4 ms·
For those of you in this field...how influential is the NYFed trying out (and apparently being satisfied with) Julia to other government agencies, computational
by danso 11y ago
For those of you in this field...how influential is the NYFed trying out (and apparently being satisfied with) Julia to other government agencies, computational economists, and/or academics? Is it "OS X is Unix/BSD-based" influential, or "Whitehouse.gov uses Drupal [1]" influential?
[1] http://buytaert.net/whitehouse-gov-using-drupal http://buytaert.net/whitehouse-gov-using-drupal
- bachmeier 11y agoTo be honest, it will have very little influence. Economists don't like to change their tools.
- k2enemy 11y agoEconomists don't like to change their tools, but Julia is getting a lot of attention among grad students that are picking between Julia, Python, and Matlab as a first language.
- grayclhn 11y agoI think you'd be surprised. I put "I ran my simulations in Julia, talk to me about it" on a slide at a talk in the spring and was really surprised by who was already using it.
- Jgrubb 11y agoI'm not sure how the comparison stacks up for you. Drupal nabbing the whitehouse site was pretty huge in enabling it to land a bunch of other government and higher ed sites/mindshare. I'm not sure which end of the order of magnitude scale you place that though.
- Cowen 11y agoAs far as votes of confidence go, Julia landing successfully at any of the 12 Federal Reserve Banks is a strong one. They all do a whole mess of complex modeling. The NY Fed in particular is a "first among equals" in the Federal Reserve system, so it's always good to be there. That said, I have no idea if this will be that influential on economists changing their tools, or the tools that they teach to their students. People tend to stick with tools that they know and like. But it's very possible that this will help Julia in the eyes of people getting into the field choosing their first programming language.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoThe Fed isn't a government agency. It has private share holders. It was named The Federal Reserve specifically to breed the confusion that most people have - it was supposed to sound like a federal agency while it is not.
- neffy 11y agoThe DSGE models are influential up until somebody comes up with a valid alternative, at which point they will be dropped at somewhat over the speed of light :) To be brutally honest, this is not a big achievement. You should be able to rapidly speed up any matlab model by porting it into pretty much any other language due to well known issues with matlab. Being able to run DSGE models more quickly is important to economists because it allows them to be better 'callibrated' - which is to say that the economists essentially tweak the models for the country they are looking at, until they fit the known data over an acceptable time period. (They don't try to hide this btw. there are scores of papers on model calibration approaches.) A good example of what this leads to is the one for Iceland: http://www.sedlabanki.is/lisalib/getfile.aspx?itemid=8077 http://www.sedlabanki.is/lisalib/getfile.aspx?itemid=8077 Notice that this is published in 2010, but for some strange reason the charts (p57 onwards) all stop in 2005. It's over fitting to the curve on computer assisted steroids.
- SolarNet 11y agoIs there a reason calibration isn't automatic? Say with some sort of genetic algorithm? Do the simulations take too long?
- pzone 11y agoCalibration here means simulation to find the right parameter values. Genetic algorithm isn't particularly useful here, it's a more general high dimensional optimization problem. But if you can cut down the simulation time from e.g. a weekend to a few hours, that is huge in terms of allowing you to find a good specification.
- neffy 11y agoThis is the critical thing - they're not simulations. They are mathematical models based on a mix of the existing economic macro-economic formula. With upwards of 200 parameters that can be tweaked. There is no particular recipe btw - if you start digging into the configuration files for these 'models', you'll find all sorts of things, with the occasional hilarious comment (my favourite -'this seems to work in Sweden'). Note that at the same time macro economists are talking about the business cycle, and the purported fit of one of these models to it, they are cheerfully ignoring the applicable Nyquist limit for whatever period cycle they believe they've identified. Again to use Iceland - because it's a diddly little country and very easy to study. They stop the charts in 2005 because after that, there is a complete deviation from the model, which the model needless to say completely failed to predict. However, anyone who spent half an an hour looking at the Icelandic monetary statistics would have been able to identify clear warning signals from 2003 onwards, and some pretty clear analyses were being issued on that within the financial community by 2005. Rumour has it the only use Wall Street has for DSGE models is to try and predict whatever crazy thing the central banks will do next. http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-01-21/wall-street-shorts-economists http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-01-21/wall-street...
- grayclhn 11y agoI work on research close to this area -- time series w/ macro applications, but not on these specific models. These specific models are very very important for estimating the effects of monetary policy decisions, forecasting, etc. because they embed a fair bit of economic theory with a decent amount of estimation theory so that the models can address questions about "causality" in a meaningful way: if I intervene by changing the interest rate, what is the distribution of outcomes that will result. (The stuff I work on uses less economic theory so it can't address those questions.) That's not to say that the NY Fed takes the model's recommendations uncritically and assumes that the models are perfect or the recommendations are the truth, because that would be nuts. Just that this class of models is one of the few ways to use "the data" to provide guidance about policy decisions. The people who've developed the NY Fed's DSGE model are some of the absolute top people working on these models. It's based on a lot of academic research and a lot of research published in top journals by people at the NY Fed involved in building the model. Other banks have their own models, but I suspect this one is the highest profile. (Again, not precisely my field of research, so I could be missing one or two.) So, to get around to answering your question. For academic research in economics, this is as "production level" as it gets. Is this the same as using Julia for algorithmic trading? No. The NY Fed's not running this model in real time, and if something crashes then they can restart it. But I think this is huge for Julia's adoption in economic research. (For a pdf with more about the modeling strategy itself: https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff_reports/sr647.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff... but that is 2 years old now.)