible change-of-angle that a laser can make off a reflective surface (compounded X times) would do well. If the arrangement is as above, rotating the reflective surface by the smallest amount will affect the produced angle in a non-linear way (compared to larger amounts).
- c-slice 11y agoAlso seems to provide evidence against simulated reality.
- breakyerself 11y agoYou can zoom into a fractal image forever.
- powertower 11y agoIn a simulated environment the cost of computation grows exponentially. There would be a cutoff point.
- coldtea 11y agoDepends on the implementation. You don't have to describe infinite (or very many) ever smaller layers at all times -- as with the fractal example, you can just render them when someone looks at them (which is almost always never below some point) and only at those areas and levels in which they look (make measurements) at a particular moment. Besides, we assume a simulation that's uniformly behaving at all points. They designer of the simulation could very well hard-code the result of that experiment to be what it is.
- dangirsh 11y agoWhat counts as a "someone"?
- coldtea 11y agoAnyone outside the simulation for starters. If you run a simulation and zoom to a certain area, you want to see it properly "rendered". And people inside the simulation too, I guess. If they make measurements at some specific area and zoom level, you want them to get results for that level consistent with their model of the world -- not to have them see the "seams" of the simulation engine so to speak.
- chriswarbo 11y agoAs always, observer-dependent effects are actually information-dependent effects. In this case, the Universe is simulated as a single entity. Since the behaviour of the Universe depends on its contents (i.e. we can gain information about the contents by observing the overall entity), this coarse-grained simulation is forced to sub-divide into smaller regions. The simulation keeps subdividing (some regions more than others) until it reaches a level where some hard-coded criterion is reached that further subdivision will have no effect on the outcome. For example, if an entire planet is getting swallowed by a star, it is not useful to simulate each atom of the planet; just treat the whole thing as one entity. Unfortunately, the simulation has to spend a lot of resources simulating part of the Milky Way galaxy, because it contains a chaotic mechanism of "life", which may cause an observable effect on the Universe as a whole, e.g. by seeding galaxies with star-engulfing, self-replicating megastructures. In the region around Earth, the simulation was forced to sub-divide to a level we might call "classical mechanics", in order to calculate outcomes with enough precision. Unfortunately, during the 20th Century, more subdivision has become necessary, as "life" has begun performing "experiments" with a precision beyond that of the "classical mechanics" level. These experiments act as amplifiers, turning very small effects (such as the discrete nature of space) into large ones (such as the publication of scientific papers, development of technology, colonisation of intergalactic space, etc.). It turns out that the Universe is written in Haskell, and a "print" statement caused a thunk to be forced ;)
- qrendel 11y ago> If the universe were similarly segmented, then there would be a limit to the amount of information space-time could contain. I thought there is a limit to the amount of information spacetime can contain: the Bekenstein bound[1], and its variations[2]. Though it's related to the surface area bounding the region, and not the volume enclosed itself. For a spherical cubic cm, about 10^66 bits, iirc. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekenstein_bound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekenstein_bound [2] http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Bekenstein_bound http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Bekenstein_bound
- lpage 11y agoI'm wondering about that as well. The closely related covariant entropy bound is predicated on both the holographic principle and our current understanding of quantum gravity, so I'm not sure if this finding calls that into question or not. There was a good HN discussion on the theoretical limits of information density a few years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6466430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6466430
- jonbaer 11y agoThe first time I learned about this project was from the BBC Documentary on Reality (excellent BTW) ... here is the holometer segment ... https://youtu.be/DbqB0--Td28?t=2346 https://youtu.be/DbqB0--Td28?t=2346
- shmerl 11y ago> If the universe were similarly segmented, then there would be a limit to the amount of information space-time could contain. Not really, if those "pixels" are a countable set. Is still wouldn't be continuous, but it could hold any information. Symbolic elements ("pixels", letters etc.) actually are basis of information, so it kind of implies a discrete space when information is involved.
- Estragon 11y agoGood to see someone getting some press for a negative result.
- jonbaer 11y agoWhat I am wondering about is what the implications (and reactions) would have been if it were a positive result ...
- Estragon 11y agoFrom a purely scientific perspective the rational response would be to assume it's a yet-to-be-accounted-for experimental artifact, but no one in the reporting chain has an economic incentive to approach it that way.
- barrystaes 11y agoReading how sensitive this equipment can measure short duration displacements, and the distance the laser beams travel.. I wonder if - and how - they would adjust this for the drift due to the earth rotating. (and its speed is not even constant)
- danbruc 11y agoIt's probably even way worse. I think it was one of the gravity wave experiments and they talked about how they picked up signals from people walking in neighboring building, cars driving on the highway and even the ocean waves hitting the beach while the beach was fifty or a hundred or so kilometers away. Maybe it's as simple as a high pass filter but I'd also like to know more about the details. EDIT: It was probably not this exact article [1] but it matches my memories pretty well. They also mention some of the countermeasures. [1] http://www.nature.com/news/physics-wave-of-the-future-1.15561 http://www.nature.com/news/physics-wave-of-the-future-1.1556...
- danbruc 11y agoProbably biased by the physicist I mostly listen to because they have a lot of lectures and talks online, Leonard Susskind and Nima Arkani-Hamed. The idea that space is quantized is pretty unlikely to be true because of relativity, i.e. because of length contraction the size of those space quanta depends on the motion of the observer. So if you find those space quanta have a specific size in your reference frame I can just go to a reference frame moving relative to yours and I will see length contracted space quanta and we will therefore disagree on their size. It is actually believed that neither space nor time are fundamental but that they emerge from something more fundamental because spacetime, relativity and quantum physics taken together are not really compatible, see for example "Space-time is doomed. What replaces it?" [1]. Susskind explores the idea that entanglement is what holds space together under the name "ER = EPR" [2]. [1] http://www.cornell.edu/video/nima-arkani-hamed-spacetime-is-doomed http://www.cornell.edu/video/nima-arkani-hamed-spacetime-is-... [2] https://youtube.com/watch?v=OBPpRqxY8Uw https://youtube.com/watch?v=OBPpRqxY8Uw
- mstade 11y agoGreat links, thank you very much!
- danbruc 11y agoYou may also enjoy "The theoretical minimum" [1], a set of courses by Susskind covering physics from classical physics over relativity and quantum physics to string theory and cosmology. It's quite a bit beyond popular science and comes with math included but is still quite accessible if one is interested in some serious physics. [1] http://theoreticalminimum.com/ http://theoreticalminimum.com/
- qrendel 11y agoI'd be curious to know why the Planck length wouldn't be reference frame independent, though... (which may be explained in your links, but it will take some time to go through them).
- danbruc 11y ago
- yCloser 11y agoTL;DR: background-color: #e45950
- TranquilMarmot 11y agoMy eyes!
- iopq 11y agoI have not reached for the Inspect Element faster than seeing this abomination. Who thought that an all red webpage might be difficult on the eyes?
- ansgri 11y agoThis is more like 'salmon' than 'red'. Seems rather readable on a good display with low brightness. Unsafe choice for not art-specific website though.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]