7 ms·
The Microbes in Your Gut May Be Making You Fat (2013)
- shiftpgdn 11y agoThe ads on this page triggered my antivirus (legitimately). A forewarning for anyone not running noscript/adblocker.
- zurn 11y agoOfftopic: anyone know a tool or service to diagnose pages for Windows malware for those of us who aren't on Windows?
- DHJSH 11y agoHow can you create matter out of thin air? Overeating makes people fat. Period.
- MisterBastahrd 11y ago"Making you fat." No, that isn't how obesity works. What you put in your face is directly responsible for how fat you become. The microbes are just a factor, they aren't the root cause.
- windexh8er 11y agoI'm not sure it's quite that simple. There hasn't been much research around gut biome, however that's changing. This topic has been coming up much more recently and I've recently been reading "The Good Gut: Taking Control of Your Weight, Your Mood, and Your Long-term Health" by two Stanford researchers (Justin & Erica Sonnenburg). Just the first few chapters expose evidence that the simple correlation between consumption and static result is simply not true. The gut biome clearly plays a much more important role that we truly understand at this point in time.
- stray 11y agoYou'll never convince the calories in/calories out crowd that there is still room for scientific inquiry. They are convinced. And they will entertain no opposing ideas.
- RIMR 11y agoCalories in / Calories out is still perfectly valid. It's just that the same portion of the same food might be considered a different number of "calories in" for different people. The "big-boned" or "genetically fat" arguments still reek of BS, but it's worth humoring the idea that we aren't 100% efficient machines that absorb the exact number of calories on the Nutrition Facts box, or burn the exact number of calories displayed on the Treadmill screen... There's a intelligent middle-ground between equally ridiculous ideas that we are "Healthy at Every Size" and that we are perfectly tuned biological machines.
- vonmoltke 11y agoThat's the problem with the so-called "calories in/calories out" crowd: they think all food has a specific energy value that varies by statistically-insignificant amounts from person to person. That people lose weight when they eat an energy deficiency and gain it when they eat an energy surplus is not in doubt. What some people refuse to do is evaluate whether the same foods have different energy values for different people, rather than one global value. I'm not saying they do, but the most ardent "calories in/calories out" fanatics refuse to even acknowledge the question.
- RIMR 11y agoI think human discipline is the most important factor in maintaining a healthy weight, and I find instances of "fatlogic" to be aggravating, but I'm not going to pretend that the human body is so simple that the Law of Conservation of Energy can be perfectly applied to our digestive systems...
- npsimons 11y ago
- xsmasher 11y agoThe question is, how MUCH of a difference does your digestive efficiency make. 5% ? 10% ? I doubt there are people getting twice as many calories out of a meal than the average person.
- stray 11y agoAnother good question is whether the gut flora have any effect on the brain. And if so, how much?
- DanBC 11y agohttp://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n10/full/tp201498a.html http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n10/full/tp201498a.html
- learc83 11y ago5% more efficient with a 2,000 calorie diet is 100 calories per day. That's about 10 extra pounds worth of calories per year.
- RIMR 11y ago>What you put in your face is directly responsible for how fat you become. To be equally pedantic, it's not what you "put in your face", but how much. Microbes are a factor in weight gain and weight loss just like diet and exercise are also factors. There is no "one simple trick" to lose weight, there are a variety of factors that, if understood, can help us understand the safest, most efficient ways to maintain a healthy weight.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThis is ideology, and not a very useful one either. Humans are just animals, and despite the illusion of will power and decisions and all that other junk, we eat as we do because 500,000 years ago our ancestors risked famine constantly. We're optimized against lack of calories, and not optimized for excess calories at all. What this means is that, for the vast majority of people, if you have it to put it in your face, you will, and while you can occasionally refuse this, you won't do so often enough to matter unless your a "fitness" fetishist (fit for what?).
- MisterBastahrd 11y agoThe vast majority of people are not obese, yet they have 24/7 access to food. Seems like there's a disconnect in your reasoning there.
- DanBC 11y ago> The vast majority of people are not obese, Obesity rates in the US are pretty high. http://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statistics/Pages/overweight-obesity-statistics.aspx http://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/health-statistic... > More than 2 in 3 adults are considered to be overweight or obese. > More than 1 in 3 adults are considered to be obese. > More than 1 in 20 adults are considered to have extreme obesity. > About one-third of children and adolescents ages 6 to 19 are considered to be overweight or obese. > More than 1 in 6 children and adolescents ages 6 to 19 are considered to be obese.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The vast majority of people are not obese, yet they have 24/7 access to food. The vast majority of people in the world do not have access to bountiful food. In the US, where the vast majority do have such access, an absolute majority are at least overweight, and more than a third are obese.
- MisterBastahrd 11y agoI'm speaking in the context of the Western world, because we aren't particularly interested in studies of the indigent. The US is overweight because of the quality and quantity of food they eat. And 66%? That's a vast majority.
- vidarh 11y agoThe problem with that idea is that we know that we are exceedingly bad at regulating our food intake. And as long as we struggle with finding ways to reliably regulate our intake by adjusting how much and what we eat, if there are simple ways to regulate the calorie intake by reducing uptake from the stomach that will still potentially help a huge amount of people.
