3 ms·
Can someone explain the logic there? That's never made sense to me and yet gets repeated a lot. Ride-hailing services are a saturated market with major network
by SilasX 11y ago
Can someone explain the logic there? That's never made sense to me and yet gets repeated a lot.
Ride-hailing services are a saturated market with major network effects (the more drivers on a service, the faster they can get to you) and thus, expensive barriers to entry.
It just seems like it makes more business sense for Tesla to sell/license as many self-driving cars as they can to any and all services that want them, and concentrate on their core business, rather than branch out into an entirely new market and write a whole new app from scratch and market it.
Can someone make the opposite case?
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Ride-hailing services are a saturated market with major network effects Not so much. Drivers frequently run Uber and Lyft simultaneously. There is no "stickiness". > It just seems like it makes more business sense for Tesla to sell/license as many self-driving cars as they can to any and all services that want them, and concentrate on their core business, rather than branch out into an entirely new market and write a whole new app from scratch and market it. You'd think so, wouldn't you? But apparently that's the direction Elon is going: http://www.techinsider.io/elon-musk-hints-tesla-may-enter-ride-sharing-space-2015-11 http://www.techinsider.io/elon-musk-hints-tesla-may-enter-ri... > write a whole new app from scratch and market it. I think its humorous this is thought of as expensive. How much does it cost to build an iOS/Android app and run the infrastructure to match riders to drivers? $3-5/million/year? Tesla has hundreds of millions of dollars of credit available to it. And you know, the cars receiving software updates constantly.
- SilasX 11y ago>Not so much. Drivers frequently run Uber and Lyft simultaneously. There is no "stickiness". I meant from the perspective of users and providers, not drivers (which are irrelevant in the case of self-driving cars...). You have to get all these users to download another app when their existing one works fine. That's money that Tesla could be further investing in their core specialty rather. >You'd think so, wouldn't you? But apparently that's the direction Elon is going Yes, which is why I'm asking; the fact that someone is in fact doing it doesn't resolve this mystery. >I think its humorous this is thought of as expensive. How much does it cost to build an iOS/Android app and run the infrastructure to match riders to drivers? $3-5/million/year? Tesla has hundreds of millions of dollars of credit available to it. And you know, the cars receiving software updates constantly. Right, but they haven't trodden the path of scaling up a ride-hailing app and made the numerous optimizations that Uber/Lyft have made based on the unique problems of that domain.
- matthewowen 11y ago> I meant from the perspective of users and providers, not drivers (which are irrelevant in the case of self-driving cars...). You have to get all these users to download another app when their existing one works fine. That's money that Tesla could be further investing in their core specialty rather. That isn't what network effects are. That same argument applies to anyone competing against an incumbent.
- SilasX 11y agoThen incumbence effects -- either way, the point is that it's a barrier to entry.
- ssharp 11y agoWhat's harder, making another Uber or making a self-driving car? Double-sided networks like Uber are hard to gain critical mass. Uber did it, which is extremely impressive, however, whoever comes up with a self-driving car will eliminate one side of that network, making it substantially easy to compete. I personally don't see how Uber's infrastructure minus the driver network is that important.
- nugget 11y agoThey don't eliminate one side of the network but they do turn it into mostly a Capex problem, which is easier to solve, especially for cash rich companies like Google and Apple.
- ssharp 11y agoAnd Google and Apple can send a software update that puts their ride-request app on phones across the world. Both also have billions of cash on hand and could easily fund capital expenses with debt. Given how Apple approaches everything, it's logical that they're going to create an end-to-end experience, meaning they make the tech, they make the cars, and they make the equivalent of Uber. I'm not sure what Google's move is once they have commercially-viable self-driving tech. Would they license it to another automaker or group of automakers? Would their tech plug into whatever request app they make? I think the strategy for Uber is to connect with a manufacturer like Tesla, who seem to be advancing competitively with Google and Apple on self-driving tech. Tesla has less access to cash and debt than Apple. Still, I see Uber's value being far less to Tesla than Tesla's value to Uber.