3 ms·
Not sure how it's damning. The premise of the article isn't Maxwells equation and the point of the quoted text isn't the validity of that specific claim but rat
by ThomPete 11y ago
Not sure how it's damning. The premise of the article isn't Maxwells equation and the point of the quoted text isn't the validity of that specific claim but rather that there are objective definitions.
In other words it might be a wrong scientific claim right there (I don't know enough about Maxwells equation) but that doesn't mean that it's damaging the rest of the article since it's not a scientific point that it's trying to make but a philosophical one.
I am not saying it's ok to be sloppy or wrong just that sometimes right conclusions and useful perspectives can happen even though some of the details are wrong.
It's not a scientific paper and as far as I read it shouldn't be read as such IMO.
But each to their own of course.