4 ms·
If the parent company happens to own the company licensing the IP then I think it is pretty easy to tell the whole thing is a sham.
by danieltillett 11y ago
If the parent company happens to own the company licensing the IP then I think it is pretty easy to tell the whole thing is a sham.
- SilasX 11y agoBut it's also possible for artistic works to legitimately have different pieces created by artists in different countries, and still be parts of the same parent company. An objective answer would require internal value accounting of an ultra-illiquid, ultra-sparsely traded good, which would be hard for experts to gauge, let alone accountants.
- danieltillett 11y agoThese artistic works are not created in places like the british virgin islands. It would be pretty easy to just put in place a rule that internal IP can only be licensed from the entity that created it.
- SilasX 11y agoThat's what they were already doing -- the whole problem is that it's hard to find a rigorous way to say which entity "really" created it in the sense of which portion of the value came from where. If Pixar:USA claims that the scribble on frame 33 (added by Pixar:Luxembourg) was worth $10 million, how does that show up on a accounting document that a tax authority could reject as being a sham?
- danieltillett 11y agoI think this is solved using what lawyers term as what a "reasonable man” would think. The simple rule is if a low tax jurisdiction seems to be earning a disproportional share of the companies profit then there is something fishy going on.
- rayiner 11y agoNot really. E.g. pursuant to their restructuring, Alphabet companies are required to pay for services they use from each other. Subsidiaries are still separate corporations and it's an abuse of the corporate form to just share all resources with a corporate parent while pretending the companies are distinct entities.
- danieltillett 11y agoI know of no good economic reason for alphabet companies that are 100% owned by a parent outside of the needs of foreign investment.