4 ms·
One problem, which the article discusses just after the parts you quoted, is that there’s a huge amount of lobbying of and money flowing to politicians willing
by jacobolus 11y ago
One problem, which the article discusses just after the parts you quoted, is that there’s a huge amount of lobbying of and money flowing to politicians willing to thwart reform efforts. Closing tax loopholes would be easier if we also had publicly financed elections or stricter limits on campaign contributions, and if the media wasn’t a consolidated corporate cartel.
> “[...] Many influential Republicans, already uncomfortable about the Peru reforms, are expected to use committee hearings to launch an attack on the European commission’s ongoing state aid investigations into suspected sweetheart tax deals granted by Ireland, the Netherlands and Luxembourg to, respectively, Apple, Starbucks and Amazon. ¶Well-resourced rightwing lobbyists are agitating in Washington for a final push against the G20 tax reforms. [...]”
There’s a feedback loop involved between corporations saving billions in taxes -> donations of some portion of that to politicians willing to play along (and offer to give them board seats and high-paid speaking gigs after they leave office, etc. Just look e.g. Bill Clinton’s post-officeholding career.). Same story with industries that receive large government contracts, or which are under heavy regulation. In every case, there’s big money to be made in helping corporate interests at the public’s expense.
Candidates running for public office have great incentive to talk about how they want to close tax loopholes, etc., but once they are elected, the only thing holding them to those promises is personal integrity, and none of the US presidents since Jimmy Carter have been able to face down that kind of temptation. The pressure might be even greater for Congress, as smaller amounts of money directed at unseating particular troublesome Reps goes further, and there’s less direct public attention on each one.
- danieltillett 11y agoThe root cause here is the amount of money required to be elected. Get rid of the need for money and you get rid of the corruption. I personally like the idea of increasing the number of members of congress so each member only represents around 25,000 people like they did 200 years ago. If your electorate only had 25,000 voters you would not need much money (nor staff) to get elected.
- desdiv 11y ago318,000,000 ÷ 25,000 = 12720 That's a little excessive, don't you think?
- danieltillett 11y agoWell it is voters not citizens so the number is a little less than this, but no I don't think it is excessive. The current system only works because each member of congress has a huge staff - about one for every 25,000 voters. If you increase the number of members of congress then you get rid of the staff. Of course you will have a problem fitting everyone into the capital building, but with technology there is no need for everyone to be in the same location at the same time. We need to think of innovative solutions to fighting corruption, not just hoping that things will get better if we wish hard enough.
- harryh 11y agoThat assumes that all the people that get elected are capable of doing all the things that staff currently does. I don't think that's a good assumption.
- danieltillett 11y agoI would certainly hope the people elected are not capable of doing many of the things that the staff currently do - say like soliciting bribes (sorry "donations"). If there is a need for certain skills then there is no reason that this could not be handled by a pool of experts working for congress - say in the same way the library of congress works now.
- dccoolgai 11y agoIt is not the root cause. Money would mean nothing if the idiots sitting on the other end of the ad the money paid for bothered to form their own opinion or research something. Politicians need money because ads cost money. They run vapid attack ads, because vapid attack ads work. Vapid attack ads work, because we are stupid and lazy. Worked in politics for many years: trust me. Money is not the root cause. We are.
- brandonmenc 11y ago> there’s a huge amount of lobbying of and money flowing to politicians willing to thwart reform efforts I suspect all these companies would get behind a low, flat tax. That's hard to lobby for. Strategically, it makes more sense to lobby for a special tax break or loophole and let everyone else fend for themselves. All of this lobbying could disappear if every country adopted flat, nearly equal rates.
- enraged_camel 11y agoFor the record, flat tax is hugely regressive. It hurts the poor more than the rich. The reason is the marginal utility of money. With a flat tax of 20%, someone making 80k would pay 16k, and someone making 30k would pay 6k. Sounds good on the surface, except losing 6k hurts the second person far more than losing 16k hurts the second person. There are ways of simplifying the tax code while keeping it progressive. The bracket system we have for income taxation is good. They just need to close loopholes, eliminate a lot of deductions and tax capital gains at the same rate as regular income.
- harryh 11y agoThis is a discussion of corporate taxes not individual income taxes. Much of your comment is not germane.
- enraged_camel 11y agoIt also applies to corporations. Flat tax hurts smaller/less profitable corporations more than more than bigger/more profitable ones.