4 ms·
That is the million dollar question as power generation is driven not by acquisition cost but by the total operating costs. One of the challenges with the big
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
That is the million dollar question as power generation is driven not by acquisition cost but by the total operating costs.
One of the challenges with the big turbines is you lose a lot of capacity with one of them off line, and it is there perhaps that kites have a small advantage.
- jacquesm 11y agoBig turbines are big because of one simple thing: efficiency. It takes a lot less in terms of materials and space to make a single 8 MW turbine than it takes to generate the same amount of power with a large number of smaller ones. Yes, if they go down you lose a large amount of capacity in one go, but that does not weigh against the cost of a large number of smaller turbines that will go down much more frequently with smaller losses (they still need to be repaired). Though the cost to repair them will likely be lower per instance the people doing the service still have to be called out. I love this google project and I'm really curious what will come out but what with wind being my life-long side interest and having seen a large number of fantastic designs come with a hurricane of fanfare and go again without a breeze I'm not going to bet on this until there is much more hard data to compare to 'conventional' systems. Three blade conventional machines are anything but, they're engineering marvels with a ton of materials science behind them, it took nearly 40 years to go from the 10 KW prototypes at Petten (in NH, NL), to the giants you see today. That's a lot of R&D invested over a very long period of time. Now these kites can leverage some of that knowledge and they no longer have to validate the concept of windpower for regular consumption, that trail has already been blazed so they should have an easier time of it. Here's to hoping that it works, and that it won't end up next to 'windtree' or the 'windbelt' or a hundred other revolutionary wind technologies that ended up being stillborn.
- kragen 11y agoI love how HN news stories sometimes get near-top comments within hours from people who have spent years pushing the envelope on them! Maybe someone from Makani can comment too. The great thing about kites, to me, is that the "tower" — the great majority of the material in a normal windmill — is reduced to the minimum: just the material necessary to resist the tensile force that's driving the generator, with negligible sideloading. And that should make it feasible to harness wind power at kilometers of altitude. (250 meters is just the start!) You are surely correct that wearout and reliability curves on these things are going to be big unknowns until we have a few thousand kite-years of experience.
- jacquesm 11y agoI hardly pushed the envelope, just re-learned a ton of stuff that is common knowledge in the industry. Compare it to creating a cpu on a breadboard in terms of computing. A 5m diameter turbine is a toy compared to these monsters. It's a pity I never got to the next step, we had the generator already done (2.5 KW for the 5 meter machine, 10KW for a 10 meter machine). You're spot on about the tower mass and turning it all into a single tensile component. But you're going to have to account for the mechanism on the ground still being anchored to withstand those forces and any multiples of those forces during sudden gusts. Wind is fickle that way. Another thing I have not yet seen addressed (maybe the knowledge is out there, I just have not seen it) how they plan on doing this in a 'farm' setup, it's one thing to have a bunch of stationary machines at regular spacing interacting with each other, quite a different one when you're going to have all kinds of 3D stacking options and interference between machines (and cabling) when the wind turns. Those are complex problems.
- msandford 11y agoI think the fairly simple answer is that you don't stack them or allow for any interference at all. If your kite goes up to 250m and has a 1km tether you space all your launchers on a 1km "radius" hexagonal grid. Your wind farm takes up more space but at first that's no problem at all. You could probably make it work at a 500m hexagonal grid but there's a small amount of risk associated there. Ultimately though one of the benefits of these things is that when they're not in use they're stowed. And that means people might be a lot less NIMBY about them. And then you might never really need to worry about all the complexity. It's probably a pipe dream to suggest that people would be accepting of them, but stranger things have happened.
- jacquesm 11y ago> I think the fairly simple answer is that you don't stack them or allow for any interference at all. If your kite goes up to 250m and has a 1km tether you space all your launchers on a 1km "radius" hexagonal grid. That would rule out a great many locations. > Your wind farm takes up more space but at first that's no problem at all. A regular wind turbine has a small base and has only one active component. To have a more complex set-up with many more moving parts including the nacelle itself moving around in 3 dimensions is a significant complication that should be offset by a gain, it should not lead to an extra loss. > Ultimately though one of the benefits of these things is that when they're not in use they're stowed. Windmills are sited such that they are rarely idle, it happens but that's money being lost and a very large amount of the pre-work in siting a wind power park is to make sure that idle time is as low as possible. Yes, it is nice they're stowed when not in use but that's a situation you want to avoid. > It's probably a pipe dream to suggest that people would be accepting of them, but stranger things have happened. If the windmills around here are any indication: prior to the installation there is a lot of friction, reaching a peak at the moment the foundations are poured. Then there is a kind of reluctant acceptance and a decade later people say they would miss the machines if they disappeared. It is an odd progression, I guess people are simply against a change for something unknown.