5 ms·
The significant change with CRISPR (compared to other ways that transhumanists might accidentally kill themselves) is that it can make heritable genetic changes
by wlesieutre 11y ago
The significant change with CRISPR (compared to other ways that transhumanists might accidentally kill themselves) is that it can make heritable genetic changes. Experiment on yourself, sure, but to pass your untested experimentation along to children is a totally different ethical question.
Recent news: http://news.berkeley.edu/2015/12/01/crispr-inventor-calls-for-pause-in-editing-heritable-genes/ http://news.berkeley.edu/2015/12/01/crispr-inventor-calls-fo...
> A three-day international summit on the ethics of making permanent, hereditary changes in the human genome begins today in Washington, D.C., the fruit of an informal discussion organized in January by Jennifer Doudna, the inventor of the CRISPR-Cas9 technology that makes such changes cheap and easy.
AFIAK this should only come up if people are messing with sperm/eggs, but it's definitely something to be aware of. Can CRISPER change existing DNA that would alter future sperm production? (am not a biologist)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krasin 11y agoWhat can be done with m̶a̶g̶i̶c̶ CRISPR, can be undone with CRISPR. I don't see anything really permanent here.
- pasbesoin 11y agoThe financial 1% becomes the genetic 1%? As one scenario. (Even if CRISPR itself is not that expensive, the computational power to determine effective scenarios likely will be. Not to mention IP "rights" and lawyers as an additional bludgeon.) (Additionally, we appear to be just beginning to really understand folding and DNA/RNA 3D and 4D geometry. I'm uncertain we can really determine the full scope of such scenarios, yet. Including perhaps transmissible negative repercussions.)
- narrator 11y agoNaaah. That would be ok. The problem comes when this technology gets too cheap and people decide they want to live longer than they are supposed to. Same problem with stem cells. The elite can do whatever they want with this stuff. It's the masses adopting it that is troublesome.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>but to pass your untested experimentation along to children is a totally different ethical question. They pass it on to the fetus, which does not have the same rights as a human even if it may eventually become such. This touches on a number of issues, include eugenics. For example, if it is wrong to pass on unknown quality genes to your children, what about passing on known bad genes? Look into the rare cases of the genetically deaf ensuring their children have the same condition, which is legal even though it would be illegal to permanently deafen a child. Also, if a person's right to do what they want with their own body can be limited due to the rights of possible future children (who may never even happen), what does this say of issues such as abortion or birth control (especially permanent methods). We should be very careful before assigning any duties people have to persons who don't yet exist.
- cobaltblue 11y agoIf a CRISPR change doesn't kill you, it seems to me unlikely to kill your offspring. This may be naive, I don't know to what extent a gene variant would be fine in an adult but not fine in a child. Most self gene edits would not be random, but would be more along the lines of "in studies x% has variant A;A and y% has variant A;G or G;G. A;A is "better" in some sense I care about, and I have A;G, so I'm going to edit that G to an A." Maybe there are dependent genes that need editing as well that we don't know about because otherwise you're no longer a viable lifeform, but it seems that any cascading effects would come up before you had a child. It's like editing a character in the string constant pool of a program. Maybe it'll be fine, or maybe you need to edit some other part whose logic depended on the original character to match the new character and avoid a crash or misbehavior. Getting my genes sequenced for $100 revealed I'm a carrier of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tay%E2%80%93Sachs_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tay%E2%80%93Sachs_disease It would be highly irresponsible of me to breed with another carrier due to the 25% chance of an offspring with the disease, which all but guarantees early death. If one of us parents has the gene edited away, or it is edited away in the womb, this is a good thing.
- adenadel 11y agoI want to clear up a misconception here. Odds are that for $100 you didn't get any sequencing done. More likely they used a genotyping chip to look for (potentially a lot) of specific variants. This is what 23andMe does. The price of sequencing the exome (all of the genes in the genome) is approaching $100 and could be lower than that for really high volume producers, but for now the most common assay at that price point is a chip.
- blfr 11y agoIt's not a totally different ethical question. Your actions routinely affect your descendants. For example, people very often decide to have children later in life now with all the risks it carries.