3 ms·
> turning either to invented pronouns like xe and zie This made me pause...aren't all pronouns (and for that matter, words in general) "invented?" Are they (se
by untothebreach 11y ago
> turning either to invented pronouns like xe and zie
This made me pause...aren't all pronouns (and for that matter, words in general) "invented?" Are they (see what I did there...) just making a distinction between words that are adapted or modified from other words, and ones that aren't?
- jnevill 11y agoPerhaps "Newly invented pronouns" would have been more clear. The distinction being Singular "They" has been around for a long time, and "Xe" can't be pronounced by the human mouth and confuses the older folk. Or something...
- untothebreach 11y agoHa, well as one of the "older folk," I will say that while "xe" doesn't confuse me, it is definitely a bit jarring when I see it used. I have no problem with it's use, I am just not used to seeing it. I recently read a book by a fantasy author whose stories I enjoy, but in this latest book she used "xe" quite often to describe some non-binary characters, and it always managed to pull me out of the story.
- coke12 11y agoI'm reading Greg Egan's Diaspora right now and he uses ve, ver, and vis for the (post-/non-human) main characters. It's definitely exciting in a worldbuilding sort of way but I still prefer they, them, and their because it's much less jarring.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chc 11y agoAFAIK most words in our language are evolved rather than invented. You may as well call our height "invented."