3 ms·
There is an important part of the multisig puzzle missing in the article: the need for an out of band protocol to communicate copayers for joining a wallet and
by wslh 11y ago
There is an important part of the multisig puzzle missing in the article: the need for an out of band protocol to communicate copayers for joining a wallet and spending bitcoins. This is something that Copay (https://copay.io https://copay.io) does but there is no standard way to do this.
There are other issues. For example, Coinbase doesn't support it fully. See this thread for more info: https://twitter.com/coinfabrik/status/661992065841123328 https://twitter.com/coinfabrik/status/661992065841123328 but other wallet services like Coinkite does: http://blog.coinfabrik.com/independently-generating-your-private-key-for-coinkite/ http://blog.coinfabrik.com/independently-generating-your-pri...
- kang 11y agoI haven't read how the wallets are implementing multisig but what is this out-of-band protocol you are talking about? If I want to spend coins from a multisig address, I create a transaction, sign it with my key and send it to the other party who can sign it and relay it or send it back to me and I can relay it. It's a very simple protocol.
- walls 11y ago> and send it to the other party Probably that part.
- kang 11y agoIt can be sent over email or anything , doesn't even need security.
- wslh 11y agoThe way you send it to another party is not standarized. Think in your grandpa, he would want to just create a transaction while everything else happens behind the scene. Sending an email is a manual process and you need to recheck if the other party received it. Beyond this, there is a bigger reason: if you want a risk service like Sig3 or CryptoCorp you should adapt the system to every multisig wallet while if you have an standarized way to communicate you wrote an standard system.
- kang 11y agoYou can send an email(messaging) behind the scene, need not be manual nor is a task that require standardization. Sig3 is more secure theoretically but its an overkill & non-requirement nevertheless. Why not have Sig4? Sig100 would be theoretically even more secure!
- wslh 11y ago> You can send an email(messaging) behind the scene So... how Coinbase handles it, what is the format? Coinkite? Copay? The nth popular wallet? You can easily see that you need a standarization, it doesn't matter if its by email, morse, or slack. Now, Sig3 is the name of a service, with Sig3 you can use any n-m wallet.
- martindale 11y agoFormer employee at BitPay (maker of Copay) here. There were indeed discussions about standardizing the out-of-band protocol, and I hope something comes of it soon. It'd be huge for the ecosystem.