7 ms·
Why the Economic Fates of America’s Cities Diverged
- powera 11y agoThis seems to ignore cost of living. A lot of the reason salaries are high in San Francisco is because rent is high, and rent is high because salaries are high. Just because people can make "more money" in San Francisco doesn't mean they'll be better off.
- ams6110 11y agoRent is high because housing is scarce. That does lead to higher salaries (because you can't attract employees if they can't afford housing) but the rent is not high just because salaries are high.
- Avshalom 11y agoRent is high because housing is scarce AND people can afford high rent. Like you say you can't get employees there if they can't afford it, but that also means that if no one could afford it there would be no demand at that price. Landlords will absolutely try to extract every last drop of economic surplus out of their properties.
- totalrobe 11y agoRent is not high just because of scarcity. It's high in North Virginia even there is plenty of new housing on the market - the problem is that developers are only building luxury apartments and trying to rent at above market prices. Most of these places are offering 3-4 months free up front because nobody is paying the obscene sticker prices for a 12 month lease. It's not just a local phenomenon - public REIT's are buying up affordable units nationwide and renting them out at >20% above market... http://www.multifamilyexecutive.com/business-finance/luxury-apartments-galore-at-what-cost_o http://www.multifamilyexecutive.com/business-finance/luxury-...
- exelius 11y agoRent is high because home-buying credit is scarce. Banks are still gun-shy about lending, so only people with stellar credit or who are borrowing a small percentage of their earning power can get home loans right now. Which has caused REITs and other PE organizations to come in and buy up real estate to fill the gap -- and REITs are not interested in dealing with "affordable" rental units and the social problems that often come along with them. So they market their buildings as "luxury" and attach a high price tag. This has led to a couple of side effects: a shortage of rental units (and the associated high rental prices), a shortage of qualified buyers (people aren't able to roll the equity from their starter house into a new home because they never bought the starter house), and an extreme shortage of new construction at the low end of the market (the only people who can even qualify to buy today are upper-middle class). We're still not out of the subprime quagmire yet. The rental market in the US was sized for a world where subprime mortgages existed -- and now that they largely don't, those people have to live somewhere. Regardless, "affordable" housing will not exist unless it is subsidized by the government. The private sector has no interest in renting to the low-income segment when the "up-market" segment is lower cost, higher margin and has significantly lower legal risk.
- sliverstorm 11y agoWell, if you assume everyone nationwide manages to save 10% of their income, and then everyone moves to Florida when they retire- San Franciscans will indeed be better off.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoExpecting anyone to do anything in their self-interest but stay alive is abysmal public policy and shows little understanding of history or human nature.
- mapt 11y ago"High cost of living" is a concept you get to use in personal decisionmaking, but it's not a concept you get to use in probing this causation, because it becomes tautological. High cost of living, where cost of living is mostly housing, is associated with high economic productivity combined with low housing stock. It cannot be used to normalize high salaries to some other abstract concept that says useful things about economic productivity, because it only co-occurs with high salaries. The article is asking why city A and city B became differently economically productive, not for excuses as to why one isn't technically rich or comparisons of disposable income. That's a different discussion.
- ghaff 11y agoAlthough it can be overstated, the real question (modulo the fact that, for geographic reasons, some cities and areas are better able to add housing stock than others) is why companies are willing to effectively channel large amounts of money to landlords and home sellers in certain areas of the country in order to be located there. I'm not sure the article makes an especially coherent argument on this particular point other than observing a trend toward more centralized industries.
- Aloha 11y agoI believe strongly that income increases have largely been to track to cost of living, in places where cost of living has remained flat, amazingly enough, incomes also remain flat. I'm also dubious of the negative effects of deregulation of the airlines and rail/trucking industries - because of the machinations of the ICC Railroads broadly almost ceased to be a going concern.
- strictnein 11y ago> "In 1966, the average per-capita income of greater Cedar Rapids, Iowa, was only $87 less than that of New York City and its suburbs" And that is a 5% difference? 25% difference? 55%? Is that number inflation adjusted? I hate stats like this. When they show up they make me really assume the rest of the article is junk as well.
- nostromo 11y agoTo give them some credit, they link to the source, so you can dig in all you like. Here, I've done it for you. 1966 average income: $3,962 - New York City area $3,875 - Cedar Rapids area So, 2% less.
- humanrebar 11y agoAdjusted for cost of living, Cedar Rapids sounds much better than NYC with those numbers.
- maldusiecle 11y agoExcept that literally the next paragraph has a bunch of percentage comparisons (as does the preceding paragraph). These aren't cherrypicked stats; the article cites a range of comparisons to create a broad, meaningful picture of the situation. But yes, by all means, dismiss a long and carefully researched article because it irks you the way a single figure is cited.
- strictnein 11y agoSo then we agree that they should have also provided a percentage along side the (meaningless without context) absolute value. But my point was about articles in general that do these sort of absolute value comparisons without providing any context, which is what I wrote.
