10 ms·
Is the new Zuckerberg fake charity an estate tax avoidance scheme?
- tim333 11y agoEstate tax avoidance scheme? They've got about 60 years before they hit estate tax and giving away 99% of your money is a crap avoidance scheme.
- luckydude 11y agoI posted this on a different thread. I think it is tax avoidance. One way to look at this is that Zuckerberg just robbed the treasury of $45B. Part of that would have come in through capital gains taxes and the rest through the estate tax. What they do with that money is up to them, not the state. It's a pretty sweeping end run around the taxation system. Maybe we'll get lucky and he'll use the money to good end like Gates is doing. And maybe not. This is a heck of a tax code we've got, it's trickle down on a grand scale. reply
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI don't understand. This is how the tax code works. If you give the money away to charity the Government doesn't take income tax on it. That is a law that was passed. The whole point is to get people to give money to charities because that's a good thing.
- mystikal 11y agoThe point is that you can justify lower taxes if you have private donations to charities instead of state funding.
- sombremesa 11y agoThe article linked suggests that they are not giving any money away.
- secstate 11y agoEh, but you're assuming that money to charities is always a good thing. There are a) some pretty terrible charities out there and b) some patently fake charities that are designed as money laundering schemes. The tax code works because it was written by people who had huge amounts of wealth and were pissed that the federal government (the People of the U.S.) created an income tax. No other developed country has such crazy laws regarding charity donations as the U.S.
- lifeformed 11y agoSo why is everyone already assuming Mark's charity is going to be one of the terrible ones? I don't see why he wouldn't give an honest shot at improving the world, as a young idealist. Maybe he won't do a great job at it, but people should reserve judgement til then.
- zeofig 11y agoI'd say you're making the assumption that it will be used for good, when so many charities are indeed used for tax evasion (and other more nefarious purposes). When you condition these probabilities on how most charities actually operate, and on Zuckerberg's past behaviour, a high level of cynicism proves to be the rational position.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 11y agoMark hasn't been improving the Internet so far (actually FB made it worse in numerous ways), so why do you think he has any incentive to improve the world as a whole ?
- justinclift 11y agoFacebook is abusive of people's personal privacy, even though it is generally an effective tool for improving people's (layperson's?) communication. So, it's probably a better idea to approach it with a cynical perspective instead of an optimistic (naive?) one. It could turn out to not be estate-tax evasion... however it seems unlikely.
- roywiggins 11y agoIt's been argued that it gives a few incredibly wealthy people undue influence on public spending. Instead of being taxed and then spent according to the government's priorities, which is at some level accountable to the public, a few wealthy people get to decide what programs have merit and pour their money into them.
- mullingitover 11y agoEh, the United States spends a lot of that tax money on the military. I don't have a problem with wealthy people making their own call on the guns vs. butter question.
- mystikal 11y ago> I don't have a problem with wealthy people making their own call on the guns vs. butter question. You can donate to military organizations that fund warfare directly?
- interesting_att 11y agoExactly. Would you trust Mark Zuckerberg with spending 15bn for the supposed betterment of society, or would you trust the US government? Given that the US government wastes so much via corrupt deals, inefficiencies, insane surveillance, and absurd military spending- I would favor Zuckerberg directing the fund.
- burkemw3 11y ago"A lot" is relative. Wikipedia says the military is 17% of expenditures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expenditures_in_the_United_States_federal_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expenditures_in_the_United_Sta... This may or may not constitute a lot, depending on who you are.
- mullingitover 11y agoIf we're going to talk about relative military spending... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_...
- vilhelm_s 11y agoThis is not a charity in the tax sense (a 501(c) organization), it's a limited liability company. So if there are tax benefits, I don't think they come from a government policy to increase charitable spending.
- 542458 11y agoI don't understand this comment - You don't have to be a charity to do charitable works, and an LLC can be a charity. Note that the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a Foundation (which is not all that different from an LLC without shareholders from a tax+reporting perspective), and does lots of charitable works.
- prostoalex 11y agoThe tax treatment of a charitable foundation (as opposed to an LLC) is very different.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoNot a charity, it's an LLC investment vehicle.
- notacoward 11y agoBut is it really charity? Unfortunately, the charity exemption is given to many things that aren't very charitable at all, including some that are materially and intentionally bad for society (i.e. many that engage in overtly religious and/or political behavior). I'm willing to give Zuck the benefit of the doubt for being sincere and meaning well, but only time will tell if this is true charity.
