5 ms·
DagCoin: a cryptocurrency without blocks
- madmod 11y agoCould a DAG chain be able to solve the latency issue for cross planetary currency with several root "branches" for different planets?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 11y agoWe need a cryptocurrency that doesn't cause so much coal to be burned.
- pellmellism 11y agoThe more power consumed, the stronger it is. A cheap chain is a weak chain
- DonHopkins 11y agoHow about solar batteries with built-in "greencoin" cryptocurrency mining circuitry, that generate electricity instead of heat as a by-product? ;)
- itistoday2 11y agoEthereum is going to do that in about a year.
- anarcat 11y agocan you be a little more specific?
- DennisP 11y agohttps://blog.ethereum.org/2015/08/01/introducing-casper-friendly-ghost/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2015/08/01/introducing-casper-frie...
- anarcat 11y agoTL;DR. What's the takeaway?
- jbpetersen 11y agoInstead of a hashing contest it uses time locked deposits on which block will be accepted next. To my understanding it works out as a combination of prediction market style betting and bidding for a block to be accepted.
- logn 11y agoCheck out Safecoin, http://maidsafe.net/documents http://maidsafe.net/documents
- qrmn 11y agoSybil is a real pain, and HashCash (via I2P, which had it as an anti-DoS option) was the first obvious attempt at a solution that worked. It would be better done with Argon2 now, but it still burns coal and is a bet that evil nodes don't have more power than all the good nodes put together - it seems we aren't always going to win that bet. Will proof-of-stake would be any better? It doesn't feel as suited to things other than currency to me, because: what value does the deposit have? We'll see how it turns out when deployed, it's hard to predict how people will react. There's a surprising amount of heat in the field now. Lots of activity, like this interesting work, some very strong opinions. Please don't eat me! I'm quite happy to leave it be and move onto other things.
- SDLerner 11y agoTake a look at IOTA Tangle. They're are developing this concept further into a IoT payment network. S.L.
- chrispeel 11y agoI like the basic idea of combining transactions and blocks.
- pash 11y agoThe author's goal for this design seems to be to increase mining decentralization, but there's another big advantage to a blockless graphical ledger over a blockchain. By attaching proof-of-work to each transaction rather than to a block of multiple transactions, a blockless scheme asks miners to answer a simple cost-benefit question: does the payoff to putting the transaction in the ledger (in transaction fees and seignorage) exceed its cost (in hashing resources)? Particularly when seignorage is zero, so that a miner's only compensation for providing proof-of-work to a transaction is the fee it offers, this eliminates a free-rider problem created by blocks in a scheme like Bitcoin's; as long as you can include as many transactions in a block as you like, the cost of including another one is nil, and so miners have an incentive to include every transaction that pays a non-zero fee, no matter how small [0]. That means the equilibrium price of putting a transaction into Bitcoin's blockchain, for example, may never rise much above zero. That's a real problem for the long-term security of the Bitcoin blockchain. Per-transaction proof-of-work eliminates that problem by making both the cost and reward of adding a transaction to the ledger a function of the properties of each transaction, rather than of an arbitrary aggregate of transactions. 0. This isn't true if there is a binding limit on the size of blocks, as there is now in the Bitcoin protocol. But a wholly arbitrary block-size limit is a terrible solution to this problem because it is unresponsive to economic factors. It may be possible that a non-zero equilibrium price of transacting could arise in response to other constraints (like the risk of "orphaning" a large block due to the increased time it takes to propagate around the network), as some people have argued in the course of Bitcoin's ongoing block-size war.
- DennisP 11y agoWhat does it mean for a transaction to reference previous transactions? Is it just listing them, rather than using them as inputs? > If two conflicting transactions appear, as more transactions are added to the DAG-chain, the number of confirmations of one of the two will increase, but the other will not Is that just because people go with whichever has the most references and/or proof-of-work so far?