6 ms·
What smoothing are you recommending, so that we can see that it's unchanged? Hard to see anything in the raw chart. Edit: as you can see below, what I'm contes
by greglindahl 11y ago
What smoothing are you recommending, so that we can see that it's unchanged? Hard to see anything in the raw chart.
Edit: as you can see below, what I'm contesting is the assertion that it's unchanged.
- gd1 11y agoThe article claims that it has increased by a foot, which is 30 centimeters: " Changing global trade winds have raised sea levels in the South Pacific about a foot over the past 30 years" What smoothing do you recommend I apply, so that I can see that?
- burkaman 11y agoThat graph pretty clearly shows 10 or 15 cm over the last 20 years. I wish I could see the data for 30 years but it doesn't seem impossible that there was a 15 cm rise in those 10 years.
- logfromblammo 11y agohttp://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/interactive-sea-level-time-series-wizard?dlat=7&dlon=171&fit=n&smooth=g&days=7300 http://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/interactive-sea-level-t... shows about a 9 cm increase over 20 years. http://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/interactive-sea-level-time-series-wizard?dlat=7&dlon=171&fit=n&smooth=g&days=1095 http://sealevel.colorado.edu/content/interactive-sea-level-t... does less drastic smoothing, to show a bit more detail.
- kaybe 11y agoMaybe that refers to the maxima, which are in the same order of magnitude? Temporary flooding is also described in the article, with the main issue of destroying freshwater supplies and trees. But you're right, that phrasing is a bit weird.
- greglindahl 11y agoWhile its fun to make fun of the non-scientific article, I'm actually probing at your claim that it's unchanged. You cited evidence, but it doesn't support your claim.
- IanDrake 11y agoMost GW people are fooled by randomness. It's just this generations version of how people are going to destroy the world. Every generation needs something to freak out about. Here's all you have to know about sea level rise... When land in Ohio is as expensive than land in NYC, we have a big fucking sea level problem. Until then, all the smart and wealthy people in the world aren't concerned and neither should you be.
- gd1 11y agoWe'll try the BOM then, that goes back to '93: http://www.bom.gov.au/ntc/IDO70052/IDO70052SLI.shtml http://www.bom.gov.au/ntc/IDO70052/IDO70052SLI.shtml Try any source you like. Show me something hard to back up "The Marshall Islands are Disappearing"
- tveita 11y agoThe chart you linked shows sea levels are rising, but that doesn't seem to match the argument you're making?
- gd1 11y agoWow. I see - at best - a random walk. A random walk where the noise is about 5 times the amplitude of any signal you might argue is there. I also see the mean tailing off the last three years to be lower than it was in '93. What do you see? I certainly don't see the "The Marshall Islands Are Disappearing". Is this some sort of Rorschach test that I'm failing?
- cadlin 11y agoMaybe you're not very good at interpreting data? This might help : http://www.jmu.edu/assessment/wm_library/Analyzing%20&%20Interpreting%20Data.ppt http://www.jmu.edu/assessment/wm_library/Analyzing%20&%20Int...
- Mikeb85 11y agoLook at your data. The last time it trended down significantly there was a major weather event (hint: 1997-1998)... The same major weather event is upon us right now. Anyhow, fit a regression line, and the trend is upward for most parts of the world. Maybe someday we'll return to an ice age, I mean, we were there in some parts of the world 10000 years ago. Right now the data shows we're in a warming cycle. It may be human-caused, it may be forces beyond our understanding (after all, the planet has gone through several heating-cooling cycles), but either way it's happening.
- 11y ago