6 ms·
Things universities should do to rein in costs
- jdietrich 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good
- wbeckler 11y agoNot only is the high price considered a positive as per your link, but Veblen specifically used university culture to explain his concept of conspicuous consumption. So much of university professor culture has nothing to do with learning and everything to do with appearing high class, but without the money. Robes, fancy eating spots, stone everywhere ... it's all about appearing upper class.
- ksenzee 11y agoWait, most universities don't offer summer classes? Where I went to school there were fewer students enrolled over the summer, but that just meant campus was a bit less crowded, not that it was a ghost town.
- ambiate 11y agoMy uni offers summer classes, but mostly for intro classes. This means if you transfer in or are a second year student, you have slim pickings in the summer offering. I would have gladly attended 90% of my classes in the summer had they been offered to students. Especially, those mid-tier classes that are only offered in Spring or Fall. IE: intro1 (Fa, Sp, Sum1, Sum2) -> intro2 (Fa, Sp, Sum1, Sum2) -> mid-tier class (Spring only) -> opens up 10 classes.
- univalent 11y agoThere were summer courses for grad school. I think undergrad didn't have any summer classes. (My experience is from 15 years ago so maybe things have changed).
- evanpw 11y agoThe summer classes are usually second-class citizens though: the material is divided up into individual classes assuming the normal-length semesters, so summer classes are always rushed.
- Jtsummers 11y agoCutting research and enrolling more students isn't necessarily the way to go. How about save money for both students and the university. Drop the absurdly nice housing that's going into them. This will reduce room & board fees and cut staffing, construction, & maintenance costs for the university. Athletics: Drop athletes that aren't student athletes. I'm sorry, but illiterate players don't belong in college. It's a disservice to them, the rest of the students, and the university's reputation. Stop spending astronomical amounts on football (primarily) and other sports, even if it pays for itself it's not needed for an academic environment. Rein these in, keep athletics but cut the programs so they aren't (budget-wise) on the level of some professional teams.
- wnevets 11y ago>Athletics: Drop athletes that aren't student athletes. I'm sorry, but illiterate players don't belong in college. It's a disservice to them, the rest of the students, and the university's reputation. Stop spending astronomical amounts on football (primarily) and other sports, even if it pays for itself it's not needed for an academic environment. Rein these in, keep athletics but cut the programs so they aren't (budget-wise) on the level of some professional teams. This isn't going to happen in the current environment. There is literally billions of dollars of profit at stake.
- sithadmin 11y ago>There is literally billions of dollars of profit at stake. Only for the top schools in top conferences, which is a relatively small number of universities in the US.
- jdmichal 11y agoYou know those games that big universities play against smaller ones? Those smaller schools get paid to participate -- typically in the millions range. Why else would they willingly walk into a high-probability loss situation? So sure, it's not billions. But it's not necessarily a losing game for those non-top-tier teams either.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoWho writes this kind of reality-free trash? The author talks about reducing administrative costs, but with today's universities you have no choice. You can throw an upper-middle-class kid into university and he will do just fine. But first-generation students, non-traditional students, foreign students, students on athletic scholarships &c need support services, and access has been expanded so much that these things consume a substantial part of the budget. You have no choice but to offer them. Without them a substantial part of the student body would fail out quickly. And then the author talks about leaving campus open all year. When you ply faculty and teaching support staff at my university with sufficient alcohol they will eventually admit that Summer term is done for the extra tuition income. When you ply them with more they will also admit that soon they will add Winter classes for even more cash - not that anyone can learn anything substantial in these three weeks. And finally the author recommends to drop research and go back to teaching. In theory that sounds good. In practice, universities have been forced to fish for grant money because state support has been scaled back. Also, in my observation, the worst teaching is done by full professors in their Fifties, who have long checked out and are not keeping up with current practice. Maybe it's time to get rid of tenure and increase state support.