- hsitz 11y agoMost charitable gifts are a form of tax avoidance (and _all_ of them potentially are if a person's income is such that it makes sense to take advantage of itemized deductions). People get receipts for charitable contributions precisely so they can deduct those amounts from their taxable income. Zuckerberg's plan is of much larger scale, but the fact is that the tax code is set up to encourage charitable contributions by making them non-taxable. The tax code is set up this way, quite understandably, to encourage individuals to make charitable gifts, by creating an extra "bang-for-your-buck" for people who choose to make them. The linked article seems to suggest that Zuckerberg is trying to take advantage of the system by gaining tax-exempt status while effectively _not_ making charitable gifts, that he is somehow trying to pass everything to the child while taking advantage of tax-exempt status of a charitable organization. I'm skeptical both that his intent is to try to do this, and that there is any scheme that could legally accomplish this. On a different, but related, note, if I were a parent with $40Bn (or $30Bn, $20Bn, $10Bn, or even $1Bn) I would certainly avoid any plan where the bulk of my estate was to be left to my child. Having that much money is a big responsibility, and it's not something that's likely to add to a person's quality of life. Quite the contrary, it's likely a hindrance, not something I would want to saddle my child with. At most, leave them some large amount ($5M, $10M, $20M, $50M?), something basically guaranteed to make them a wealthy person who doesn't need to worry about money, but hopefully not enough to require that responsible management of their fortune be a main focus of their life. (I realize there are moral implications of having that much money for anyone who has even $10M -- perhaps even $1M -- but when the amounts get astronomical, say to hundreds of millions or more, the moral responsibility really does -- or should -- become almost overwhelming. Not a burden I'd want to put on my child.)
- dizzyviolet 11y agoI've never understood that about deducting charitable donations. I've always had the principle that I shouldn't be getting anything for my charity. Otherwise, it wouldn't really be a donation to me. It would be make it conditional. I'm giving this money away, but give me some back from the taxpayers? I might sound like a sucker, but that's just always been my thought on it. My mother once said something to me like that as a kid and I've applied it donating.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoWell, it is proportionally less money for the things that are funded the most by the government.
- ganeumann 11y agoThis, obviously, does not make sense. The entire $45billion would not have been given over to taxes.
- mattzito 11y agoIt's an LLC, isn't it? That means that the LLC will pay capital gains tax when the stock is sold. The government gets its money either way. The estate planning part is more complex, I'm not qualified to answer that, but even in that article the linked option basically talks about how you can get a 40% discount on the value, but the estate tax basically kicks in regardless once you transfer LLC shares to your kids. So it's not quite as cut-and-dried as saying, "Zuckerberg just robbed the treasury of $45b"
- mikeryan 11y agoNo the loopholes is that if the LLC donates the appreciated shares to charity it will get a deduction of the fair market value. However if a tax-exempt entity (Charity) then sells the stock it does not pay capital gains.
- csmajorfive 11y agoThe same is true if he donates the shares directly without going through an LLC.
- mikeryan 11y agoBut then the money doesn't get the protections and shelter as part of the LLC which may very well likely invest as a for-profit entity. In other words there are other reasons to create the LLC that aren't about avoiding taxes. And my point still stands this way there is no capital gains paid [edit] on shares donated to charities. Yes there may be taxes paid on shares donated to for-profit entities or liquidated by the LLC. There's multiple scenarios here my capital gains comments only refers to donations of shares directly to a non-taxable entity.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cdcarter 11y agoIf any of the shares the LLC holds are donated to a public charity, there will be no tax implications for the LLC, as if Z donated the shares directly or operated a private foundation, and without any of the freedoms of the LLC. If any of the shares the LLC holds are liquidated by the LLC or granted to for-profits, situations where the "other reasons to create the LLC" are in effect, capital gains tax WILL be owed. The LLC is as if he held the shares personally, when it comes to capital gains. The estate situation is very different, not cut and dry, and that's what is being discussed in this article.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeryan 11y agoThere's a better article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/04/business/dealbook/how-mark-zuckerbergs-altruism-helps-himself.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/04/business/dealbook/how-mark...
