6 ms·
I don't understand. This is how the tax code works. If you give the money away to charity the Government doesn't take income tax on it. That is a law that was p
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
I don't understand. This is how the tax code works. If you give the money away to charity the Government doesn't take income tax on it. That is a law that was passed. The whole point is to get people to give money to charities because that's a good thing.
- mystikal 11y agoThe point is that you can justify lower taxes if you have private donations to charities instead of state funding.
- sombremesa 11y agoThe article linked suggests that they are not giving any money away.
- secstate 11y agoEh, but you're assuming that money to charities is always a good thing. There are a) some pretty terrible charities out there and b) some patently fake charities that are designed as money laundering schemes. The tax code works because it was written by people who had huge amounts of wealth and were pissed that the federal government (the People of the U.S.) created an income tax. No other developed country has such crazy laws regarding charity donations as the U.S.
- lifeformed 11y agoSo why is everyone already assuming Mark's charity is going to be one of the terrible ones? I don't see why he wouldn't give an honest shot at improving the world, as a young idealist. Maybe he won't do a great job at it, but people should reserve judgement til then.
- zeofig 11y agoI'd say you're making the assumption that it will be used for good, when so many charities are indeed used for tax evasion (and other more nefarious purposes). When you condition these probabilities on how most charities actually operate, and on Zuckerberg's past behaviour, a high level of cynicism proves to be the rational position.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 11y agoMark hasn't been improving the Internet so far (actually FB made it worse in numerous ways), so why do you think he has any incentive to improve the world as a whole ?
- justinclift 11y agoFacebook is abusive of people's personal privacy, even though it is generally an effective tool for improving people's (layperson's?) communication. So, it's probably a better idea to approach it with a cynical perspective instead of an optimistic (naive?) one. It could turn out to not be estate-tax evasion... however it seems unlikely.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 11y ago> No other developed country has such crazy laws regarding charity donations as the U.S. Wrong. France has the "Association Loi 1901" law and it's pretty much the same thing, a money laundering scheme for most of the organizations benefiting from it - most of the time politicians using public money to finance such organizations where they put their friends and families in charge. This kind of things has no borders.
- n0us 11y agoI've wondered if the charity Claire Underwood works at in House of Cards was intended to be a commentary on this sort of thing. Claire takes a huge salary from donations by corporations, then Frank spends it. They seem to be intimately involved with San-Corp at every turn but there are lots of questions raised that never get answered. For example it's never explained why so much of the staff was rapidly cut, or why they pivoted to international work. I think they were even present in the whole Russo ordeal where the environmental initiative is replaced by natural gas after that bill fails. At the same time it is never directly implied that the CWI was an outright money laundering scheme.
- baddox 11y agoWell, implicit in this discussion is also the notion that tax revenue is always a good thing. I think both assumptions are poor, but I'd sure take charity over tax revenue any day of the week.
- roywiggins 11y agoIt's been argued that it gives a few incredibly wealthy people undue influence on public spending. Instead of being taxed and then spent according to the government's priorities, which is at some level accountable to the public, a few wealthy people get to decide what programs have merit and pour their money into them.
- mullingitover 11y agoEh, the United States spends a lot of that tax money on the military. I don't have a problem with wealthy people making their own call on the guns vs. butter question.
- mystikal 11y ago> I don't have a problem with wealthy people making their own call on the guns vs. butter question. You can donate to military organizations that fund warfare directly?
- interesting_att 11y agoExactly. Would you trust Mark Zuckerberg with spending 15bn for the supposed betterment of society, or would you trust the US government? Given that the US government wastes so much via corrupt deals, inefficiencies, insane surveillance, and absurd military spending- I would favor Zuckerberg directing the fund.
- burkemw3 11y ago"A lot" is relative. Wikipedia says the military is 17% of expenditures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expenditures_in_the_United_States_federal_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expenditures_in_the_United_Sta... This may or may not constitute a lot, depending on who you are.
- mullingitover 11y agoIf we're going to talk about relative military spending... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_...
- vilhelm_s 11y agoThis is not a charity in the tax sense (a 501(c) organization), it's a limited liability company. So if there are tax benefits, I don't think they come from a government policy to increase charitable spending.
- 542458 11y agoI don't understand this comment - You don't have to be a charity to do charitable works, and an LLC can be a charity. Note that the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a Foundation (which is not all that different from an LLC without shareholders from a tax+reporting perspective), and does lots of charitable works.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe tax treatment of a charitable foundation (as opposed to an LLC) is very different.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoNot a charity, it's an LLC investment vehicle.
- notacoward 11y agoBut is it really charity? Unfortunately, the charity exemption is given to many things that aren't very charitable at all, including some that are materially and intentionally bad for society (i.e. many that engage in overtly religious and/or political behavior). I'm willing to give Zuck the benefit of the doubt for being sincere and meaning well, but only time will tell if this is true charity.