5 ms·
The root cause here is the amount of money required to be elected. Get rid of the need for money and you get rid of the corruption. I personally like the idea
by danieltillett 11y ago
The root cause here is the amount of money required to be elected. Get rid of the need for money and you get rid of the corruption.
I personally like the idea of increasing the number of members of congress so each member only represents around 25,000 people like they did 200 years ago. If your electorate only had 25,000 voters you would not need much money (nor staff) to get elected.
- desdiv 11y ago318,000,000 ÷ 25,000 = 12720 That's a little excessive, don't you think?
- danieltillett 11y agoWell it is voters not citizens so the number is a little less than this, but no I don't think it is excessive. The current system only works because each member of congress has a huge staff - about one for every 25,000 voters. If you increase the number of members of congress then you get rid of the staff. Of course you will have a problem fitting everyone into the capital building, but with technology there is no need for everyone to be in the same location at the same time. We need to think of innovative solutions to fighting corruption, not just hoping that things will get better if we wish hard enough.
- harryh 11y agoThat assumes that all the people that get elected are capable of doing all the things that staff currently does. I don't think that's a good assumption.
- danieltillett 11y agoI would certainly hope the people elected are not capable of doing many of the things that the staff currently do - say like soliciting bribes (sorry "donations"). If there is a need for certain skills then there is no reason that this could not be handled by a pool of experts working for congress - say in the same way the library of congress works now.
- dccoolgai 11y agoIt is not the root cause. Money would mean nothing if the idiots sitting on the other end of the ad the money paid for bothered to form their own opinion or research something. Politicians need money because ads cost money. They run vapid attack ads, because vapid attack ads work. Vapid attack ads work, because we are stupid and lazy. Worked in politics for many years: trust me. Money is not the root cause. We are.
- jMyles 11y agoI think you are saying the same thing. The commenter to whom you are responding didn't say that money is the root cause, but that the amount of money required to win is the root cause. And the reason that it costs this amount of money, as you point out, is that attack ads (inter alia) are often successful.
- danieltillett 11y agoExactly right. It is the scale of money required to get elected that is the issue. When you have districts with upwards of a million people then they only way you can have any contact with any voter within that district is via adverting. A 15 second ad is not a good way to get across a complex idea, hence we end up with campaigns built around personal attacks and dog whistles. Get the electorate down to the size where each politician knows the majority of their electorate personally, where you can call up your representative and talk to them rather than some staffer, and where public meetings can work, and then you will change the whole dynamic of politics. It won’t be perfect, but it should be more resistant to corruption as the root cause will be removed.
- jMyles 11y agoAlthough, anybody who has been involved in municipal or campus politics can attest that, at least occasionally, oversimplification and attack ads work in those markets as well. All things considered though, I agree with you. One other thing to overcome though, is gerrymandering. If we have 10x-100x the number of house districts, the gerrymandering algorithms will have a field day unless we take action to stop them in practice first.
- such_a_casual 11y agoThere are huge problems with that idea. California represents 10% of the population. Good luck convincing the other 49 states to give up that much power. Another huge problem with that idea is that congress is not held accountable for their decisions by the public. In my opinion, this is because they are able to split the blame 100 different ways in the senate and 435 different ways in the house, making no one responsible for any given decision. Your suggestion makes this problem much, much worse and guarantees more bureaucracy.
- danieltillett 11y agoCalifornia would still have 10% of the representatives, they would just have many more like everyone else. There would be no power shift from state to state. So you are saying the problem is no one is held accountable now, but the problem will be worse with smaller districts because then no one will be held accountable? I think having smaller electorates where you can get elected by knowing your constituents personally rather than via advertising and attack ads would be an improvement.
- such_a_casual 11y agoThe second part is just my own bullshit, but yes. I think that we want to be able to point to someone and say that it's their fault. I think that's why we don't care who our representatives are. We don't see them as being directly responsible for what happens. Even if I'm wrong, more representatives will mean more bureaucracy, which means slower governing.
- danieltillett 11y agoIf you could personally call up and speak to your representative and they had to speak to you in person to get elected then I think you would be happier. You could at least hold them responsible for their actions and your vote would count much more for them than it does now. I don’t see how having more representatives will increase bureaucracy. We would basically shift from having one representative with 19 staff to having 20 representatives with no staff. The net cost should be zero.
- pandaman 11y agoThis is a very naive view. Ancient kings were not elected yet were beholden to money just as much as modern politicians. The fundamental issue is that at the end any government runs on people with weapons who require money to brandish these weapons (otherwise they will have to do something else including but not limited to brandishing for their own interest or leaving the whole brandishing business for more productive endeavors). For a short while you can make the people with weapons work for free with an ideology. But this won't last forever and eventually you will either have to pay them or forget about your government (see USSR vs PRC to see how both ways work).