- csmajorfive 11y agoThey do not avoid capital gains taxes by doing this. Also, more broadly, when you see a "sweeping end run around the taxation system", it may be instructive to consider why everyone else doesn't just do the same. Legal tax avoidance techniques are not secrets.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- logn 11y ago> why everyone else doesn't just do the same When your upside on doing fancy tax maneuvers is several billion, you can afford IRS lawsuits. And you can afford the initial time for a lawyer to set this all up. Average people are using Turbo Tax for yearly taxes and relying on common law to handle their estate, because that's all they can afford.
- dools 11y agoYou can't rob the treasury of USD ... The US government creates USD when it spends.
- duncan_bayne 11y ago"What they do with that money is up to them, not the state. " That's how property works, you know. Hopefully this represents a step away from compulsory taxation as a society.
- zizee 11y agoHow the heck would a modern society function without some sort of compulsory taxation?
- duncan_bayne 11y agoThere are a lot of questions wrapped up in yours :) Briefly: if you pare Government back to core functions, you don't need much money. In New Zealand, we (meaning the Libertarianz) estimated it at around $2,500 / working adult / year. That (back at the turn of the 21st century) would get you courts, police, Parliament, defense, embassies and the glue to run it all. Then you need a way of raising the money. Probably, most working people can afford $2,500 per year to keep civilisation running, especially if they're not paying any other taxes. Maybe a poll tax? Seems reasonable that those paying also do the voting. Could simply solicit donations, or maybe run a lottery. But no: you couldn't run a socialist country that way. Which is sort of the point :)
- tolmasky 11y agoWell as long as he doesn't use half of it to start a bunch of wars in the middle east, we'll probably end up ahead of what would have happened if it would have gone to taxes. As you said, if Gates' leadership is followed, I think we'll end up wayyyy ahead of what would happen if it goes to taxes (especially if you consider that ironically enough many of the people that actually need the help might get it - like poor in other countries benefiting from malaria cures, vs whatever domestic interests would do with the money here)
- joshmn 11y ago"The only solution to the current tax system is to make more rules, so it's more convoluted than ever." — every politician. No, what we need is to trim down the fat that your liberal arts degree decide to fluff in there for the sake of your ego.
- gizi 11y agoWait a second. Mark did not steal his money. It is his money. Hence, he does what he likes with it. If you believe the estate tax department should have his money, let them set up a Facebook project. What is stopping them from creating similar value? Are they really waiting until someone else does it, to leech from him?
- zgohr 11y agoYou believe the government had no hand in the success Facebook has had?
- gizi 11y agoCausality is something that you prove in repeatable experiments. Where are the repeatable experiments backing your claim?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- quadrangle 11y ago> Mark did not steal his money If theft is defined solely by law, then you are correct. > creating similar value Facebook does not create value, it merely captures it. I suspect you subscribe to a simplistic economic ideology that does not even recognize the existence of a create vs capture distinction.
- gizi 11y ago> Facebook does not create value, it merely captures it. That is not up to any of us to decide. In the meanwhile, the world population has voted with its feet on exactly that subject. Technology is a meritocracy. Seriously, nobody cares about the ideological manifest of the one or the other communist party. It is technology that runs the world and not any unproductive, imbecile political opinion. Furthermore, technology overrules politics. Time after time, with new technology we bring the political idiots to their knees, and we shall keep doing so.
- 55555 11y agoThere's no way to know; only time will tell. He either genuinely wants to maximize his charitable contribution to the world, or he just wants to avoid capital gains and estate taxes, and the smart choice of action (that which he has taken) is the same in either case.
- ilyanep 11y agoMan, is anyone else seriously bummed out by how cynically everyone is viewing this announcement? There's a rich guy who founded an organization, ostensibly with the hopes of doing something good with all that money that he owns. Maybe the organization doesn't go anywhere, or maybe he winds up paying less in taxes. Can't we all hope for the other side of the coin -- that he does wind up doing good for the world? Why not wait and see?
- jrcii 11y agoBetter a 5% chance it does good than a 100% chance it's squandered on bureaucracy and inefficient solutions to problems other tax dollars went to creating.
- jMyles 11y agoI'm surprised this isn't a more popular opinion. Whatever ethical questions may lie in forming a "charity" with an unknown level of veracity, there are also ethical questions in giving the money to an organization that will, without a doubt, surveil, imprison, torture, and murder.