- 6stringmerc 11y ago>And finally the author recommends to drop research and go back to teaching. That struck me as pretty disingenuous too, considering how lightly he glossed over the real-world problem of "labor as a cost of doing business" mentality that has shifted teaching toward adjunct staff members. It's almost like he doesn't care those starting out in their career, who would likely become the next generation of great teachers at a reasonable price are pretty much being shoved into poverty from the get-go. No intelligent, worthwhile teacher/professor can withstand that kind of lack of support all while being fed lines about how "we have to cut costs" like the examples mentioned.
- Retric 11y agoNontraditional students add minimal administrative overhead. There are plenty of schools that are dysfunctional or pad their budget for various reasons, but done well this is really cheap. Universities spend ungodly amounts on things like recertification, advertising, internal busywork, fundraising, government requirements etc. Abstractly this stuff adds zero value for students, but good luck telling an auditor you have better things to do with your time. And internal politics is all about how someone changes things not how this pet project actually helps students.
- imgabe 11y ago> A better approach would be to offer comparable pay and status to professors who spend most of their time teaching, reserving reduced teaching loads for professors whose research continues to have significance and impact. I think the problem with this is that you have no idea up front which research is going to be significant and impactful and which isn't. If you knew what the outcome was going to be, it wouldn't be research, now would it?
- Retric 11y agoPeople optimize for what you measure. If you want numbers they will pump out numbers, if you want citations they will set up citation rings etc. The real solution is to realize research is best ignored. Don’t count it for anything in any way. And they people who stick with it will likely focus on actual important things.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWell, in keeping with Mr. Pearlstein's desire to identify things "universities should do" in a vaccuum of authority where neither of us can enact change through a dictate by fiat avenue, I'll take a crack at four even more aggressive and not-likely-to-happen scenarios, and I'm not even getting paid to write them! 1. Downsize course offerings in areas where graduates can not be reasonably expected to recoup the cost of a University education in the forseeable, full-time job market - such as journalism. 2. Perform genuine, rigorous auditing of participating in NCAA sports for cost-benefit analysis and completely shut down programs which do not recoup or actually cost money. 3. Become fiscal mentors to prospective and current students by engaging in hands-on financial counseling with respect to private loans and income earning potential. 4. Drastically reduce the number of Freshman and Sophomore students and aggressively recruit potential graduates through the Community College systems nationwide. I mean, there are a lot of ways to save money, and while I can enjoy comfy-armchair musing as much as the next guy, sometimes articles like this one just seem so out of touch.
- jdmichal 11y ago> Drastically reduce the number of Freshman and Sophomore students and aggressively recruit potential graduates through the Community College systems nationwide. Doing a 2-year stint at a community college is just about one of the most sane things a person can do. At the end, you still end up with a bachelor's degree from whatever university you finish at, indistinguishable from any other graduate. And you do it typically at a fraction of the cost. Oh, and often community colleges focus on teachers with industry experience, meaning that you're not learning about software engineering from a computer science academic that's never actually been a software engineer.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoDoing a 2-year stint at a community college is just about one of the most sane things a person can do. Really? I know how introductory courses are taught at the local community college, and there's the MIT/Berkeley/whatnot lectures online. It's a difference between day and night! Of course you can watch the Youtube lecture instead of the tripe they feed you at the c.c. but you do miss out on interaction with fellow students and professors. This means missing out on a lot.
- SneakerXZ 11y agoI always wonder when somebody proclaim they have best universities, what does it actually mean? Eg. methodology in this article http://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings-articles/world-university-rankings/qs-world-university-rankings-methodology http://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings-articles/... Basically it is all about reputation that is very subjective and if you are not good, the name will not help you or research that is nice if you want to do PhD otherwise it is not very useful for you. I would recommend people in US to study abroad. You might learn a new language and you will receive equally good education and it will be much cheaper for you.
