8 ms·
"She was capable of circling the planet 14 times at 20 knots without needing more uranium. All this was accomplished while she emitted no greenhouse gases." "I
by protomyth 11y ago
"She was capable of circling the planet 14 times at 20 knots without needing more uranium. All this was accomplished while she emitted no greenhouse gases."
"In her first year she had to release more than 115,000 gallons of low-level radioactive water into the sea"
On the balance, I think I would prefer the greenhouse gases.
- Bluestrike2 11y agoThat's just an engineering problem, and one easily (comparatively speaking) solved by applying the lessons learned with other nuclear-powered craft. The other problems with the concept were far more damning.
- protomyth 11y agoFrom the publics point of view, the dumping radioactive water would probably be the most damning. From a business perspective, you are correct, the other problems listed[1] are the true problems. 1) timing wise, wow, hitting just before containers is just bad luck
- SamReidHughes 11y agoThey say the best way to dispose of nuclear waste is to mix it with the concrete we use to build our elementary schools. 115,000 gallons is a very small amount of water. That's 40 ft x 40 ft x 10 ft of water. Mix that into the ocean and the pollutants will disperse widely. One cubic mile holds 1.1 trillion gallons.
- protomyth 11y agoYeah, that's not going to fly as a suggestion nor will the public listen to that whole "small amount". I can here the pundits now if that happened today. Sorry, too many movies and TV shows with nuclear as the bad guy. We need to get over it to replace current power generation, but someone is going to have to do one hell of a sales job.
- SamReidHughes 11y agoOh, my bad, I didn't realize the first-person pronoun could be given third-person usage.
- protomyth 11y agoNo, I meant I as in first person as in "I wish they never had built it and I would have traded one more ship to output the gases". Political pride tours seldom work. Well, I guess the Navy did pretty well for itself with them, just not the civilians.
- mikeash 11y ago"They" are idiots if they actually say that, and countering anti-nuclear hysteria with pro-nuclear hyperbole doesn't do us any favors.
- 7952 11y agoI am in favour of nuclear but some of the arguments you hear from advocates make my skin crawl. The caution people exercise over nuclear power is exactly what we should want for any activity that carries risk to health or the environment. Radioactive material is very dangerous, and fission is intrinsically difficult to control. We may be able to successfully deal with those risk, but it is intellectually dishonest to pretend that those risks don't exist just because physicists are so wonderfully clever. The problem is not lack of support for nuclear but tolerance for dirty and unsafe fossil fuels. We need to deal with that using nuclear or solar or whatever.
- mikeash 11y agoCare is certainly called for, but the way it's treated goes too far. Waste is a good example. People insist on perfect safety, and not just for today, but insist on storing waste so that in a hypothetical future 10,000 years from now when civilization has fallen and nobody knows what nuclear anything is, the waste is still safe. This is just not reasonable, and does more harm than good. The problem is that you get people who think you'll glow in the dark if you live near a perfectly functioning power plant, then you get people on the other side who say it's fine to drink plutonium, and both sets of crazies are louder than any reasonable discussion in the middle.
- Klinky 11y agoWhat is the benefit of nuclear if we are left with uncontainable highly toxic radioactive waste? There are already problems with handling waste at existing storage sties. Radioactive waste isn't a problem to be solved 10,000 years from now, it's already a problem. Even guaranteeing safe containment for 50 - 100 years seems like a difficult task, and that is not an outrageous demand for people to make.
- douche 11y agoThe question there, is how low-level. Are we talking bananas, or Chernobyls?
- protomyth 11y agoDoesn't matter really. Imagine the late night pundits, will they ask that question? Nope, neither side would.
- ItsDeathball 11y agoAccording to the ship's current caretakers at http://www.ns-savannah.org/ http://www.ns-savannah.org/: From the FSAR (Final Safety Analysis Report) for the ship, STS-004-002, section 7.1.2 we obtain the following: "During the NSS's operational period, most of the leakage from the primary system was from the buffer seal (SL) system reciprocating charge pumps and from the diaphragm-operated relief valves. Maintenance techniques for the buffer seal charge pumps (which took suction downstream of the primary system demineralizers) were steadily improved. Improvements in the design and testing sequence of the relief valves reduced the leakage. As a result of these improvements, leakage was reduced from a maximum of 1200 gpd [gallons per day] to 50-100 gpd. Leakage from the buffer seals of the control rod drive shafts and from the valve stem packing was always well within acceptable and anticipated limits." (The buffer seal system described above provided a positive inflow of water into the reactor through the control rod drive shaft seals, preventing leakage out of them; the diaphragm operated relief valves are overpressure protection for the reactor plant. The implication of the buffer seal pumps taking suction downstream of the demineralizers is that the water is highly purified after having passed through them; thus, any leak off is purified as well.) The process was that accumulated leaked coolant was stored in tanks. Prior to discharging this liquid , the tanks were sampled to ensure they were within Federal (US 10 CFR 20, Table II, MPCW) limits. After this was guaranteed, the water was safely discharged at sea. Significantly radioactive material, such as ion exchanger resin or any such, was not discharged at sea but rather at approved facilities such as that at Todd Shipyards, Galveston Texas or else onto dedicated servicing barge NSV ATOMIC SERVANT. No solid materials were dumped at sea.
- vonmoltke 11y agoWhy? Without knowing the exact quantity of "low-level" it is hard to say, but if that is the price for effectively removing several hundred thousand cars from the road (which is the amount of fossil fuel pollution the ship would have created had it been oil-fired) I'm all for it. This paranoia over radiation needs to end.
- protomyth 11y agooh for f sakes..... Do you understand what little effect 3 mile island had versus what the media affect was? Do you get that they put out a movie with Jane Fonda that was one of the nails in the nuclear coffin because of that little leak? Do you get that much radioactive water released was enough to trigger the paranoia? I would rather they never built the damn ship since it is just another "look at them dumping radioactive waste" event. We need nuclear, we don't need political pride projects.
- 91bananas 11y agoAm I mistaken or are you and the parent not saying the same thing?
- protomyth 11y agoSame end point I would guess ("Nuclear Good"). I just don't believe its safe to dump any amount of radioactive water given how it will look, and I don't believe that any argument will get you past the media safely. Arguing it was ok and within a safety margin is utterly hopeless.
- vonmoltke 11y agoI understand all of that. I also believe that confronting that crap head-on and reversing the public perception is the right way to proceed, not squirreling away nuclear technology under a cover until it is perfect and unassailable.
- protomyth 11y ago
- logfromblammo 11y agoI would prefer the low-level radioactive water. In fact, given the choice, I would rather drink the water directly out of the Savannah's holding tank than breathe the exhaust of a bunker-burning cargo ship. While I couldn't find the numbers to back this up, I suspect that unfiltered water from the Mississippi River is more radioactive, thanks to the lingering fallout from nuclear weapons tests. An item can be classified as low-level nuclear waste if it exits a controlled nuclear facility with lower levels of radioactivity than the same sort of item found in general commerce. A paper hospital gown discarded from a radiation therapy room is LLW, even if it is less radioactive than another paper gown from another part of the same hospital that had pureed banana spilled on it. Gallon simply does not have a conversion factor to Becquerels. The total volume of waste released tells us absolutely nothing about the actual or potential environmental damage that release represents.