- username223 11y ago> a 100% chance it's squandered on bureaucracy and inefficient solutions to problems other tax dollars went to creating. After all, there's absolutely no chance that you are able to choose people to do thankless tasks upon which your life depends (disposing of sewage, supplying potable water, maintaining roads, ...).
- thatswrong0 11y agoUm those expenditures are absolutely tiny compared to the total of government spending.
- username223 11y agoHow many votes do you get toward Zuckerberg's spending?
- sremani 11y agoIf it were are tax avoidance scheme, Mr.Zukerberg would have been well served if it was all kept silent from public. For all his flaws, Mr.Zukerberg seems to be a guy who cares, and he will have my benefit of doubt until proven other wise. The vitriolic reaction to his announcement is uncalled for.
- hackerboos 11y agoYou're mixing the meanings of tax avoidance and tax evasion. Zukerberg is not breaking the law, he's legally structuring his finances to avoid capital gains. The fact that these gaping loopholes in the tax code is combination of incompetence and corruption.
- dumbfcks 11y agoZuck: Yeah so if you ever need info about anyone at Harvard Zuck: Just ask Zuck: I have over 4,000 emails, pictures, addresses, SNS [Redacted Friend's Name]: What? How'd you manage that one? Zuck: People just submitted it. Zuck: I don't know why. Zuck: They "trust me" Zuck: Dumb fucks https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg
- yankoff 11y agoJust because he was an idiot while in college doesn't mean he can't change and do something good.
- whybroke 11y ago>...an idiot while in college... But "Young people are just smarter" -Mark Zuckerberg [1] [1]http://venturebeat.com/2007/03/26/start-up-advice-for-entrepreneurs-from-y-combinator-startup-school/ http://venturebeat.com/2007/03/26/start-up-advice-for-entrep...
- sombremesa 11y agoGood point. Why is anyone in prison? We should just let them all run free because we have optimism and faith in their ability to self-reform.
- yankoff 11y agoThe question is not about a proper punishment for a crime, the question is whether a person still can do a good thing after he previously fucked up. People bring his previous silly actions as if it proves he can't do anything good. It simply doesn't.
- ekianjo 11y agoHe was not an idiot, he was smart and manipulative. That's rather the opposite of an idiot. Assuming that he stopped being manipulative now that he's rich would be rather the stupid thing to consider. He's rich now because behaving this way has worked well for him.
- facebookcia 11y ago> The letter is a significant addition to the literature of comparative American victimhood: “Can we truly empower everyone — women, children, underrepresented minorities, immigrants and the unconnected?” Expect FWD.us and similar outfits to be showered with cash.
- ganeumann 11y agoGreenspun would read the worst into whatever Zuckerberg did here, as seen by him starting the post criticizing the timing of Zuckerberg's marriage. Why not assume the best? Zuckerberg said he planned to give away 99% of his wealth to help other people. That's a good thing. Why criticize him now? If he ends up not doing it, criticize him then. If all he was doing was trying to avoid some estate taxes, he could have done that without any announcement at all, certainly drawing less scrutiny. Scrutiny is important here, because the IRS could disallow the application of the LLC estate planning loophole here just by saying so. The 40% discount for non-management shares is an accounting judgement, not a law, and not one the IRS need accept if it believes the sole purpose is to evade taxes.
- bcg1 11y agoHe didn't say he would give away 99% of his wealth. He said he would use 99% of their Facebook shares to fund their agenda. And he said they would do that with 99% of his shares over their lifetime... if they were 'giving away 99% of their wealth' they could just do that today. As it happens, they can still realize significant returns from those funds in the meantime, and probably end up richer than when they started. The pattern of manipulative billionaires sheltering their legacies like this is not new; see Rockefeller, Carnegie, Ford, Gates, etc.
- soared 11y agoWhat the fuck? You don't even make an argument with this comment. You just bashed the rich.
- hackerboos 11y agoZuckerberg is not accountable at the ballot box the same way politicians are. If it is tax avoidance then, as a commenter above pointed out, he's robbing the treasury of billions of dollars that should be spent by government. Some of us don't have the luxury of avoiding taxes and some of us deem it highly unethical when people do.
- seunosewa 11y ago
- zatkin 11y agoHas there ever been a multi-billionaire/millionaire that did the same thing?
- peterjlee 11y agoI don't think Zuckerberg is trying to avoid estate tax but even if he is and if he's doing it legally, this is something we should complain to the Congress for writing bad tax code.
