4 ms·
In a developed economy, having kids is financially stupid. Deeply stupid. It costs individuals a ton, but the benefits accrue to society. Classic tragedy of the
by TulliusCicero 11y ago
In a developed economy, having kids is financially stupid. Deeply stupid. It costs individuals a ton, but the benefits accrue to society. Classic tragedy of the commons.
If we want people to have more kids, say, up to the replacement rate, then that means subsidies. Cheaper childcare seems to be the main thing that encourages more kids: http://www.economist.com/news/international/21659763-people-rich-countries-can-be-coaxed-having-more-children-lazy-husbands-and http://www.economist.com/news/international/21659763-people-...
- danieltillett 11y agoNot in Australia if you are unskilled, uneducated and unemployed. Of course if you are educated and working then children costs a fortune.
- aianus 11y agoOr we could just increase skilled immigration to maintain the population. Costs us nothing.
- danieltillett 11y agoOr we could just have fewer people living in the country. The population of Australia has expanded massively in my lifetime (it has about doubled) yet the infrastructure to support this higher population has not been built. Twice as many people trying to live using the same infrastructure does not make for a fun time.
- victorhooi 11y agoA lot of naive observers suggest this, without having thought through the demographical consequences. Go look at Japan to see what happens when you reduce both births and immigration. An aging population, combined with falling fertility rates and no immigration is a disaster waiting to happen. You need fresh blood to keep an economy going - they form the backbone of the workforce (read: taxes) - and in general, they're not scared of trying new things.
- danieltillett 11y agoJapan is doing ok. What matters is per capita GDP not gross GDP.
- joeclark77 11y agoNeither of those things could help Japan. Ultimately old people are going to need nurses and other people to provide services for them. If there are not enough young people willing to do those jobs, then all the money in the world is useless.
- aianus 11y agoNothing stopping them from importing nurses from abroad when and if they get to that desperate stage.
- joeclark77 11y agoThe parent, parent, parent comment (by victorhooi) is stating that Japan's problems stem from its reluctance both to have children and to allow immigration. Your answer -- that they should change their attitude toward immigration -- doesn't refute him or me, it agrees with us.
- nova 11y ago> An aging population, combined with falling fertility rates and no immigration is a disaster waiting to happen. No, that's what's going to happen in Europe. Japan will just have to make some deep, technical changes to budget and taxes in a culturally and ethnically homogeneous civilization, not have to deal with social upheaval.
- joeclark77 11y agoAlso gains you nothing, if your civilization is extinct in a few generations.
- yongjik 11y agoAccepting immigrants is a pretty good insurance against your civilization going extinct, in fact. More diversity, more innovation. Sure, so the inheritors of my civilization might share like, only 99.95% of my DNA instead of 99.99%, but so what?
- nova 11y ago> Accepting immigrants is a pretty good insurance against your civilization going extinct, in fact. Yeah, it only gets replaced. > More diversity, more innovation. Sure, sure.
- jbarham 11y agoThat's a very cynical perspective. Life isn't about money, and in my experience being a parent brings with it many enjoyable moments that could not be bought for all the money in the world. I live in Australia where the financial support for parents is IMHO actually very good. "Family Tax Benefit" direct payments to parents are quite generous (http://www.humanservices.gov.au/customer/enablers/centrelink/family-tax-benefit-part-a-part-b/ftb-a-payment-rates http://www.humanservices.gov.au/customer/enablers/centrelink...) to the point that my effective income tax rate is negligible. Quite apart from Australia's universal Medicare, supplementary private health insurance is quite reasonable (e.g., I pay $320/month for a family of five, regardless of my employment status) so I have none of the concerns about affording healthcare that I did when we lived in the US.
- vithlani 11y agoIt is not good at all if you are earning above an ever decreasing threshold -- which is the govt's way of clawing even more from you. In that case you get no FTB. The supplementary private health insurance is good for hospital cover but not for things like dental -- god forbid your kid should need any braces, etc.
- joeclark77 11y agoIf your opening sentence is true, then living "financially smartly" is deeply unwise. Children represent true wealth; dollars do not.
- endtime 11y agoIt's one thing to call it expensive, but stupid? Presumptuous. I work so I can feed my kids. As far as I'm concerned, that's what money's for.
- deadalus 11y agoIt is stupid if you happen to wife up a sloot. Than you pay child support for 18 years + alimony.
- klipt 11y agoYou know what's even more financially stupid? Dying! You lose all your hard earned cash and you can't even take it with you to count in the grave. Humans are frankly, financially retarded. Getting married? Having kids? Dying? Why can't they just live eternally childless like a smart, economically motivated person should? Don't even get me started on how much it costs to be born and educated. A really smart human would just pop into existence with a masters degree.