18 ms·
I hate to be so negative. Elon is a really bright guy and electric cars are fantastic; a real advancement away from fossil fuels. We need more of that! But we
by titzer 11y ago
I hate to be so negative. Elon is a really bright guy and electric cars are fantastic; a real advancement away from fossil fuels. We need more of that!
But we don't need hyperloop. We need decent subways, lightrail, buses and trams. And decently fast (200km/h) intercity trains. We don't lack the technology or the engineering, we lack the political will. Pissing away billions on more techno fantasy is just a distraction while the number of cars and parking lots and freeways just keeps on growing, accreting ever more, little by little, like it has for the past 60 years in the US. The layout of and density of US cities is already profoundly inefficient due to streets, parking lots, and freeways.
A lot of comments here seem to be betting big on self-driving cars, like somehow magic chariots will appear from the sky and whisk us away to fairy land where we never have to look at a stranger or sit in a seat next to someone we don't know, or god, touch a railing! And they'll just as easily disappear into the ether where they require neither maintenance nor upkeep, storage, or cleaning. Apparently these self-driving cars will also run on magic engines that are somehow going to be more efficient than electric light rail or subway, or god forbid, a bike.
- zimbatm 11y agoThen don't be. There is room for one more transportation system. Money is not a single pot which gets distributed to a number of things. It's a fallacy to think that if hyperloop didn't happen more money would go to other transportation systems.
- masklinn 11y ago> And decently fast (200km/h) intercity trains. Surely you mean 200mph? 200km/h barely qualifies as high-speed rail on old lines in europe, new lines require 250, 350 lines are being rolled out and plans are being drawn for 400 lines in the UK and Russia.
- titzer 11y ago200km/h would be smoking fast in the US. Sadly.
- Scarblac 11y agoAlmost all Dutch intercity trains run 140km/h, and that's fast enough (it's faster than cars, and goes city center to city center). Of course cities are close together here, but we are in Europe. I'd certainly call 200km/h "decently fast".
- masklinn 11y ago> Almost all Dutch intercity trains run 140km/h, and that's fast enough When it's hard to find cities more than 100km apart, sure. And the US already have passenger trains in that range. > Of course cities are close together here, but we are in Europe. I quoted what's considered high-speed rail in Europe, I'm sorry that offends you. > I'd certainly call 200km/h "decently fast". Not when your cities are 500km apart or more.
- ju-st 11y agoNew high speed railways in Germany are built only for 250km/h: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendlingen%E2%80%93Ulm_high-speed_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendlingen%E2%80%93Ulm_high-sp...
- masklinn 11y agoA specific 80km rail section with a long tunnelled ramp is only built for 250 (which does qualify as high-speed anyway). Germany also has 300km/h rail: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erfurt–Leipzig/Halle_high-speed_railway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erfurt–Leipzig/Halle_high-spee...
- titzer 11y agoThe trains almost never go that fast, and even if they do, it's for short periods of time. Average speed is the key thing. Why are we only impressed by megafast trains? They aren't really cost efficient and probably won't be built at all. The best train is the one that exists! 200km/h is already probably reaching. Even 150km/h means you could go Chicago to Cincinatti in 3 hours (vs 4.5 by car) or San Francisco to LA in under 5 hours (vs 6 hours by car). At 5 hours, that beats the hassle of an airplane, IMO.
- mattlutze 11y agoTl,dr: If the US is going to give up personal driving, it needs fast intercity connects and ubiquitous in-city transportation. - Subways and light rail are high cost, high visibility, negative return investments for most municipalities. - Intercity could be trains or a hyperloop, given hyperloop developers' projected cost structures. - In-city should be buses and, eventually, self-driving quasi-taxi fleets. ---- On the in-city transportation: Subways are very expensive to build, very expensive to move, and a deficit on their community if the areas in which they're built don't have very high population densities. See: almost any city in the US with a subway, many cities elsewhere. ---- Light rail, if the tracks are built into existing roads, is a little less expensive to build and move but suffers the same population and planning issues as subways, as well as being an added impediment to traffic and imposing the same commuting inefficiencies on the rider as if they were in a car. If they're instead given dedicated space, they become much more expensive as extra road lanes must often be built (or easements otherwise negotiated and purchased by municipalities), and they end up much harder to move for want of further easement & road expansion. The light rail requiring expansion of paved traffic surfaces would also make them less environmentally friendly from the perspective of urban surface radiance. See: The Arlington/Alexandria, Virginia light rail project most quickly comes to mind. I'm looping "trams" in here as well because I'm assuming they're electric-line-driven mass transport boxes of some sort. If they're not track-dependent then cost is installation and maintenance of a whole bunch of tram power lines, so cheaper than light rail but still slow to respond to population growth and change. ---- Buses require no tracks, no tunnels, no $5 million train cars, and a route can be switched in a day by putting up a couple new bus stop posts. Bus systems can actually be profitable if local governments don't try to make political wins by drawing expensive bus routes in distant, low-volume rural areas. Buses suffer from traffic like most light rail does. As an answer to urban congestion, buses are cheap, require almost no new infrastructure, can carry a ton of people, and with kinetic recovery and alternative fuel systems can be very low-impact. When used in higher density areas where personal car parking would be onerous, bus commuting can be quicker than private driving. See: Lots of bus systems. Stuttgart, Germany's SSB has hybrid buses with kinetic recovery systems improving efficiency by 18%, for example. Self-driving cars or crowd-shared cars (e.g. Car2Go) provide gap-filling where bus routes don't conveniently link up.
- 11y ago
- Agustus 11y agoI will give up my car when the people driving the subways, lightrail, buses, and trams promise not to strike. The day the subways, lightrail, buses, and trams are run by private enterprises and are not subject to the political whims of the unions and elected officials, then I might consider giving the concept a test run.
- jazzyk 11y agoIn the US in general, strikes are NOT the problem. I do not recall a single strike in the past 20 years or so (In the Boston area). There are tons of other problems (like outdated cars, frequent equipment issues, etc) - but I doubt a private enterprise would improve things much by itself. Introducing competitive environment, on the other hand, would.
- Agustus 11y agoBecause the transit systems do not have that as a tool. Look at other countries and see that where the system is used by more hostages, the number of times a ransom is demanded anecdotally appears higher. In the last 15 years for U.S. transit: * 2005 New York City transit strike * 2007 Orange County transit strike * 2010 Spirit Airlines Pilot Strike (U.S.) What does private enterprise need to improve as it currently stands? The government subsidizes transit to such an extent that private players stay out and any hint of a profitable line is look unfavorably upon by government players that they ban it or try to robustly oppose it; examples include Google Bus', and Jitney's in New York.