3 ms·
COBOL made things easier for developers, saw widespread deployment, and still runs much of our backend. If anything, it was too easy to use as much of the code
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
COBOL made things easier for developers, saw widespread deployment, and still runs much of our backend. If anything, it was too easy to use as much of the code was written by amateurs and is too large/complex to port w/out risk of breaking it. SystemVerilog, based on what its users write, is much worse than that. They say it barely does what it seeks to accomplish and imply it's really used just because it's what tools support and people know.
So, developing alternatives is a worthwhile thing so long as there's tools developed to make them useful. A comment on that page references ParC as one of those:
http://parallel.cc/cgi-bin/bfx.cgi/index1.html http://parallel.cc/cgi-bin/bfx.cgi/index1.html
The presentation on the site does a good job showing why existing approaches suck to varying degrees. Curious, anyone else in this field or researching it have a short list of other alternatives that show promise for this level of things? Especially verification.
- electrichris 11y agoChisel (https://chisel.eecs.berkeley.edu https://chisel.eecs.berkeley.edu) is an HDL built on Scala. It does hardware design and verification. Notably Chisel has been used by RISC-V to create an implementation of their ISA called Rocket. MyHDL (http://www.myhdl.org http://www.myhdl.org) is an HDL build on Pyhton. It supports hardware design and verification. Cocotb (http://cocotb.readthedocs.org/en/latest/introduction.html http://cocotb.readthedocs.org/en/latest/introduction.html) is another project in Python but is purely for verification. I use Cocotb to for test benches and it is really does make HDL verification easier. As one would expect having the power the full power of language like Python available can make many tasks much easier to do. However communication overhead between Python and HDL simulator become a limiting factor for more involved test benches.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAppreciate the list. The Chisel and MyHDL work are impressive. The Cocotb is new to me. I'll have to check it out. Btw, what do you think of this one which I haven't seen anyone report on: http://cx-lang.org/ http://cx-lang.org/ Need to see someone experienced in hardware design try it with some realistic components and see how well it does. Especially ease of use and practical value compared to established alternatives like Chisel or MyHDL.