4 ms·
Intelligence and nuttery/crackpottery are two separate things. In fact, intelligence can even enable nuttery because an intelligent nut is better at rationalizi
by philwelch 11y ago
Intelligence and nuttery/crackpottery are two separate things. In fact, intelligence can even enable nuttery because an intelligent nut is better at rationalizing his own nuttery than an unintelligent nut. Someone can be literally a world-class brain surgeon and still believe that the pyramids were constructed to store grain, for instance.
- scoot 11y agoOr any number of otherwise intelligent people who hold spiritual beliefs.
- spinchange 11y agoHis example is poignant because it falls out of even normative doctrine in the cultural/religious context it's referencing. It's like a double-inconsistency and yet...the guy can separate conjoined twins at the head. (Shaking mine.)
- fleitz 11y agoSmart people are outliers, hence their ideas are also outliers. Also, never underestimate the intelligence required to tailor a message to its audience.
- frenchy 11y ago> still believe that the pyramids were constructed to store grain, for instance. But, in civ 2, the pyramids gave you a granary in every city, so obviously they were for storing grain!
- rtpg 11y agoI really like the idea that Carson played Civ and thus holds this tidbit of knowledge
- cat-dev-null 11y agoFour factors: 0. Intelligence is hard to "measure;" and even informally, there are mostly inferred attribute from a subject's performance filtered through the viewer's (fallible/biased) perception. 1. There's many domains of intelligence: - critical thinking (i.e., lawyers) - fact memory - abstract thinking - spatial - problem solving - social - political - emotional ... and far too many others to list. 2. Biases - upbringing, environment, experiences and so on tend to influence a person's preferences and beliefs, and they may be expressing what it is their social group expects or how they view themselves. 3. I'm sure there is at least one belief each of us clings to that others find wacky. Sometimes person don't pick up that a certain view is social unacceptable. Examples: - The guy in Starbucks with backpack supporting "the missile men of gaza"... de-facto endorsement of terrorism. - I happen to be vegetarian (not driving around with "meat is murder" and slaughterhouse shame pictures)... a lot of people are offended by that and heap on certain biases. - People struggling to survive, yet don't support unions, basic income or higher taxes on large trusts and estates, and are still libertarian "completely unregulated market" types.
- colordrops 11y agoThe comments in this thread are exceptionally ironic.
- fab13n 11y ago> a world-class brain surgeon can believe that the pyramids were constructed to store grain Carson is a world-class surgeon trying to convince whatever subset of the Republicans (a) can decide the outcome of the primary and (b) aren't already secured by Trump. He probably says whatever nonsense he thinks will please rednecks with a 90 IQ and an sinking feeling that "their" country and its core values are being pulled from under their feet. And I can understand if he's a hard time empathising with people who think that >6k years ago, when pyramids where built, the Earth didn't even exist. TL;DR: I think/hope he's failing at understanding plebeians, not Life. It might be wishful thinking because I don't want to live in a world where someone could be both so smart and so dumb.
- gnoway 11y agoThis isn't a new position for him, unfortunately. Here's a link to a video[0] of him in 1998 explaining it at a commencement speech. I guess this could be taken out of context, and he's actually just being sarcastic, but I don't think so. [0] http://www.buzzfeed.com/natemcdermott/ben-carson-egyptian-pyramids-built-for-grain-storage-not-by#.riR87RbZj http://www.buzzfeed.com/natemcdermott/ben-carson-egyptian-py...
- dhimes 11y agoAnd I can understand if he's a hard time empathising with people who think that >6k years ago, when pyramids where built, the Earth didn't even exist. I think he's one of those people, actually. https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/ben-carsons-creationist-views-spark-controvery-over-commencement-speech/2012/05/08/gIQAi0vsBU_blog.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/ben-c...
- cookiecaper 11y agoThe problem is that you assume people who feel their country and its core values are being pulled are necessarily 90 IQ rednecks. There are a lot of intelligent socially conservative people. One who can't admit that is brainwashed.
- fab13n 11y ago