- matrix 11y agoThe issue of administrative costs (e.g. IT) growing rapidly boils down to the fact that there are no economic forces that would otherwise enable the administrators to be held accountable for their spending. In the private sector, if you are responsible for a P&L, and "P" isn't a positive number, you'll eventually lose your job. In higher ed, there is no metric that similarly lays bare whether an administrator is effective or not. This allows spending to run rampant and weak managers to thrive, which just continues the cycle. If anybody figures out how align spending with outcomes in this sort of environment, they deserve a nobel prize in economics.
- fredgrott 11y agoan alternative.. Some of the Purdue campuses in Indiana have reduced their administrative cost by re-aligning and pairing two commuter campuses together with one administrative body..expected savings $500 to $1000 off of tuition costs per student.
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe only way to do it without swimming against the economic flow is to create some new universities not encumbered by all the academic cruft that accumulates over multiple decades. Any new business that can focus solely on the elements of what makes university education valuable in the first place, and can maintain that focus for enough time, will end up eating the old guard's lunches, turning out grad with 90% of the useful skills and 50% the advantageous social connections, at only 10% the cost. Those grads will go on to jobs that pay 75% as much, but their student loan payments will be 10% as burdensome. College-age kids are not quite so dumb as to never realize that they could get along just as well academically, at less cost, while living in a decrepit old dorms, capsule hotels, discreetly parked converted vans, or parents' basements. In short, existing universities can do nearly nothing to meaningfully cut their own costs. Their hands are tied by foundation requirements, tradition, alumni expectations, and countless boards and committees. Their budgets are so strictly controlled by vested interests who have built both careers and pensions on them that they can sooner fire an adjunct than to refrain from installing a bronze plaque dedicated to Someguy Alumni in the Inverted Aquatic Basketology building. Start 100 new universities from scratch, and let 90 of them fail. Repeat until tuition falls permanently.
- erbo 11y agoThe biggest thing that would help rein in costs would be the elimination of all the "free money," i.e. loans, that students can get to pay those costs. If students can't pay those costs, they won't. Universities will either then reduce their costs, or go bankrupt and be replaced by institutions that will. This could be accomplished with a couple of changes to current policy. First, remove the restriction that makes student loans nondischargeable in bankruptcy. Second, get the Federal government out of the business of providing student loans. With these changes, private institutions will only lend money for education if they have a reasonable expectation that the money will be paid back. That'll dry up the "free money" spigots. Back in the 1960's, it was possible for a student to pay for his education by flipping pizzas at night and over the summer, without having to take out loans. That's the standard we should be shooting for.
- VLM 11y agoIt'll likely be part of a cross generational compromise. So due to educational debt the kids can't buy their ancestors overpriced real estate or pay SS taxes sufficient to keep SS afloat. The solution is government education loan jubilee day paired with an increase in SS taxes such that the kids end up paying as much as before, but now their balance sheet is more mortgage positive. Meanwhile the old people keep running the SS ponzi for a couple more years.
- Joof 11y agoGive accreditation for MOOCs. Many are well designed (more so than community college and often regular college) and provide a far more social experience than showing up to class and not asking questions (which is the case 99% of the time).
- moyix 11y agoI thought that Daniel Drezner's rebuttal to this (also in the Washington Post) was pretty good: https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/11/30/four-tough-things-columnists-should-do-before-writing-about-universities/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/11/30/...
- alpineidyll3 11y agoThis is the same guy who was criticized by Greenwald for arguing bank bailouts were a good idea. (http://www.salon.com/2008/10/31/pearlstein_3/ http://www.salon.com/2008/10/31/pearlstein_3/) I am a professor. This man's ideas are totally naive. Universities and colleges are engaged in a cold war to avoid gaps in endowments, buildings and other metrics of prestige. Their students are willing to pay more for this prestige and so the cost goes up. It's simple as that. If universities that decided not to heavily invest in themselves were effective at generating that prestige, the cost wouldn't be going up. Only a fraction of the people at the university are there because it is a place of learning, and almost all the people are engaged in research. Many of this guy's ideas are worse than bad, they are poisonous.