3 ms·
I'm not claiming your land, I'm just tearing up every square meter of its surface area to mine it. Whatever's left over is still yours.
by andrewflnr 11y ago
I'm not claiming your land, I'm just tearing up every square meter of its surface area to mine it. Whatever's left over is still yours.
- tomp 11y agoWell, it's not my land...
- jerf 11y agoEarth-based metaphors and forms of thinking break down here, because it's not Earth. There's no "tearing up every square meter" analogue here. To the extent that there is one, the entire universe is already "torn up". So far as we know, it's not "alive", there's no meaningful way in which it is "pristine", there's nothing there to "hurt". On Earth, you can casually assume that effectively every cubic centimeter has some life in it. That assumption, and other similar ones, must be examined when discussing space.
- andrewflnr 11y agoI'm not trying to say anything about original owners or inhabitants. My only point is that its nonsensical to say that you can mine an asteroid and cast off the slag without saying you haven't laid claim to it. Having the right to control use of or destroy an object is as good a definition of ownership as any I know of, and that's precisely what you're claiming when you mine an asteroid. I guess I should have just said that, instead...