4 ms·
People who hold to your preferred cause are the only sane ones, and everyone else is "merely playing politics." Cool. Or maybe, just maybe, the real world is a
by mikeash 11y ago
People who hold to your preferred cause are the only sane ones, and everyone else is "merely playing politics." Cool.
Or maybe, just maybe, the real world is a little more complex than that. Maybe it is Islamic extremism and climate change and income inequality and a thousand other things all interacting with each other.
I don't doubt that Piketty is using ISIS to advance his agenda, because that's what people do. Everybody everywhere is using ISIS to advance their agenda. Piketty uses it to support his ideas about income inequality, and Sam Harris uses it to support his ideas about Islam.
Ultimately, pointing fingers does nothing. The question is, what do you do now to fix things? I don't see anything actionable on that front coming out of the "Islamic extremism" cause.
- jules 11y agoThere's actually lots of really important actions that get mostly ignored precisely because saying that this is related to religion is politically incorrect. 1. The West should more publicly defend the people who stand to gain most from a decrease of religiosity in Muslim majority countries: women, intellectuals, gays, etc. Those are the people who have a self-interest in reform, and thus are most likely to actually try. 2. In Europe in particular there should be a bigger emphasis on religion in education; particularly education about different religions and about atheism. 3. Any immigrants and refugees should get personal and very intense help to integrate into European society, and gaining a European passport should be tied to achievement of those goals. 4. Salafist and Wahhabist organisations should be banned, and any money coming from Saudia Arabia and other Gulf states investigated. etc.