- x5n1 11y ago$45 billion dollars for me. $0 for the US government. Why did they give me this tax avoidance loophole? Same reasons those "dumb fucks" gave me all their personal information, I guess. It's good to be King.
- zkhalique 11y agoSomehow from what I know of Mark Zuckerberg, he's not exactly looking to sit on all those billions. The motives the article is imputing to him are wrong.
- onewaystreet 11y agoI wonder how many wealthy people are reading all of this criticism of Zuckerberg and are thinking to themselves: "On second thought, I'll just buy another boat." Remember how cool it was when Larry Ellison spent $500 million on that Hawaii island?
- prostoalex 11y agoThere are two sides to every transaction. Someone who owned fairly illiquid Hawaiian land now has $500,000,000. Perhaps they would do something with it.
- datashovel 11y agoGenerally speaking I'd say it's far healthier world when we don't think we're all dependent on billionaires to make the world a better place. Also far healthier world when billionaires don't actually believe they're responsible for illuminating the world's path to salvation. IMO the criticism is warranted, and there is a clear path Zuckerberg could take to quash all of the bad publicity. While he may be surprised people are calling him out, I say good for them. Why let anyone pull wool over your eyes voluntarily?
- logicallee 11y agono, next question.
- datax 11y agoit is possible.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoMore generally I've never understood why charity is tax free. When I or others to give money to charity that is great and I support that. But why do so many expect they can take from the governments pocket when funding a cause they believe in? Dont get me wrong, I understand 'the logic' to encourage charitable giving this is a net positive. In my home country charities are often abused by business and individuals. Given increasing sophistication and selfishness of individuals non-profits and charities should be taxed like any other organisation. Ideally real charities would have very low tax rates anyway. They typically distribute income to causes creating expenses against income, basically turning them into very low margin and subsequently low tax business. And those that abuse this structure or hoard income can pay tax like any other business. Little bit controversial I know but I find this tax-free relationship is taken as 'its the way it is' without further thought.
- tim333 11y agoA couple of reasons: It's better for society if the rich give money to medical research and the like rather than buying yachts and jets so why not encourage it. If they taxed donations you could achieve the same effect tax wise by say Facebook spending money directly on medical research - $1bn blown on reseach is $1bn less taxable profit. But it's messy that way. The present system's cleaner.
- haberman 11y agoYou're not the only one: http://www.economist.com/node/21556570 http://www.economist.com/node/21556570
- steve19 11y agoThe simple reason, at least in democracies, is that voters want charities to be tax free. If they did not care, you can be damned sure tax-free status would be dropped. I don't think there is any more complex moral reasoning than this. I for one would never vote for a party advocating taxing donations. As to what constitutes a charity ... well that is another debate [0] [0] http://mentalfloss.com/article/18575/ikea-worlds-largest-charity http://mentalfloss.com/article/18575/ikea-worlds-largest-cha...
- necessity 11y agoIf it is, good on him. Estate tax is just tax on something that has already been taxed.
- kspaans 11y agoThe money you use to buy stuff also (usually) pays consumption taxes. Yet that money was income that you've already paid income tax on. Should consumption taxes be abolished?
- necessity 11y agoIf it were possible, yes. It is actually a big problem, specially on countries that heavily depend on it (such as Brazil), since the poor can't escape it and it affects them badly. The poor are the ones who pay more taxes proportionally because of that, in Brazil[1], whereas whoever owns a business (small or big) can usually avoid some taxes. [1] http://noticias.r7.com/record-news/video/populacao-de-baixa-renda-paga-mais-impostos-no-brasil-4defa15db51a597468aec95b http://noticias.r7.com/record-news/video/populacao-de-baixa-...
- csmajorfive 11y agoIt would be pretty strange to tell the IRS that he's discounting the transfers 40% after publicly stating "we receive no tax benefit from transferring our shares." If you believe in the government's ability to allocate money, you should probably believe in its ability to collect it, too.