- daenz 11y agoWhen your calories in is greater than your calories out, you gain fat. The point that the article is making is that one collection of gut bacteria may be more efficient at extracting calories from the same food than another collection, resulting in more "calories in." What is disconcerting is the idea of engineering your gut bacteria to be less efficient at absorbing calories and nutrients in order to not require self control about what you give your body in the first place.
- Roritharr 11y agoIt's just a form of hedonism, nothing our society looks down upon in other areas. Optimize for happiness isn't the worst path to walk down in life.
- DanBC 11y agoThe gut flora can cause feelings of not hungry, so it's plausible they can cause feelings of hungry. If that's true then manipulating gut flora is less about allowing people to have no self control, but about helping people get back self control.
- daenz 11y agoSorry, the article doesn't say that at all. It does say: "If you want to stay lean, you'll want bacteria that are not very efficient," says Claire Fraser, a professor of medicine and microbiology and immunology at the University of Maryland School of Medicine.
- DanBC 11y agoHere's a link that shows gut flora can cause people to feel not hungry. http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n10/full/tp201498a.html http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n10/full/tp201498a.html
- dragonwriter 11y ago> When your calories in is greater than your calories out, you gain fat. Wrong. Calorie surplus is neither necessary for nor a guarantee of fat gain. When your calories in are greater than your calories out, you gain net energy content of body mass. If you have very low body fat already, you aren't going to be able to gain lean body mass without increasing net energy content, which means a calorie surplus; and a calorie surplus can sometimes, AFAIK, be beneficial in building lean body mass even if you haven't already driven your body fat %age to a very low level. Conversely, you can gain body fat while losing lean body mass with a calorie deficit. > What is disconcerting is the idea of engineering your gut bacteria to be less efficient at absorbing calories and nutrients in order to not require self control about what you give your body in the first place. Why is that disconcerting? If excessive efficiency in this one function is associated with adverse health outcomes, and people with less efficient (than the level raising concern) gut microbiomes tend toward healthier weights and better health outcomes, preference for maximum efficiency in this area is a harmful microoptimization, like optimizing a firm's software development operations for maximum lines of code produced per day rather than business functionality delivered.
- louprado 11y ago"If you want to stay lean, you'll want bacteria that are not very efficient" I hope this article isn't suggesting that it is preferable to have less efficient digestive systems so that we can all eat more. Given the environmental impact of food production these efficient digestion microbes are something we should encourage. Maybe they are harmful because of insulin spikes ? But the article doesn't mention this.
- speeder 11y agoThe problem is the efficiency in different things. I have a disease that makes me very inefficient in absorbing protein and vitamins. The amount of stuff (in both food, and actual medicinal supplements) I consume to just keep my body working, of course has calories in it, I don't want a efficient calorie absorption...
- jobu 11y agoThat seems to be the suggestion, but I wonder if it's the the wrong hypothesis. What if some bacteria have evolved to "hack" the metabolic signals from our guts (and possibly other mammals)? They could stimulate ghrelin to make us want more food to feed them. Or slow down food progress through the gut to give them more time to reproduce.
- CuriouslyC 11y agoYou're partly right. The primary byproduct of bacterial fermentation is short-chain fatty acids. These do in fact stimulate the release of peptide YY, which reduces gastric motility. It is extremely unlikely that the bacteria are the ones "hacking" us though; short chain fatty acid production is the result of fairly ubiquitous, low level pathways whereas modulation of hormone release is a fairly specialized, high level function.
- zurn 11y agoThe energy surplus builds up obesity is on the order of 1%. It's not nothing, but it is marginal compared to the effect of food type choices do to the environment. Environmentally the chief problem is that we are gorging ourselves on luxury foods (red meat as prime offender) that do enormous amounts of environmental damage and are actively harmful to our bodies. More broadly using the majority of farmland for animal feed is the issue. We need a major shift of diets to veggie. (Awareness of animal treatment issues in the meat industry would help the cause too, but tangential issue...)
- djsumdog 11y agoStop eating carbs. Stop eating bread, pasta, beans, chips, rice and potatoes. They're not healthy. They never have been. They're pure starch. Calories from sugar are waaaay worse than calories from fat. Low fat doesn't work. Low carb, high fat is the way to go. Keto, Adkins, etc...They work. But they're not diets. It's a healthy lifestyle choice. It needs to be a change in your life. Two years ago I was 70kg. Now I'm 59 ~ 61kg on average, I have more muscle mass, more energy and I feel great. Also cholesterol isn't bad for you. It fixes the damage caused by sugar to clog your arteries. No sugar, you can have a ton of cholesterol and dietary cholesterol doesn't affect blood cholesterol in most people anyway.
- mlucero 11y agoPlease don't listen to blanket nonsense like stop eating carbs. They are not unhealthy, and serve as fuel for whatever exercise/activity you choose to do. Exercise more and eat a well balanced diet including carbs, fat, and protein.
- Domenic_S 11y agoComments like this piss me off so much. The article was about the role of gut microbes in weight loss, and you're here preaching diet advice that has nothing to do with the article.
- RIMR 11y agoBut it worked for me, so it must work for everyone right? /s This is literally what these studies on gut flora are disproving...
- xutopia 11y agoThe top comment does the same thing telling people to worry about caloric intake when the evidence is with higher protein and fat diets to lose weight.
- sixothree 11y agoI sometimes wish people who submit links could moderate the comments section directly and mark items as off-topic.