4 ms·
He might have had selfish motivations, and he might be a bad guy. But neither of those things changes the fact that he did an experiment with giving employees e
by smt88 11y ago
He might have had selfish motivations, and he might be a bad guy. But neither of those things changes the fact that he did an experiment with giving employees equal salaries, and that experiment had positive results on the company.
I think sharks are circling because people have a zeal for debunking the idea that someone is selfless. If you Google it, you can even find people who criticize Mother Theresa for having secret, selfish ulterior motives.
I personally believe people who help others always get something out of it (even if it's just private satisfaction), and that's OK. A good act is a good act, regardless of the internal thoughts that triggered it.
- tptacek 11y agoThe pay raise made it easy for Gravity to recruit, but the retention benefits are unclear (some employees left due to the raise). It does not appear to have improved customer retention. It's unclear whether the raise was a net positive for the company. The subtext of the story is that the raise was an unqualified win for one person, though: Dan Price.
- whatok 11y agoYou could actually make a decent comparison between Gravity and companies appeasing Wall Street by juicing quarterly earnings or buying back stock. If Gravity is spending an inordinate amount on employee pay and it's not accompanied by corresponding growth... well we all know what happens then.
- isleyaardvark 11y ago>(some employees left due to the raise) 2 employees out of 120.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's how many left because of the raise. We don't know what their overall employee turnover is.
- stevesearer 11y agoDid he actually give all employees equal pay, or did he just raise the starting salaries to $70k/year? those two things are quite different.
- DanBC 11y agoPeople criticise mother theresa because she believed that suffering was a gift from god and because of that she didn't allow pain medication to be used in her "hospices". And her hospices didn't separate the curable from the untreatable, so a bunch of people died needlessly.
- smt88 11y agoThat's very interesting! I haven't seen that specific (and horrifying) criticism. What I've seen was from Christopher Hitchens, who said that she wasn't a "good" person because her primary motivation was to proselytize, as she believed Jesus instructed her to do. My comment was creating an analogy between those two: Dan Price doing something awesome for his employees because of a lawsuit is something like Mother Theresa serving the poor because she believed it was how she would have a good afterlife. I don't know if either of those motivations are true. It's impossible to know someone's motivations with certainty. That's why I think an action and its consequences are the thing to focus on. If it's true, as the article says, that Dan Price is creating the cult of Dan Price (a do-gooder-CEO kind of thing), great! Even if he's just some narcissist who wants people to love him, I'm happy that another wealthy person is pursuing some form of humanitarianism. All the really "good" people might be narcissists, for all we know!
- stuaxo 11y agoDid you see the Christopher Hitchens documentary? There seems to be quite a lot of detail in it beyond just her motivation being to proselytize..
- vithlani 11y agoAnd a lot of that criticism is warranted. For example, she was never able to account for how much money her charity took in and where it went. And people have observed how the general upkeep of the charity's facilities would never change -- year after year, donation round after round.