- gopi 11y agoFoundation or LLC, when Mark dies only 1% of his wealth will be passed to his kids...If this is not Generosity i don't know which is
- tzs 11y ago> The letter to our daughter works pretty well as comedy, e.g., “Medicine has only been a real science…” (emphasis added). I'm not sure what the author is trying to say here. He cut out important context. The "..." was "for less than 100 years". While one might quibble with the exact number, Zuckerberg was reasonably in the ballpark. > It also works pretty well as a dictionary example of “optimism”, with Zuckerberg imagining that a $1 billion annual budget is going to move the needle (NIH spent $31 billion in 2010, according to Wikipedia, and the drug companies keep telling us that they are spending some of their Irish dough on research) The Gates Foundation spends about $4 billion a year, spread over many different kinds of initiatives. Their health spending is "only" about $1 billion a year, and they move the needle there. I see no reason the Zuckerbergs can't move the needle at $1 billion per year as long as they don't spend in too many disparate areas. Here's an article from NPR that explains why it can be more effective to do charity and activism through an LLC instead of through a non-profit foundation: http://www.npr.org/2015/12/03/458276386/facebook-founder-to-give-away-his-fortune-through-for-profit-company http://www.npr.org/2015/12/03/458276386/facebook-founder-to-... Some excerpts: "A foundation itself is not allowed to do what the Internal Revenue Code defines as lobbying," he says. "If you're trying to achieve a social end through advocacy, you're going to find yourself very constrained, whereas if you're just paying it out of your own pocket if you're a company or an LLC, there are really no constraints at all, at least imposed by the tax code." In a public letter to their newborn daughter, Chan and Zuckerberg said about their philanthropic goals, "We must participate in policy and advocacy to shape debates." and Mollie Cullinane, who runs a law firm that specializes in philanthropic giving, says creating an LLC instead of a nonprofit looks like a move by Chan and Zuckerberg "to get more deeply involved in advocacy and promotion of certain causes that other charities and foundations can't speak out about as loudly." and But beyond politics, there are other ways an LLC will give the couple philanthropic flexibility. "There's a whole new area opening up, so-called impact investing, where you invest in a for-profit organization that has a social mission," Brest says. So the couple might invest in clean energy companies, for example, and could make money off those investments. Foundations can do some of that. But, Brest says, "you are freer from any restrictions if you simply do it through a private company."
- 11y ago
- punee 11y agoOkay, so now I'd like someone honest to read this whole thread and tell me with a straight face that Hacker News is "full of libertarians", as I read here from time to time. I mean, there's someone here who doesn't understand why some people try to lower their tax bill by "taking from the government's pocket", and it goes completely unnoticed. I can't be the only one to find this hilarious?
- umaguma 11y agoA letter apologizing for his wrongs, announcing that Facebook will no longer collect personal information and that it will exist for users not advertisers, as well as promising to refrain from ever using the word "hacker" again to refer to himself or anyone at Facebook. "Move fast and break things." Privacy: broken. Won't fix. Sorry.
- Aloha 11y agoFacebook is not, nor has ever been a charity for its users benefit - anyone presuming you can operate a business (or a successful anything) with no cash flow is deluding themselves, advertising is a free and easy way to get cash flow. The users freely give their personal information to Facebook for the benefits they obtain from it, its well disclosed what Facebook is going to do with that information, and Facebook gives you a modicum of control over how that information is presented to the general public. I don't know what more people expect.
- ricksplat 11y agoThere probably is a sneaky aspect to all this, but having seen the benefits of private philanthropy up close (to whit: Gates Foundation providing otherwise unaffordable HIV medication in southern Africa) I'd be slow to dismiss outright. It's not ideal, but for the people to whom this matters it makes not a jot of difference.
- stillsut 11y agoAt issue here is _not_ whether this one instance (Zuck) is a tax coward or a much needed 21st century philanthropist. Instead this is about whether our tax-code can raise tax rates on business-owning millionaires and billionaires to arbitrarily high levels and capture the desired revenue. Economic historians have documented this type of tax avoidance in previous era of high taxes. When an executive was taxed 90% of his income, his salary was greatly decreased and instead got 2-weeks time on the company's (pre-tax) yacht. These type of "global charities" are very disturbing at this moment when it is becoming clear that tax rate will need to be increased substantially in the future to pay for our growing deficit. Which means it will become increasingly desirable to be employed or make deals with one of these shell corporations (zero tax), while all the boring but actually essential things like construction will face huge tax burdens. Ultimately, the big fear is that it will become completely rational to spend more effort trying to game the IRS then it will to do IRL value-add. (see Michael Lewis's piece on Greece in the run-up to '08 to see what this looks like)