3 ms·
You think 1 year cliff is always right? I think a cliff can be an easy path to abuse.
by brianwawok 11y ago
You think 1 year cliff is always right? I think a cliff can be an easy path to abuse.
- tptacek 11y agoYes. If you can't trust your team not to abuse the vesting cliff, you can't trust them to be cofounders. It is hard to imagine a scenario with a normal (<=4) number of cofounders where it is reasonable to let someone who spends less than a year on the project to walk away with as much as 6% of the company. Having just wrapped up a 10 year company, it is honestly hard to imagine it being fair for that person to walk away with 1%.
- brianwawok 11y agoI would say the reverse of that is also true. If you can't trust someone to not abuse not having a cliff, you can't trust them enough to be cofounders. Especially if a cofounder is putting sweat or cash equity in, he absolutely should not have a cliff of any kind.
- tptacek 11y agoSpeaking as a founder who is putting both sweat and cash equity into their company: run, don't walk, from cofounders that demand not to have a cliff. You might not end up regretting giving someone a pass on their vesting cliff, but if you do regret it, you will regret it a lot. If you're part of a founding team and you put cash in, get IOUs, and take cash back out later.
- shostack 11y agoNot to diminish the importance of trusting founders, but what are some approaches to remove the need for trust in solving for this? As a fan of the saying "trust but verify" and its derivations, while I feel trust is important, I hate leaving such critical things up to trust at the end of the day.
- brianwawok 11y agoOne interesting thing to look at is the possible losses via a little game theory. No Cliff - Risk is that one founder sucks for a year and then takes some equity (2, 3%? How much vested in the first year anyway). If company goes for billions, you make a few million less - basically a rounding error. Cliff - Risk is the controlling founder fires the non-controlling founder on day 364, but company still goes on to succeed. Loss is the non-controlling founder loses a year of his life where he worked for equity that was stripped from him.
- tptacek 11y agoFirst, 2% is a lot. It's more than any senior employee is likely to get after year 1-2. Second, if you're doing equal split and you have three cofounders, without a cliff you're talking about someone who might walk away with 8% of the company without even having spent a year there. CEOs of companies routinely get significantly less than 8% of the company. Finally, the "no cliff" risk happens all the time. People leaving after less than a year is practically the default setting. I'm sorry, but as often as malfeasance among founders happens (the fact that it's newsworthy when it does is suggestive), it's not the default.
- s73v3r 11y agoI think the outcome where someone gets fired just before the vesting period is far, far, far worse and more damaging that someone getting a small chunk of the company for not doing anything.
- tptacek 11y agoYou're answering a question nobody posed. The question is, what's more likely to happen: a cofounder leaving in less than a year, or a cofounder being deliberately screwed by all their cofounders and fired ruthlessly just before the cliff. The answer is: the former scenario is far more likely than the latter.
- 11y ago
- brudgers 11y agoThe situations I can imagine involve doing what is right in the strong sense of "what is right" The obvious cases are when circumstances beyond normal business operations are behind the person's leaving...knicked by a bus, serious illness, etc. The less obvious circumstances would be a case where the person leaving is for the good of the company and acknowledged all around, e.g. it turns out that two good people can't get along and so one or the other leaving increases the odds of success, and leaving quickly and cleanly is in the interest of the company. In both cases, the person leaving with some ownership expresses the underlying trust and without their ownership, their never really was any trust.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoYet in the end, its business. Whatever gets written down, is what is enforceable. Fairness is an odd notion, with maybe little importance to contracts. I've witnessed anger/frustration in 2-3 year old companies where one founder 'checked out' early. E.g. a college professor was offered a large share, for expert consulting privileges. Their expertise was perceived to have a large value to the new company. After a year or two it became obvious who was getting the better deal. But too late for regrets - the prof still owns a small fraction of the company.
- brianwawok 11y agoWell and the 2-3 year mark, what can you do? Even a cliff is gone.