3 ms·
How well have the first generations of helium drives lasted? I'm wary of trusting my data to something that relies on incredibly good gas seals. But if there a
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
How well have the first generations of helium drives lasted?
I'm wary of trusting my data to something that relies on incredibly good gas seals. But if there are no observed reliability issues, it seems that problem has been solved.
- dangrossman 11y agoThey come with a 5 year warranty and 2.5M hours MTBF rating, which says something about the manufacturer's opinion of their reliability.
- chefkoch 11y agoThat hasn't really helped the 3TB seagate constellation drives...
- davidandgoliath 11y agoSeagate has really gone downhill in that respect, though it's worth noting their enterprise grade stuff is still reasonable (ymmv).
- hga 11y agoYou mean their almost certainly doomed by flash drive 10K and 15K drives? (A class of drive I've been using since 1995 and just stopped buying new ones; in fact, a 15K Savio mirrored system disk recently failed and I replaced both with an Intel enterprise SSD rather than send it in for warranty repair. So far I'm not looking back.) Officially, Constellation drives are "Enterprise", 5 year warranty (which still works well, did that on a 2TB drive last year I think), available in SAS as well as SATA interfaces. Although they're now saying that you shouldn't transfer more than 550TB of data per year through the best of this class of drives.
- chefkoch 11y agoIn a 8 disk nas i replaced 6 oft them in one year because of bad smart data. Some lastet only Werks before marked as faulty. This series is really bad.
- X-Istence 11y agoPlace where I used to work had large NetApp array's using HGST's Helium filled drives. During the time that I was there (1 year, these had been in service longer than that), out of the 250+ drives in service we didn't have a single failure.
- wazoox 11y agoNone ever failed me (several hundreds in production). In general, HGST drives are much more reliable than Seagate and WD anyway, but the He are supposedly even better.