5 ms·
> “For too long, powerful corporations have exploited loopholes that allow them to hide earnings abroad to lower their taxes,” said Democratic presidential cand
by ars 11y ago
> “For too long, powerful corporations have exploited loopholes that allow them to hide earnings abroad to lower their taxes,” said Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton. “Now Pfizer is trying to reduce its tax bill even further.”
You don't like the loopholes? Close them. Do not blame people for using every single option they are given.
The right thing to do is lower the tax rate and remove the loopholes. The total tax paid could stay the same, but the distribution would be different.
The current system is unfair, you need to pay a lot of money to work out these complicated scenarios, this hurts smaller businesses, and costs a lot of money to implement.
"Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which will best pay the Treasury; there is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes." - Gregory v. Helvering, 69 F.2d 809, 810 (2d Cir. 1934)
"Over and over again courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging one's affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everybody does so, rich or poor; and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands: taxes are enforced exactions, not voluntary contributions. To demand more in the name of morals is mere cant." - Commissioner v. Newman, 159 F.2d 848, 851 (2d Cir. 1947) - dissenting opinion
- jacobolus 11y agoOne problem, which the article discusses just after the parts you quoted, is that there’s a huge amount of lobbying of and money flowing to politicians willing to thwart reform efforts. Closing tax loopholes would be easier if we also had publicly financed elections or stricter limits on campaign contributions, and if the media wasn’t a consolidated corporate cartel. > “[...] Many influential Republicans, already uncomfortable about the Peru reforms, are expected to use committee hearings to launch an attack on the European commission’s ongoing state aid investigations into suspected sweetheart tax deals granted by Ireland, the Netherlands and Luxembourg to, respectively, Apple, Starbucks and Amazon. ¶Well-resourced rightwing lobbyists are agitating in Washington for a final push against the G20 tax reforms. [...]” There’s a feedback loop involved between corporations saving billions in taxes -> donations of some portion of that to politicians willing to play along (and offer to give them board seats and high-paid speaking gigs after they leave office, etc. Just look e.g. Bill Clinton’s post-officeholding career.). Same story with industries that receive large government contracts, or which are under heavy regulation. In every case, there’s big money to be made in helping corporate interests at the public’s expense. Candidates running for public office have great incentive to talk about how they want to close tax loopholes, etc., but once they are elected, the only thing holding them to those promises is personal integrity, and none of the US presidents since Jimmy Carter have been able to face down that kind of temptation. The pressure might be even greater for Congress, as smaller amounts of money directed at unseating particular troublesome Reps goes further, and there’s less direct public attention on each one.
- danieltillett 11y agoThe root cause here is the amount of money required to be elected. Get rid of the need for money and you get rid of the corruption. I personally like the idea of increasing the number of members of congress so each member only represents around 25,000 people like they did 200 years ago. If your electorate only had 25,000 voters you would not need much money (nor staff) to get elected.
- desdiv 11y ago318,000,000 ÷ 25,000 = 12720 That's a little excessive, don't you think?
- danieltillett 11y agoWell it is voters not citizens so the number is a little less than this, but no I don't think it is excessive. The current system only works because each member of congress has a huge staff - about one for every 25,000 voters. If you increase the number of members of congress then you get rid of the staff. Of course you will have a problem fitting everyone into the capital building, but with technology there is no need for everyone to be in the same location at the same time. We need to think of innovative solutions to fighting corruption, not just hoping that things will get better if we wish hard enough.
- harryh 11y agoThat assumes that all the people that get elected are capable of doing all the things that staff currently does. I don't think that's a good assumption.
- danieltillett 11y agoI would certainly hope the people elected are not capable of doing many of the things that the staff currently do - say like soliciting bribes (sorry "donations"). If there is a need for certain skills then there is no reason that this could not be handled by a pool of experts working for congress - say in the same way the library of congress works now.
- danieltillett 11y agoI would be a lot more comfortable with this approach if the powerful corporation had not bribed the current system into existence. Yes the best solution would be to lower rates and reduce loopholes, but until the corruption that allowed the current tax system to arise is addressed all you will end up with a lower rate and the same number of loopholes.
- rayiner 11y agoWhat exactly is the "loophole" here, and how could small companies take advantage of it?
- deoptimo 11y agoThe loophole is setting up a multi-national structure to implement the base erosion and profit-shifting strategies discussed here: https://www.oecd.org/tax/aggressive/beps-2015-final-reports.htm https://www.oecd.org/tax/aggressive/beps-2015-final-reports....
- rayiner 11y agoHow is that a "loophole." Multi-national structures seem like a necessary facet of the tax code. And the listed strategies don't seem to take advantage of obscure provisions, but basic mechanics of the tax system: deduction of costs from gross revenues, etc.
- deoptimo 11y agoTake a closer look at the sections on hybrid entities, treaty shopping, and transfer pricing. There are loopholes wide enough to let tanker ships pass.
- joeblow99 11y ago"loophole" is a word for "a completely legal tax maneuver I don't like"
- rhino369 11y agoWorse, it's often a work for "a completely legal tax provision I don't understand."
- tosseraccount 11y agoPoliticians complain ... but ... c'mon, they have had plenty of opportunity to fix things. Still do.
- georgemcbay 11y ago"You don't like the loopholes? Close them." The problem is the loopholes extend way beyond the tax code into the election system, specifically campaign finance and things like the Citizen's United ruling and into things like the weakening of the media ownership rules which bring us a level deeper into the morass with a largely uninformed (and often just plain scared) electorate. Thus we have mostly shitty bought-off politicians (on both sides) representing "us", but mostly really representing their donors who are big business. The current system is unfair by design, as much as big corporations complain about it these issues (like taxes too high, but with plenty of loop-holes) serve as a giant moat for them to avoid the establishment of any serious competition because you have to hit a certain scale before you start to worry about things like how to hide tens of billions of dollars offshore. We are honestly probably way beyond really fixing this stuff at this point, no matter how easy it is to say "Well just fix it" or "just close the loopholes". America's entire large-corporation/government system needs something like a defrag and full reinstall, but there's basically no way to do that while keeping things running.
- ageek123 11y agoTax loopholes existed long before Citizens United and the end of the Fairness Doctrine. In fact there were more tax loopholes in the 1970s and 1980s than today.
- hwstar 11y agoAgreed. As long as private money does the nominating of our political candidates, then the piper (loopholes) will need to be paid. If we were to switch to government funded elections, then there would be no pressure on the legislature to return the favour once they are elected. The only snag I see with publically funded campaigns is determining who qualifies for the public funding.
- guelo 11y ago> You don't like the loopholes? Close them. Do not blame people for using every single option they are given. You say that as if it's not the corporation's lobbyists that create and defend the loopholes.
- newman314 11y agoI've said it before and will say it again, what I take issue with is that people don't have access to the same loopholes as corporations do. It's surprising that there isn't a bigger uproar over the fact that corporations pay a lower effective tax rate than people do.
- ars 11y ago> It's surprising that there isn't a bigger uproar over the fact that corporations pay a lower effective tax rate than people do. Why? At the end of the day a person will make the profit, every corporation is owned by someone. So that person should pay the tax, not the corporation. The only issue is the ability of corporations to defer the tax paid by their owners endlessly. If you changed that, you could get rid of corporate tax entirely.
- Magi604 11y agoGreat quotes there at the end of your post. I've always shook my head at how people get mad at other people (individuals/corporations) for doing smart things with their money.