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> When they show up they make me really assume the rest of the article is junk as well. Sounds like you stopped reading at the first page and didn't bother to check the rest.
- jonesb6 11y agoI cannot recommend the book Boomerang by Michael Lewis enough. He examines what several countries (Greece, Ireland, Iceland, Germany, the United States) did between 2000-2012 when they were allowed to barrow vast sums of money with little oversight. He's a great narrator and it's an overall insightful book. Towards the end of the book he examines what a number of American cities did when they were allowed to barrow vast sums of money with little oversight. Thumming through it now he covers Vallejo and San Jose. TLDR would be they bankrupted themselves with pensions and tax cuts. Oh and it's a light read too. And it has an Arnold Schwarzenegger interview.
- throwaway_xx9 11y agoThe story goes much deeper than that. The public sector unions across California circulated a letter in each municipality that they would only support candidates willing to approve 8% guaranteed annual pension returns. And they got it. As a result, California cities are all bankrupt today. FYI: San Jose is bad, but ironically wealthy Palo Alto has one of the worst budgets.
- exelius 11y agoI dunno, when I look at migration data over the long term in the US, a few things stand out to me: 1. Weather is a huuuuuge factor. The large, growing population centers in the US are in warm or mild climates. Nobody wants to live in Buffalo or Minneapolis unless you're from there. 2. Location is far less important to the industries that generate the majority of value today. A lot of industrial jobs (and cities) sprung up in the midwest in the early part of the 20th century thanks to its proximity to raw materials (iron ore, coal, etc) and easily navigable waterways. That's not as important to the economy as a whole anymore, so companies have little reason to start (aka create jobs) in locations that are otherwise undesirable. 3. Given that there are fewer job opportunities that are reliant on proximity to natural resources, and that more of the new job opportunities will be located in cities with milder climates, it's no wonder that rust belt cities are bleeding people. Would you start a new business in Buffalo? Or would you just go to Chicago, New York or Philadelphia instead?
- rm_-rf_slash 11y ago>Would you start a new business in Buffalo? It doesn't take much capital to turn a 19th century mansion into an incubator/hacker house. Sure the weather and the Bills suck but inside you'll find a welcoming community spirit at a price you can start a business and raise a family at. Buffalo has also been experiencing a boom in green tech investment (http://mobile.buffalonews.com/?articleRedirect=1&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.buffalonews.com%2Fcity-region%2Fbuffalos-future-looks-very-green-with-states-investment-in-high-tech-facilities-20131121 http://mobile.buffalonews.com/?articleRedirect=1&url=http%3A...) As for Upstate NY in general, I think it's a great place to start a business. At the end of the day, most businessss can be run anywhere (hence the boom in remote work), and, again, putting aside the biblically shitty weather, you have an affordable region with plenty of fresh water and local farms, and isn't at risk for rising tides (NY,FL,CA), earthquakes (Cascadia,CA), droughts (CA, southwest, Midwest when the aquifer runs dry), name it. This is a great region to start a family, and at the end of the day, your best employees are the ones tied to your office and location, not mercenary college grads shopping around every couple years for a raise. In 100 years, Upstate NY can exist without desalinated/pumped life support. Not so sure about the rest...
- Eiriksmal 11y agoThis was an excellent, thought-provoking piece. Anyone have some book recommendations for further examinations of how the rise of the corporation has affected America?
- Ologn 11y ago› Today, the commuter-rail system that once made it comparatively easy to live in suburban New Jersey and work in Manhattan is falling apart, and commutes from other New York suburbs, whether by road or rail, are also becoming unworkable. Increasingly, this means that only the very rich can still afford to work in Manhattan, much less live there I don't find this to be true. New York City subways are better now than they were in the 1970s. Public transportation into Manhattan has not changed much in the past decades, although the prices have risen. There are plenty of places to live for working class people with decent commutes to Manhattan. I know plenty of people at startups who lived in Manhattan - engineers could live by themselves, others needed roommates. You're not going to live on 5th Avenue, of course. I live in the suburbs so my apartment has some space, not due to expense - I could rent a smaller Manhattan apartment for the same price.
- hyperion2010 11y ago> They did so primarily by making the tech industry much less about engineering and much more about lawyering and deal making. This is my take home for everything. Lawyers are the ones in congress. Who ultimately benefits from the arrangements we have now? Lawyers and pretty much no one else. Simplistic? Yes. However, if you play the 'follow the money' game I'm not sure who else benefits, because I'm fairly certain it isn't the landlords.
- Periodic 11y agoWhat really stood out to me was the idea that the current climate of shooting for an acquisition as a primary exit strategy is due to the threat of the entrenched goliaths of the industry and the concentration of power they have in terms of markets and patents. I had never linked that trend to anti-competitiveness in the market because the market looks so competitive based on how many companies are starting and getting funded.